Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[Mastermind of Sin]

farside, you get used to BM after a while. Other people, not so much.

[farside22]

farside, you get used to BM after a while. Other people, not so much.

If it was BM alone I would not be rubbing my eyes and pounding my head. Beep has that award.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Beep is special. BM at least tries to support his theories with logic, even though he's usually wrong.

[Thesp]

Official D3 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (Mr_Gnome_It_All)

farside22 - 6

(Holy, PookyTheMagicalBear, Mathcam, Mastermind of Sin, hasdgfas, Battle Mage)

Holy - 1

(farside22)

PookyTheMagicalBear - 1

(Iammars)

Mathcam - 1

(AmeliaSlay)

Beep! Beep! - 3

(petroleumjelly, RossWilliam, curiouskarmadog)

petroleumjelly - 1

(Beep! Beep!)

Not Voting - 1

(

Cult of the Couch (1)

)

With 14 alive, it's 8 to lynch.

Players are also reminded of this rule in reference to PMs from me:

Don’t quote or paraphrase any PMs from me. You should be able to pretend in thread that I'm not a part of this game outside of this thread, other than necessary nightchoice responses, if any. Don't even refer to my responses (or lack thereof).

Questions are certainly okay, in thread or by PM, but I may choose not to answer them, as here:

Mod, if we have a Quack Doc in this game, could that Doc target and kill scum?

If you have questions about roles in general, we have an excellent wiki resource you can research. If you have speculative questions of the mod about the setup, perhaps you should be trying an Open Game, several of which will be in signups tonight.

[curiouskarmadog]

what I am really hung up here in reference to farside is the fact that he knew the McCoy card before we saw the McCoy card....it would make sense that we might have two doctor roles and one be a quack. The fact that these cards are online and maybe could have figured it out where they were bothers me.

Also, the fact that he lied bothers me...going to reread a bit and try to figure out motivation.

[Holy]

Lets see if people read things I say.
I'm tired of being ignored and I want to help with the confusion. So I will say Beep Beep you are trying hard to lynch a claimed doctor on WIFOM logic. Mafia could be using that same tactic and it is completely easy to do with Monkey dead and coming up doctor.
Now that said I am a Quack Doctor. I wasn't a 100% sure day one since I replaced a person and I wasn't going to say anything about it figuring I would get lynched saying who CB actually targeted and I wanted to stay alive long enough to understand who was scum, who was jester and who was town. I'm not getting anywhere with anyone so it doesn't matter. Night one CB targeted Mith, Mith died. Night two I targeted Sacrostro because (a) I thought him Jester and if he wasn't Jester he was scummie as hell and wanted to see if the Quack Doctor theory I had was right. Well he died and was shown as a townie. I only say this because well people keep ignoring me execpt to say I'm scummie or to listen to crap-pot Beep beep for some assign reason I have yet to understand. Plus it helps lesson the confusion on the 3rd kill or 2 mafia idea that people have.
I still stand by Holy and Mathcam as scum other then that I haven't got a clue. If you still want to lynch me I'm not going to stop or argue go right to town, but I will keep saying I expected, I still expected it and nothing is going to get through to any town person left in this game, but I already figure I'm going to be lynched. I'm just helping solve one less confusion.

QUACK OR NOT, you did claim a doc, and you survived.
The fact that you changed your story of who you protected actually, only convinced me more of you as scum. If you concerned of your sanity which you doubted on Day 2, and if you really protected Sarcastro last night, EARLY on this day when you found you're likely to be lynched, you would reveal this immediately to the town, you got 2 results which dead because of you to be sure of it (if it's true), but no, you pushed this Quack theory on the middle of the game and after PJ mentioned about his Quack theory.
So, nooo, I don't buy your new claim.

vote Beep Beep

, I dont think you are the Jester now, you are just DGB, if the Mod assigned you the Jester role, he is a sick SOB.

Gasp! So it's DGB >.> <.<

My FFM mod, euh...

withholding information

Sure is. That's how I find scum, and how I want to be able to continue finding scum. Nobody but me needs to believe in my method. I don't need to make converts. If you don't trust it, that's fine.

Vote me, lynch me over it. I don't care.

Hmm, *thinking hard...* *thinking reaaally hard*
Nahh, your predecessor was jester-ish also.

[Beep! Beep!]

I think that farside's claim clip flops have been so preposterous that I smell a Jester.

I anyone able to confirm that Farside22 has killed mith and Sarcastro? Because if he truly did, then we know he's not the Jester, and we can just lynch the scum.

[Beep! Beep!]

I anyone able to confirm that Farside22 has killed mith and Sarcastro? Because if he truly did, then we know he's not the Jester, and we can just lynch the scum.

EBWOP

IS

anyone able to confirm that Farside22

[farside22]

I anyone able to confirm that Farside22 has killed mith and Sarcastro? Because if he truly did, then we know he's not the Jester, and we can just lynch the scum.

EBWOP

IS

anyone able to confirm that Farside22

I can confirm it.
By the way to answer PJ's question. Let's just say the answer I got was not an answer. Most Quack games I've played do not kill mafia.

[curiouskarmadog]

it is harder for me to believe the Doc claim with the lies. I could look over the fact that after your claim you werent night kill, especially after DG..err..Beep, pushed that you must be mafia because you werent NKed...but I cant swallow the changing of the story...and as I doubt you are the jester..

vote farside.

I believe that puts him at -1

[farside22]

it is harder for me to believe the Doc claim with the lies. I could look over the fact that after your claim you werent night kill, especially after DG..err..Beep, pushed that you must be mafia because you werent NKed...but I cant swallow the changing of the story...and as I doubt you are the jester..

vote farside.

I believe that puts him at -1

Can you at least say her instead of him before lynching me.
I know it is the lynch all liar mentality, but if I told the truth yesterday about Mith I think I would have been lynched. So it's just the same results, but once my Doc status comes out the town has an idea that there isn't a second kill group and that is all that matters to me.

[curiouskarmadog]

her..sorry..the laughing male dog is throwing me off.

you want us to believe that instead of telling the truth, you choose to lie and killed someone else?

[farside22]

her..sorry..the laughing male dog is throwing me off.

you want us to believe that instead of telling the truth, you choose to lie and killed someone else?

I suspect Sacro of being jester or scummie and if I was right I would have come out and said something right away. I'm wrong so it was worth a shot. I could have said something the beginning of the day about Sacro, but I just hoped not to get lynched at first. Then when I saw the confusion created by the 3rd kill I realized I needed to say something.

[hasdgfas]

stupid me

[Beep! Beep!]

Farside22,

You are so Jesterishly giddy with your impending lynch, it's gushing through my computer screen like water through a hole in Hoover Dam.

Beep! Beep!

[Beep! Beep!]

If I wanted to get myself lynched.

An Essay by Beep! Beep!

I would claim cop because I am not a cop, or any other role that exists, so that I would be counterclaimed. I would make dubious statements about my own sanity. I would give conflicting information about my night choices. I would try to provoke aggressive players.

Like this: Most Glorious Jester Performance, Lifetime Achievement Award

A+

[RossWilliam]

has? whats up?

and I believe farsides claim. well, kinda. i could see it being either way. My vote is still on Beep Beep, though, because she hasn't explained scum scores yet. I'm a man of my word, Beep!

[Battle Mage]

*waits for hammer*

[Beep! Beep!]

Ross William here is a man of his word, he won't hammer his buddy!

[RossWilliam]

if I were her scumbuddy I would have hammered her by now. honestly, i wouldn't be suprised, if her scumbiddies (assuming she is scum) aren't already on her bandwagon, that's how lost her cause is.

[RossWilliam]

scumbiddies = the female form of scumbuddies.

i.e. Beep Beep

[Beep! Beep!]

scumbiddies = the female form of scumbuddies.

LOL, I like mafiababe quite a bit too, haha.

Ross, you seem to think farside22 is not mafia.

How can you be so bloody sure she's not the Jester?
How can you be so bloody sure she's town?

I am intrigued.

Let see if you can convince me.

[RossWilliam]

I'm not bloody sure she's not the jester.
I'm not bloody sure she's town.
But, I'm not bloody sure she's scum.

And when she's at -1, that's a big but. I'm not gonna hammer someone unless I'm positive she's scum.

[Beep! Beep!]

Ross William,

I'm not arguing with your conclusion, but I would like to understand how you arrived at it a little better.

Is there anything farside22 has done that seems Jester-ish to you?
Is there anything farside22 has done that seems particularly townie to you?
Is there anything farside22 has done that seems particularly scummy to you?

[RossWilliam]

yes to all three. still not enough to hammer.