Scummies Nomination Thread 2017

[Alisae]

VOTE: Good Play
seems legit

[Lycanfire]

Guys remember to nominate good play when you see it!

Doing nothing until EoY and maybe remembering to nom in December is fine too

[Alisae]

atleast you're nominating things.

[Aristophanes]

atleast you're nominating things.

I meant to like months ago... j may blitz yhia or forgrt.

[Alisae]

atleast you're nominating things.

I meant to like months ago... j may blitz yhia or forgrt.

hmmmmmm
I wonder what intriguing language you're speaking.

[Kaede Akamatsu]

I nominated

Danganropa V3 uPick

for

GOTY

mostly because the setup (except for a few things), flavour, moderation quality, and play from both town and me (because I kinda solo hero'd and didn't have partners since they were both guiltied by D3, one of which was a janitor and didn't even send a single action in after telling them over and over) was good, and the game was enjoyable to play.

When it comes to the setup itself, its kinda perfect in that it basicly takes us all the way back to what mafia on ms is, dayplay. It was a setup that rewarded dayplay over nightplay by far. And as a result, this is what you get, a fun, intense F5 where its anyones game (even with wolves being guiltied).

Not to mention the role pms, even though the templates are taken and modified from someone else, are still cool to look at

+1

[Creature]

Still think SU2 was the best game.

It was pretty enjoyable to play, despite the hyperposting players were actually playing and there weren't many inactivity problems.

[Alisae]

I can say the same thing for DRv3

[Varsoon]

...I, uh, still think SU2 was the best game, too.
I will contend that FFT Mafia has the best flavor/design of any game of mafia ever run anywhere, but that's maybe because making those rolecards took more time than any rolecard process rightfully should.

[Ginngie]

FFT mafia?

[Alisae]

Final Fantasy Tactics

[Alisae]

...I, uh, still think SU2 was the best game, too.
I will contend that FFT Mafia has the best flavor/design of any game of mafia ever run anywhere, but that's maybe because making those rolecards took more time than any rolecard process rightfully should.

I want to make role pms like that

[Ginngie]

dude what the shit

those are nuts

[Alisae]

Final Fantasy Tactics: The game that no one knows Varsoon modded but he actually did

[SleepyKrew]

will varsoon ever stop sucking his own dick in these threads?

[KidAmn]

will varsoon ever stop sucking his own dick in these threads?

Who shat in your cornflakes this morning

[Alisae]

will varsoon ever stop sucking his own dick in these threads?

You don't even play games.
Well except for two of them
but you didn't play those either

[Varsoon]

will varsoon ever stop sucking his own dick in these threads?

Excuse me, it's called 'blowing my own horn'
Also, I'm pretty sure my spine is stuck like this now.

[nancy]

Can we not expend effort on fostering dislike for each other please it's not helpful we all have feelings here.

[Varsoon]

I love you all
but I love myself the most.
Except when we're in a game of mafia, then I hate everyone and I hate myself the most. Unless I'm winning.

[Alisae]

but I love myself the most.

Well I mean selfcare is pretty important <3

[Ginngie]

I love myself

[Alisae]

Got till the 31st to nom things!

[Ellibereth]

I nominated

Chara

for

Rising Star

. Nomination text copied in full below.

----------------------------------------

Note: Chara used to play under the account Not Chara and uses the latter account in some of the cited games.

I am nominating Chara because of their townplay. I have little experience with their scumplay. However, I feel like the following positive sides of their townplay are 1) the most important elements of good townplay and 2) increasingly rare among players on site.

Chara is obvtown in the vast majority of their town games and is almost never a distraction to the town solving-process. They are, consequently, never mislynched. They are often an integral part of the town-solving block. Their reads are sufficiently good to win the game and they are occasionally the one pushing correct lynches. Even when they are wrong, they don't cause the town to implode on itself.

Citations:

Inception Mafia: viewtopic.php?f=94&t=71602. They were obvtown. They were an integral part of the town block, keeping town together and organizing complex mechanics. Please note that this game was played across multiple threads. You can find them by looking through the topics of the mod.

DBZ Mafia: viewtopic.php?f=54&t=71107. They were also obvtown. Their reads were average, but they were good enough that when working with the rest of the town, they got the win.

Beneath the Mask: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=73578. They were one of the few obvtowns through positive play in a very chaotic and unstable town. They were not a distraction at all unlike the vast majority of the game. Their read accuracy didn't matter because they sheeped their way to a crushing town victory.

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment. Reads were sufficiently good to win a close game in the end.

[Alisae]

I have little experience with their scumplay.

Its actually kinda terrible.