The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[meaning of life 42]

unvote SS
vote Korais

because Corsato is right

lynching a troll can't be bad, even if he claimed it himself.

[drummer97531]

That was...unusual. I'm not sure how far I'd trust Korais's claims about night choices and such just yet. But I guess it's okay to kill him. I personally would have lasted as long as I could.

[mikehart]

And with that, Korais666 the final troll, Tom, was killed.

It is

Night 3

, choices please.

[mikehart]

dpressing number of choices in...

no one has died surprisingly and it is now Day 3

[Yaw]

Well, remember how I said yesterday that I thought the other goblins were lurkers because I couldn't see connections to jediknight? Time to test that theory.

Vote: IndenturedDjinn

Time for the lurker wagons.

[PeaceBringer]

well if we vote IndenturedD we will be waiting a long time for a claim.

Also Narnianin has asked to be replaced in other games-

Wouldn't a couple more replacements be in order?

Otherwise lets just lynch all the lurkers and see what we have left.

[Internet Stranger]

It would be hypocritical for me to not vote for Coolbot at this point.

Vote: Coolbot

[Internet Stranger]

I forgot to add:

Im rather shocked that out of the 100 possible evil people we are supposed to have, none did anything last night. Was Superman doing his rounds last night?

[Yggdrasil]

Well, by the "dpressing number of choices" I think it would be safe to assume that at least one of the mafia groups/SKs is one of our inactives, so (at the risk of being hypocritical, considering my lack of participation) let the lurker waggon begin.

vote: IndenturedDjinn

[Yaw]

PeaceBringer, part of the rationale here is to force prods and replacements. Although, I had thought the same thing as Yggdrasil too. In addition to the fact that I hadn't been able to tie people together with Jediknight as goblins, it's probable that at least one group missed a kill because of inactivity, rather than doc protection or role-blocking. So there is enough evidence that some of our lurkers are scum, and this is a good strategy to get a full complement of people here as well. Even if we need to get a replacement, we won't be lynching without claims.

[PeaceBringer]

problem is Yaw that a GG role player may also be in the Lurking and non-submitting crowd.

I am all for getting rid of what I refer to as speedbumps. I guess a down side of games here is folks lose interest or get busier then when they were set up.

Frustrating on my book and no reason games should move as slow as they seem to, but of course makes folks take time to think.

Vote: Indentureddjinn

because worst of the speedbump/lurkers

[PeaceBringer]

IN fact it is more probable a GG role player would be a non submitter. Unless a SK role the BGs usually have an opportunity to have someone around to submit.

[MMCL]

Quite - although it is depressing for Mike, it is great news for us....

Can someone explain GG and BG for me?

[Flying Dutchman]

GG: Girl Guides, Governor-General, Grenadier Guards
BG: Baldur's Gate

That's all I can come up with.....

[MMCL]

D'oh - Good Guys and Bad Guys...

[Flying Dutchman]

Ah, that's possible too. I prefer Girl Guides though

[MMCL]

Girl Guides is better...

[meaning of life 42]

ok, i've also put some thought into this and decided to

vote Indentureddjinn

because of the fact that no one was killed last night. If no one was killed last night, Mafia must have been in a REALY REALY REALY nice mood, or they are inactive.K.

[Yaw]

IN fact it is more probable a GG role player would be a non submitter. Unless a SK role the BGs usually have an opportunity to have someone around to submit.

Except that about half the game is inactive. Look at how long it took us to lynch Korais, despite the fact that he claimed scum, and was the last remaining member of a scum group, and so had no partners left. I'd say probability's pretty even right now.

[MMCL]

Quite Yaw... Let's have a look at the list of players left:

coolbot
Corsato

drummer97531

Flying Dutchman

Gaspode

indentureddjinn

Internet Stranger

Jaylen

Lord Gurgi
meaning of life 42
MMCL

Murk

Narninian

PeaceBringer

Shivan_Dragon

the silent speaker

Tigris

Uraj45

Yaw
Yggdrasil(replacing Ibanez (replacing chaotic_diablo))

If your name is in bold it is because I haven't seen much of you in this game (no figures to back it up - just my personal opinion) and I would ask for you to get remotivated.

[meaning of life 42]

ok, so half the game's inactive. but if we vote for an inactive person, and they're lynched, will we miss them? They're already inactive, so you would miss that person after they're dead?

[Yaw]

If they're scum, no.

Seriously, though, this is in part an attempt to get everyone back into this game. There is sufficient reason to believe we have scum among the inactives, so that's worth probing. We're definitely not going to lynch anyone who isn't here.

Also, normally I'd actually count for a lurker list, but I don't have time today and it wouldn't really help much (replacements and vacations provide enough mitigating circumstances that the list won't be truly objective). Jaylen's been here, but not a frequent posted. I'd tend to add Yggdrasil to that list, then note that he, along with Gaspode and Shivan_Dragon, have been on vacation at some point during this game. (I think Uraj and Djinn have been too, but Djinn's been gone since getting back and never did get around to actually participating despite a promise to contribute, which is why my vote's there.)

[meaning of life 42]

YAW

Seriously, though, this is in part an attempt to get everyone back into this game. There is sufficient reason to believe we have scum among the inactives, so that's worth probing. We're definitely not going to lynch anyone who isn't here.

ok then,

unvote Indentureddjinn

[Yaw]

What the? No, we

need

the pressure still. That will help us get a replacement if the lurkers aren't around. The fact that we aren't going to

finish

a lynch without response doesn't mean that we shouldn't have the pressure of a bandwagon to get a response.

[meaning of life 42]

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, YOUR CONFUSING ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ok,

vote Indentureddjinn

and that's my final answer. OK?