Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[hasdgfas]

what crap?

[curiouskarmadog]

what crap?

your whole existence in this game. Your two word “PR”...your convenient fake claims, your stalling and complete avoidance to answer questions which you now try to back up with “twas joke”…why did I have to ask you that question 3 times before you answered? And what was funny about asking for a consensus? If we do not lynch Has today, we deserve to lose.

[hasdgfas]

outside reference

[curiouskarmadog]

outside reference

and who was this outside reference directed too? Meaning who would get it?

[Thesp]

Official D4 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (Mr_Gnome_It_All)

curiouskarmadog - 4

(hasdgfas, Beep! Beep!, Mathcam, Battle Mage)

hasdgfas - 1

(curiouskarmadog)

Battle Mage - 1

(Iammars)

Not Voting - 5

(AmeliaSlay, Holy, Mastermind of Sin, Mr_Gnome_It_All, petroleumjelly)

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

[Iammars]

lol you sure thats not coz i suggested the Mod kick you out of the game?

No, that's not the reason. Actually, I thank everyone for being patient with me in this game. Things aren't going well IRL, but this has been a really interesting game that I still want to be a part of.

FoS Iammars..

Why exactly do you feel that BM is a better vote than Has or myself?

BM hasn't really been feeling great with me all game, which is slightly unusual, but that last post just flipped the trigger. It is impossible for anyone to be overdefensive.

[mathcam]

CKD:

Finally, since you're apparently claiming that the first step in my argument is the faulty one, let me probe deeper -- Why didn't you deny that you targeted Pooky? Why did you phrase that one quote the way you did?

Cam

[curiouskarmadog]

I did deny I targetted pooky...thus the vote right after Has said I claimed him...what part of "he is lying" are you defending?

[Beep! Beep!]

Amen!

I believe hasgfas, I don't believe CKD, can we lynch him please?

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

Of course we

can

lynch him. That is the idea of the game after all.

The real question is, do we do it now and move on to night, hoping that there is a next day and that someone will have some info to go on, or do we use the rest of the time we have until deadline trying to get a handle on who else might be scum?

[Mizzy]

Oh god, please don't head to night yet...I have so much more to read yet that I swear I'm never going to catch up.

[Battle Mage]

FoS Iammars..

Why exactly do you feel that BM is a better vote than Has or myself?

BM hasn't really been feeling great with me all game, which is slightly unusual, but that last post just flipped the trigger. It is impossible for anyone to be overdefensive.

Wtf are you on about? Of course its possible to be over-defensive. -.-

And your meta is a lie btw. As far as i recall, we have only played 1 game together recently, and in that, you felt suspicious of me if i recall correctly...

BM

[curiouskarmadog]

there is no way we are going to win, we are too populated with fools. THINK ABOUT IT....I hope to God we are not at lylo....if you get another day after you idiots mislynch please, vig HAS, then lynch Beep..she is so obviously scum it hurts....Also Beep (dgb) I am not sure how you keep getting towns to mislynch me but you obviously are a better player...think maybe my next game I will push shitty cases with no logic, make up scoring systems from no where, and just be as anti-town as possible...seems to work for you...

yes people, SCUM CAN PLAY THIS BADLY!!!!! I have seen her do it once.

[hasdgfas]

if

mislynch

[curiouskarmadog]

if

mislynch

why is it "if" Has? I thought you want everyone to think you think i am scum?

[hasdgfas]

1662 response

[Battle Mage]

ive heard what CKD has to say, and i still see no alternative to his lynch today.
no hard feelings,

BM

[mathcam]

Here's what you said, ckd:

what exactly did you do, track pooky or track me?

all you have is two words and you can even get those straight...nice slip up fake claim

vote Has,

You did not deny having targeted Pooky. In fact, you seem to leave it deliberately vague as to whether or not it was possible that he did in fact track you before you committed to a claim one way or another. As I've mentioned before, I just don't see that first line being phrased like that coming from someone who had actually targeted someone else -- I can see it being a somewhat rhetorical question, but it just seems like the "track me" option wouldn't even be part of the equation from that point of view.

In fact, another thought just occurred to me -- if Has were a mafia tracker attempting to frame you, why wouldn't he have just revealed that you targeted RW last night, who also died? In fact, that seems pretty conclusive to me. If Has is trying to frame CKD, he's scum just making it up, as opposed to being a mafia tracker.

Cam

[Iammars]

FoS Iammars..

Why exactly do you feel that BM is a better vote than Has or myself?

BM hasn't really been feeling great with me all game, which is slightly unusual, but that last post just flipped the trigger. It is impossible for anyone to be overdefensive.

Wtf are you on about? Of course its possible to be over-defensive. -.-

And your meta is a lie btw. As far as i recall, we have only played 1 game together recently, and in that, you felt suspicious of me if i recall correctly...

BM

A town member has the right to be as defensive as he wants. He knows he's town, so he wants to prevent his lynch as much as possible. Therefore, you can't fault overdefensiveness.

And I read a lot of other games. I develop metas based on games I'm not in.

[curiouskarmadog]

Here's what you said, ckd:

what exactly did you do, track pooky or track me?

all you have is two words and you can even get those straight...nice slip up fake claim

vote Has,

You did not deny having targeted Pooky. In fact, you seem to leave it deliberately vague as to whether or not it was possible that he did in fact track you before you committed to a claim one way or another. As I've mentioned before, I just don't see that first line being phrased like that coming from someone who had actually targeted someone else -- I can see it being a somewhat rhetorical question, but it just seems like the "track me" option wouldn't even be part of the equation from that point of view.

In fact, another thought just occurred to me -- if Has were a mafia tracker attempting to frame you, why wouldn't he have just revealed that you targeted RW last night, who also died? In fact, that seems pretty conclusive to me. If Has is trying to frame CKD, he's scum just making it up, as opposed to being a mafia tracker.

Cam

now you are really strectching...you KNOW EXACTLY what I was saying when I asked Has that...he claimed he tracked pooky, then Beep asked him what exactly he meant THEN he said he tracked me....I was calling him out on his fakeclaim..

BM, there is an alternative..lynch Has...I am telling you he is lying..if you lynch him and he turn out town, please by all means (vig) me.....

[curiouskarmadog]

ugh, I am tired of arguing with this town...you deserve to lose..

unvote Has, vote CKD

thats is negative one kids...lets see which scum jumps in and hammers me

[mathcam]

Well, that's completely unproductive.

Unvote: CKD.

.

Yes, CKD, I even mentioned that I realized your question was rhetorical, but I still think it looks more like a post by someone who hasn't made up their mind what to do yet.

I'm also beginning to wonder if ckd's recent rant is motivated by the fact that I said that PJ's rant made him look more pro-town. If ckd does come up scum, I might have to retract that line on PJ.

Cam

[hasdgfas]

1669 wrong.

[Mastermind of Sin]

uhhh. computer dead, using desktop, but I have to spend time fixing it tomorrow and this game will take time to catch up on. ugh, be patient please.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

He didn't say he tracked Pooky, he said Tracked :arrow: Pooky (Tracked

TO

Pooky) How do you not pick that up?