Penalty Box Mafia - Eagles. Game over. Scum wins (0-1)

[Lowell]

MOD

, I think you'd have more luck finding a replacement if you sold is as being a fresh start, as it pretty much is at this point. Anyone coming in wouldn't have to read back, since we're random at this point anyway.

[The Venerable Zorg]

I'm Centre-Forward. Hence my desire not to be in goal, and my earlier comment that claiming positions is flawed because my position is not actually one that features on the field.

[Foolster41]

Substatuting for killerbob, we have Capricious.

[Capricious]

Hi everyone, read through the game. So everything from the first 20-odd pages are useless, eh? Do we need me to claim my position ASAP?

[Capricious]

Doesn't seem to be any downside to get us all in the right positions, so: I'm a goalie

[Capricious]

And.. I would also like to point out that MoS is solidly pro-town for letting us in on what scum can do (pretty much nothing).
If MoS is scum and lying, first time something weird happens, we lynch him and win, and I don't think MoS is completely devoid of intelligence, therefore, he is town.

FoS TVZ

for nudging us a reminder that the mod could be pulling a stunt and kept MoS as scum.

[Flameaxe]

And.. I would also like to point out that MoS is solidly pro-town for letting us in on what scum can do (pretty much nothing).
If MoS is scum and lying, first time something weird happens, we lynch him and win, and I don't think MoS is completely devoid of intelligence, therefore, he is town.

FoS TVZ

for nudging us a reminder that the mod could be pulling a stunt and kept MoS as scum.

Except...MoS has the same chance as anyone to be scum...

[JDodge]

And.. I would also like to point out that MoS is solidly pro-town for letting us in on what scum can do (pretty much nothing).
If MoS is scum and lying, first time something weird happens, we lynch him and win, and I don't think MoS is completely devoid of intelligence, therefore, he is town.

FoS TVZ

for nudging us a reminder that the mod could be pulling a stunt and kept MoS as scum.

how is intelligence at all a factor

and furthermore why is it scummy that someone is being smart and reminding the town of an important possibility

[Capricious]

Notice at the time of his post, the majority of us had not claimed yet. So he was in a position to give us bad info about his abilities as scum that might screw us or at least delay us to buy time for the other team to sort themselves out. He did not do this.

If he was lying then the first time something weird happens, we lynch him and win.

Also, I believe that people with prior positions revealed prior as scum are town,as two scum at one position means we will never be able to play at full strength. Therefore the other goalie (me) and whoever claims forward right wing are also town, barring a counterclaim, of course.

[Capricious]

Ah, gator was the other right forward. Missed that since the guy only made one post.

[Capricious]

There are six positions, Left Foreword, Center, Right Foreword, Left Defence, Right Defense and Goalie. There are two players for each position on a team, and players may be switched around to play other position, but won't be as good in that position.

I'm Centre-Forward. Hence my desire not to be in goal, and my earlier comment that claiming positions is flawed because my position is not actually one that features on the field.

We have him.

Vote:TVZ

[Capricious]

nvm, center forward is just a center, watched/played too much basketball recently. Thought center/forward were mutually exclusive.

Unvote

Goalie: Capricious
Right Defence: Shanba/MoS
Left Defence: Flameaxe
Center: TVZ/Jdodge
Right Forward: None
Left Forward: Lowell

I would like to understand how there are 11 players on the team, but there are two players for each position.

[Mastermind of Sin]

We don't have a right forward, it looks like.

[Capricious]

Nah, our right forwards are both dead.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Oh.

[Mastermind of Sin]

So we have 2 dead right forwards and 1 dead left defence?

So we only have 1 claimed goalie and 1 claimed left forward right now. And 1 person yet to claim. I'm guessing we only have 1 goalie, that's why there are 11 players.

[Foolster41]

I'm working on a complete list of the lineups, but my list isn't quite complete. It's going to take more time to get it all together.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Thanks.

[Lowell]

Is anyone paying attention? Has the other team lynched any scum yet?

If not, I propose another no lynch. It'll force them to either (a) lynch fast, or (b) no lynch also, either of which, one would think, would favor us.

[Capricious]

We need a replacement to claim before we go on.

[Flameaxe]

They just got their first scum lynch, Lowell.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Is anyone paying attention? Has the other team lynched any scum yet?

If not, I propose another no lynch. It'll force them to either (a) lynch fast, or (b) no lynch also, either of which, one would think, would favor us.

Lowell, Primate and I already suggested this

[Lowell]

Okay sorry, I'm falling behind. Interest is waning. Lynching scum doesn't help, so it's hard to know what to do. Carry on.

[Capricious]

replacement claim

send in lineup of most pro-towners, namely, the person in a solo position, and MoS, the double agent.

If we score, keep lineup

If don't score or get scored on, shuffle. Simple.

[Flameaxe]

MOS
ISN'T
CONFIRMED