Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[Thesp]

Final D3 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (Mr_Gnome_It_All)

farside22 - 8

(Holy, Mathcam, Mastermind of Sin, hasdgfas, curiouskarmadog, RossWilliam,

Cult of the Couch (1)

, Battle Mage)

Holy - 1

(farside22)

PookyTheMagicalBear - 1

(Iammars)

Mathcam - 1

(AmeliaSlay)

Beep! Beep! - 1

(petroleumjelly)

petroleumjelly - 2

(Beep! Beep!, PookyTheMagicalBear)

Not Voting - 0

()

Show of hands again so I make sure I've got this right...6...7...and 8. farside22, you've been lynched, please show us your card.

farside22,

Doctor

, has been lynched.

Everyone have their appetite? Great! Next stop - Mugshots, and their famed peanut butter burger. I know you'll love it!

Night 3 begins.

Please have all nightchoices in to me within 72 hours. Thanks.

[Thesp]

How about that burger? Anyone get any sleep last night? Pooky was falling asleep playing Mu, and still beating the tar out of everyone.

Speaking of Pooky...

PookyTheMagicalBear,

Jester

, has been killed.

RossWilliam,

Seer

, has been killed.

Day 4 begins.

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

[petroleumjelly]

Battle Mage

1.)

Did you send a PM to Thesp yesterday when you hammered Farside22? I tried to post something

very quickly

after you did so, but the thread had already been locked practically instantaneously.

2.)

Prior to hammering, you asked if anybody had anything pressing to say; after only a couple posts and a few minutes, you then hammered. Why even bother

asking

if anybody has anything to say if you were going to hammer with so few responses?

3.)

Why would you even

bother

hammering in a game where a deadline was coming up anyways,

and

we have plurality lynches (i.e. your vote was not even necessary?

Holy

1.)

What do you think of Beep! Beep! now that she cannot possibly be the jester?

~~~~~

Mod

, can we have confirmation that a 'Seer' for this game is essentially equivalent to a 'Cop'?

I think Beep! Beep! and Battle Mage are scum together. Yesterday was completely unacceptable. Beep! Beep!'s arguments have been

preposterously

bad, and she can no longer even use the concept of Jester to possibly dissuade lynches on herself any longer.

Vote: Beep! Beep!

. This could

so

easily be a Battle Mage vote.

[petroleumjelly]

hasdgfas

1.)

I would suggest breaking your restriction today, but wait until we get a consensus before you do. I'm tired of not being able to read you on account of you not posting anything of substance. Did you get an action last night?

[hasdgfas]

received action

[petroleumjelly]

Mastermind of Sin

You have not been posting. Post something. Make it snappy, and make it good. The longer your post, the better. I want as much commentary on as many things as possible.

I fully realize you are not the only person who has not been posting up to snuff, so do not use this factoid in any way as a 'defense' against your laxness. You seem way more willing to ooze into the background than

you

ought to be.

[petroleumjelly]

mathcam

Give an analysis on Battle Mage and Ameliaslay.

Mr_Gnome_It_All

Explain your position on Beep! Beep!, then analyze MeMe/mathcam.

Iammars

Read through MoS's posts and comment on them. Then give me your position on MGIA, given your earlier comment on the Cult of the Couch Role.

SlaySlay

Analyze CKD and Holy.

CuriousKarmaDog

Analyze Iammars and Ameliaslay.

Beep! Beep!

Die scum die.

[Beep! Beep!]

Greasy Spot(town) WAGON
mith(town), wolfcrier/BB(town), Sarcastro(town), Monkey(town), Captain Bandwagon/farside(town)
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester), RossWilliam(town)
petroleumjelly
curiouskarmadog
Iammars
Mastermind of Sin

Greasy Spot(town) OFFWAGON
Dani Banani(town), hasdgfas(town), Greasy Spot(town), alko(town)
MeMe/mathcam
BattleMage
petroleumjelly
Holy
QuickBen/ASlay

RossWilliam WAGON
Sarcastro(town), al_kohaulec(town),
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester)
Battle Mage
petroleumjelly

JDGA(town) WAGON
Monkey(town), hasdgfa (town), farside22(town), RossWilliam(town)
petroleumjelly

farside WAGON
Sarcastro(town), Talitha (town), al_kohaulec(town), RossWilliam(town)
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester)
MeMe/mathcam
curiouskarmadog

Beep! Beep!(town) WAGON
hasdgfas(town), Monkey(town), Talitha(town), farside22(town), RossWilliam(town)
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester)

Monkey(town) WAGON
al_kohaulec(town), Sarcastro(town),
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester),
Mastermind of Sin
Holy
MeMe/mathcam

Monkey OFFWAGON
Sarcastro(town) Beep! Beep!(town)
Battle Mage
curiouskarmadog
QB/ASlay
Iammars
petroleumjelly

farside22 (town) WAGON
hasdgfas(town), RossWilliam(town),
Holy
MeMe/Mathcam
Mastermind of Sin
curiouskarmadog
Battle Mage

farside22 (town) OFFWAGON
Beep! Beep!(town)
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester)
Iammars
AmeliaSlay
petroleumjelly

SCUM SCORES, hasdagas as town:

248 petroleumjelly
123 MeMeMe/mathcam
115 curiouskarmadog
110 BattleMage
78 Mastermind of Sin
78 Iammars
75 CKD
73 Holy
73 Amelia

[Battle Mage]

This game is starting to make a little more sense now. With the Jester down, we should have an easier job today. Plenty of leads at least. Oh and i am now 95% sure PJ is town. Something i spotted at the end of yesterday. Vague i know, but live with it.

Battle Mage

1.)

Did you send a PM to Thesp yesterday when you hammered Farside22? I tried to post something

very quickly

after you did so, but the thread had already been locked practically instantaneously.

Actually i DID!
I saw he was already online, so i figured a pm prod would enable him to reveal Farside's affiliation. I hate suspense.

2.)

Prior to hammering, you asked if anybody had anything pressing to say; after only a couple posts and a few minutes, you then hammered. Why even bother

asking

if anybody has anything to say if you were going to hammer with so few responses?

3.)

Why would you even

bother

hammering in a game where a deadline was coming up anyways,

and

we have plurality lynches (i.e. your vote was not even necessary?

Hammering ends the day. Theres no point letting time run down if we are done talking, and cant go any further till we know a players affiliation. It was polite to give a little time for people online to speak. I'm not the most patient person in the world. I'm not going to wait around ages for everyone to check in. Thats just the way i are.

I think Beep! Beep! and Battle Mage are scum together. Yesterday was completely unacceptable. Beep! Beep!'s arguments have been

preposterously

bad, and she can no longer even use the concept of Jester to possibly dissuade lynches on herself any longer.

Vote: Beep! Beep!

. This could

so

easily be a Battle Mage vote.

I think, given the information we now have, there are far better plays today. I'm torn between 2, and neither of them are DGBeep.

Beep Beep- could you please explain your scum scores in more detail. Currently they are totally incomprehensible. You have PJ as top by a country mile, yet according to the data you have listed, he is far from scummy.

BM

[curiouskarmadog]

CuriousKarmaDog

Analyze Iammars and Ameliaslay.

I can do this, but I dont think either are big posters...who will you be reviewing PJ?

Now that the jester is dead, I think Beep is scum and my vote will be going there...unless something unforseen happens.

Also, I disagree with you PJ, I think BM is town.

[Battle Mage]

EBWOP: Sorry, Beep Beep IS 1 of the two people i was talking about.
I forgot who it was who replaced Wolfcrier.
Yeh im happy to lynch her or the more obvious choice.
Prize to the first person to work that one out.

BM

[curiouskarmadog]

happy bday BM

[Battle Mage]

lol thanks. its not actually my b'day though. but i appreciate the thought

BM

[Beep! Beep!]

Beep Beep- could you please explain your scum scores in more detail.

Yep.

Example:

RossWilliam WAGON

Sarcastro(town), al_kohaulec(town),
PookyTheMagicalBear(Jester)
Battle Mage
petroleumjelly

I assume that there was some scum on the RossWilliam wagon. Although - I know see that we've had some wagons in this game that were made up of only townies. That's rare, but nothing is impossible, I am looking at probabilities, not absolute, despite accurate-lookingi numbers.

In the above example, we have a wagon on a townie with 5 players. Not a huge wagon, may or not have scum on that one, but I assign the unconfirmed alignment players on that wagon 50 points each (1/2 * 100)

What this method emphasizes is that scum is expected to "distribute" itself on wagons, and points to unconfirmed-alignment players that remain after the other players have had their alignments revealed as town. PJ's sin is to be much too often one of the few remaining players on wagons where most other players have been confirmed town.

Since you know your own alignment, I can make the same exercise, marking you down as town, and the scores would change. See:

Assuming BM is town:
283 petroleumjelly
108 MeMeMe/mathcam
100 curiouskarmadog
83 Iammars
83 Amelia
58 Mastermind of Sin
58 Holy

What if PJ was town?
145 BattleMage
128 MeMeMe/mathcam
103 curiouskarmadog
86 Mastermind of Sin
83 Iammars
78 Holy
75 Amelia

[Battle Mage]

so basically it punishes people who vote alot?

[Beep! Beep!]

We have now lost 10/21 players. We got rid of the Jester, but we have no scum so far.

We have also lost mucho power roles.

I'm just vanilla, and I'm expendable, so lynch me today if that's what you think is best. But we are now 11, and there may be up to 3 kills per night, so that tomorrow me might be as few as 7 players, against possibly 4 living scum.

[Battle Mage]

We have now lost 10/21 players. We got rid of the Jester, but we have no scum so far.

We have also lost mucho power roles.

I'm just vanilla, and I'm expendable, so lynch me today if that's what you think is best. But we are now 11, and there may be up to 3 kills per night, so that tomorrow me might be as few as 7 players, against possibly 4 living scum.

Actually i was thinking if we have 5 scum now, as is fairly likely, we could be at LyLo.

[Beep! Beep!]

so basically it punishes people who vote alot?

Occasionally the pool of "off-wagon" voters can be used, because one would expect some scum to hid in there.

What is does punish, say, on Day 4, is the sole remaining unconfirmed-alignment player on a given wagon. Or the sole remaining unconfirmed-alignment player voting OFF a wagon.

It only works when there has been a large enough number of wagons, that's why I like to replace, it's the best situation to use this method.

[hasdgfas]

probable scum

vote: CKD

[Beep! Beep!]

probable scum

vote: CKD

What are your reasons? Please explain in two words or less.

Amen!

BTW, please don't break your restrictions, the town is pretty power-poor and outscummed at the moment.

[curiouskarmadog]

probable scum

vote: CKD

where the shit did that come from? Any reason?

[hasdgfas]

tracked :arrow: Pooky

[DrippingGoofball]

Tracked or watched?

[Beep! Beep!]

Tracked or watched? Amen! Ahem!

[hasdgfas]

tracked CKD