Penalty Box Mafia - Eagles. Game over. Scum wins (0-1)

[Capricious]

yes, but everything is a percentage, he's not 100%, I guess, he could be scum deciding to tell us what scum can do when he could've made us make suboptimal moves.

[Primate]

Hullo Cap. Diggin' the enthusiasm. You can be goal today.

Also, so people are aware of my lineup, Caps in goal, we have a mos/shanba shuffle, I don't think we have a third right forward, but I'm going to put panzer up there anyway cause hell why not. Much as I appreciate you trying, don't presently believe it's possible to figure out alignments from posting.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I'm betting panzer is the left forward, so putting him at right forward shouldn't be *too* bad.

[Shanba]

Much as I appreciate you trying, don't presently believe it's possible to figure out alignments from posting.

Eh? I thought we'd simply agreed that it was impossible to learn anything from the first lot of pages, not that anything written after the error should be discounted.

[Primate]

Much as I appreciate you trying, don't presently believe it's possible to figure out alignments from posting.

Eh? I thought we'd simply agreed that it was impossible to learn anything from the first lot of pages, not that anything written after the error should be discounted.

Maybe in the future it will be. Don't reckon it is atm.

[Foolster41]

Who is the other person to be replaced? I have a potental backup, but I'd like to do a prod and wait about 3 days before I actually replace.

[Mastermind of Sin]

@Foolster: Panzerjager requested replacement from you about 4 months ago. He recently posted in this thread again (to remind you that he asked for replacement, even) because I actually prodded him to post, which proves that you didn't even

prod

him in the last 4 months. Can you please just replace him and forgo the three days? He's not missing, he just doesn't want to be in this game.

[Mastermind of Sin]

From the other thread:

If we go into a tie-breaker, I think my poison power becomes more useful because it gives us 2 lynches in 1 day. The other team hasn't used their poison power either, so they can employ the same tactic if we go into a tie-breaker.

Whoever has this power should claim it. I just hope they didn't become scum in the re-shuffling of that alignment.

[Foolster41]

Oh. ok. sorry. I wanted to be sure. Replacing now.

[Lowell]

I too would like to see this power claimed.

Is it violating the spirit of the rules if we ask MoS whether he had any special powers as scum?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Primate already asked that.

Out of town until Wednesday.

[ZeekLTK]

I'm replacing panzer apparently.

If panzer hasn't claimed yet - I am a FW Left Wing.

Put me in coach, we need goals!

[ZeekLTK]

Well, from what I gather these were claimed positions:

Goalie: Capricious
Right Defence: Shanba/MoS
Left Defence: Flameaxe
Center: TVZ/Jdodge
Right Forward: None
Left Forward: Lowell/ZeekLTK

Goalies: Farside22, swetapantsninja
Centers: Hackerhuck
Right Defense: ckillor, hasdfgas
Right Forward: Hjallti, isuquinndog
Left Defense: Lloyd, JordanA24
Left Forward: ThAdmiral, Iammars

And these were the lineups:

Scum

Correct position

Similar position (offense or defense)

Similar side (right or left)

Wrong position & side

Day 1

Hawks' possession = Hawks Score

--------------

Creampuffeater

--------------
---------

Flameaxe

---------

Oman

-----------
--

TheVenerableZorg

---

MoS

---

Shanba

--


------

Rob

-----

N9V

------

JordanA24

--------
--------

YogurtBandit

---------

Aimee

-------
-----------------------

IH

---------------------

Day 2

Eagles' possession = Shot Saved

------------------

Lowell

----------------------
---------

ZeekLTK

--------

TVZ

-----------------
------

Shanba

------

CPE

------

Jdodge

-------

-------

Hjallti

-----

Unright

------

ckillor

---------
---------

hasdgfas

-------

ThAdmiral

--------
-----------------------

IH

------------------------

Day 3

Hawks' possession = Miss Wide

------------------

Lowell

----------------------
---------

ZeekLTK

--------

TVZ

-----------------
------

Shanba

------

CPE

------

Jdodge

-------

---

Iammars

---

HackerHuck

------

hjallti

----
-------------

Lloyd

----------

hasdgfas

--------
-------------------

farside22

------------------

Day 4

Eagles' possession = Miss Wide

------------------

Lowell

----------------------
---------

ZeekLTK

--------

TVZ

-----------------
------

Shanba

------

CPE

------

Jdodge

-------

---

ThAdmiral

---

HackerHuck

------

hjallti

----
-------------

Lloyd

----------

hasdgfas

--------
---------------------

TSPN

----------------------


-------

I didn't see any change in lineups since Day 2 so I assume we used the same one for 3 and 4. If we didn't someone tell me what we did use. I listed myself in for Panzer too...

Obviously they scored because we had scum in goal and had all 3 scum on the ice on Day 1, even though they had a scum as forward...

We had possession and shot on target on Day 2, but they saved it.

We had possession and shot wide on Day 4.

On Day 3 they had everyone playing in the positions they were suppose to play in (or at least what they claimed in the thread) and of course they won possession. However, we won possession on Day 4 and they only changed 2 people, so that means they probably had more scum on Day 4.

I think scum shoot wide and pro-town shoot on target, so on Day 2 someone other than CPE took the shot, but on Day 4 I think CPE took the shot. Not sure how it is determined who shoots though...

This sucks that we don't know who the scum is now, because with MoS off and the other 2 dead we were guaranteed to not have any scum on the ice and probably would have scored on Day 5. :/

[Flameaxe]

The one of the front page is the one from day 4. True story, especially because CPE was killed on day three.

[ZeekLTK]

Okay so this was Day 4:

-------------------

Killerbob

-------------------
-----------

MoS

--------

Flameaxe

-------------
-----

ZeekLTK

-----

Jdodge

------

Lowell

-----

---

ThAdmiral

---

HackerHuck

-----

hjallti

----
-------------

Lloyd

----------

hasdgfas

--------
---------------------

TSPN

----------------------


In that case I am confident we had a stronger squad on the ice (aka they had more scum than we did), however I think we did not score because one of the forwards was scum.

I'd suggest using this lineup for Day 5:

Same defense/goalie
Left Wing: ZeekLTK
Center: TVZ
Right Wing: ???

For right wing we could put in the other right defender, Shanba, or decide which of Lowell/Jdodge we think is scum and put the other one in. Coaches call on that I guess...

[ZeekLTK]

Since I know I am town, I'd prefer to see Lowell sit out.

[Capricious]

Hullo Cap. Diggin' the enthusiasm. You can be goal today.

Also, so people are aware of my lineup, Caps in goal, we have a mos/shanba shuffle, I don't think we have a third right forward, but I'm going to put panzer up there anyway cause hell why not. Much as I appreciate you trying, don't presently believe it's possible to figure out alignments from posting.

Have you sent in a line-up, Primate?

[Primate]

Hullo Cap. Diggin' the enthusiasm. You can be goal today.

Also, so people are aware of my lineup, Caps in goal, we have a mos/shanba shuffle, I don't think we have a third right forward, but I'm going to put panzer up there anyway cause hell why not. Much as I appreciate you trying, don't presently believe it's possible to figure out alignments from posting.

Have you sent in a line-up, Primate?

I sent a lineup on Feb 23rd.

[Primate]

This sucks that we don't know who the scum is now, because with MoS off and the other 2 dead we were guaranteed to not have any scum on the ice and probably would have scored on Day 5. :/

Also because this setup is broken at a basic level and once we'd mass claimed the scum was obviously MoS just from the roles claimed, which is the real travesty of the scum being randomised.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Primate, while I was scum, I'd actually considered fake claiming my position if we mass claimed. However, since it never came to that, I never really thought through the strategy completely. But that might've made it less obvious who was scum at that point, if I didn't fuck it up.

[ZeekLTK]

So what is the lineup for Day 5?

[Lowell]

I too would recommend a rotation of players. I'll sit out if you want.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Hasn't the other team already sent a lineup? Why are we still in Pre-Day? If both teams have sent a lineup, it seems unfair for the day not to have started yet, especially since our team's strategy relies on being able to quickly no lynch so that the other team doesn't have much time to lynch. Giving them 2 extra weeks of pre-day is completely biased towards the other team.

[Capricious]

The game is already completely biased towards the other team.

[Flameaxe]

dot dot dot.