Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[hasdgfas]

scum scores?

[Beep! Beep!]

scum scores?

My vote on farside22 is independent of the scum scores. I've explained my vote for farside22 in detail.

Hence your comment that I am "a pot calling the kettle black" when asking that petroleum explain her unvote is misleading. I did explain my vote. Many times, in fact.

I hold the high ground when I ask for petroleum to explain her unvote.

[petroleumjelly]

Hi. Let's look at your "scum scores":

With farside as unknown alignment
95 PJ
91 RossWilliam
88 hasdgfas
78 farside
53 MoS
50 BM
33 MeMe
33 Holy
33 karma
20 Iammars

With farside as scum
116 RossWilliam
108 PJ
83 hasdgfas
66 MeMe
58 MoS
58 karma
50 BM
33 Holy
25 Iammars

According to your analysis, regardless of farside's alignment, I am either #1 or #2 "scummiest" on your list. You claim to think hasdgfas is scum even though you later claim to have not realized he claims to have a posting restriction (a bit hard to believe for anybody who claims to have read the game). Since hasdgfas is lower on the scale than I am in both cases, you must therefore think those higher are also scum. Basically, you calling the set of {Farside22, PJ, hasdgfas, RossWilliam} all scum, which I have nothing against people doing, but it does strike me as silly given that you have explained any of the reasoning (if there is any) you are employing.

You further fail to realize that all the townies (etc.) have the same pictures, and the same goes for town roles -- if there were two full Doctor roles, then

yes

, they both

would

be Doctor McCoys because that's how mith's cards are set up to work.

Throughout it all, you have failed to give your

own

explanation for your own suspicions, so yes - when you ask

me

why I unvoted Farside22, it

does

strike me as a pot calling the kettle black. How are we to judge

you

when you aren't explaining yourself?

The purpose of my unvote should have been fairly self-explanatory. It is early in the day, my vote is not strictly necessary, and I am not comfortable with Farside22 being lynched before I have time to think it over (which is more likely to longer I leave my vote on her).

[petroleumjelly]

^ Additionally, you claim that with Farside22 as unknown alignment, I am the top of your list; assuming that you do not know Farside22's alignment, your vote on Farside22 (who is fourth on your list) over myself (who is first) does not even make sense.

[hasdgfas]

Amen PJ!

[Beep! Beep!]

^ Additionally, you claim that with Farside22 as unknown alignment, I am the top of your list; assuming that you do not know Farside22's alignment, your vote on Farside22 (who is fourth on your list) over myself (who is first) does not even make sense.

That scumlist ONLY looks at voting patterns.

My vote for Farside22 is clearly based on the unlikelihood of a second full doctor claim, a claim identical to that of a player confirmed by death, a very odd night choice, the so-called doctor surviving a night with 3 kills, AND to some extent, farside22 showing up on my scumlist.

I am quite certain that you realize this, and that you realize it fully and completely.

Have I not explained my vote at length, and repreatedly?

Thank you for explaining why you unvoted, though your answer was quite vague, especially weighed against the detail of your attempt to discredit me.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

@The idiot protown player who targetted Talitha, stop being stupid and claim.

@BM why does my timing suck? should I wait until I get blown away at night before I claim results?

[Battle Mage]

@The idiot protown player who targetted Talitha, stop being stupid and claim.

@BM why does my timing suck? should I wait until I get blown away at night before I claim results?

Your timing sucks because our lynch is obvious. We have 1 scumbag under wraps. Youve outted yourself as a fairly strong power role, and seem to just be prolonging the day. You havent bothered to initiate a checklist of players who havent posted yet, so you have little idea of when is a suitable time to reveal your info with no-one coming forward. You seriously ought to be revealing the name of anyone who has currently posted and who you spotted, as they are almost certainly going to fit the role of scum according to your criteria. I'm seeing this as having a strong chance of being a scum gambit with the intention of outting protown power roles, and potentially getting multiple mislynches, with the additional result of saving Farside for a while longer. Even implying that a protown player targetting Talitha is an idiot is insanely scummy. The only protown roles who would target Talitha with the motive of thinking she is scum are RB and Vig as far as i can see, and WHO COULD BLAME THEM?
She was hardly as town as pie. -.-

Claim your results, and prove me wrong.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Unvote: Farside22

.

Please provide reasoning for your unvote.

I wholeheartedly endorse this product, service or statement.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

the prolific nature of the nightkills raises the possibility of multiple deaths per cycle in a protown favor(which means one lynch is not just enough) and also increases my odds of going to the grave with my information.

That obviously makes me coming out more good for us.

[farside22]

@The idiot protown player who targetted Talitha, stop being stupid and claim.

@BM why does my timing suck? should I wait until I get blown away at night before I claim results?

Your timing sucks because our lynch is obvious. We have 1 scumbag under wraps. Youve outted yourself as a fairly strong power role, and seem to just be prolonging the day. You havent bothered to initiate a checklist of players who havent posted yet, so you have little idea of when is a suitable time to reveal your info with no-one coming forward. You seriously ought to be revealing the name of anyone who has currently posted and who you spotted, as they are almost certainly going to fit the role of scum according to your criteria. I'm seeing this as having a strong chance of being a scum gambit with the intention of outting protown power roles, and potentially getting multiple mislynches, with the additional result of saving Farside for a while longer. Even implying that a protown player targetting Talitha is an idiot is insanely scummy. The only protown roles who would target Talitha with the motive of thinking she is scum are RB and Vig as far as i can see, and WHO COULD BLAME THEM?
She was hardly as town as pie. -.-

Claim your results, and prove me wrong.

BM

I disagree. Whether you believe I'm scum or not there should be a discussion as a town to find scum and not look for a quick lynch just so scum can continue to hide under the radar. I agree with Pooky that coming out with the info with 3 kills in one night is not a bad play especial considering that I look at it as I'm a doc about to be lynched and someone is looking for a quick lynch which to me is more suspicious.

[Battle Mage]

thats of course only suspicious should you actually be a Doc. lol
and besides, ive hardly been out to quicklynch you today. I didnt bandwagon immediately, i looked at all the information. You can criticise me all you want, but fact is, theres about 6 other players here who were far more keen to quicklynch you earlier. Now i think we've found scum, i'm happy to join them. Its not a quicklynch cutting off discussion. Its a scumlynch which we dont want to get distracted from.

BM

[farside22]

thats of course only suspicious should you actually be a Doc. lol
and besides, ive hardly been out to quicklynch you today. I didnt bandwagon immediately, i looked at all the information. You can criticise me all you want, but fact is, theres about 6 other players here who were far more keen to quicklynch you earlier. Now i think we've found scum, i'm happy to join them. Its not a quicklynch cutting off discussion. Its a scumlynch which we dont want to get distracted from.

BM

You are question Pooky about coming out with the info and stating that I should just be lynched. As much as I can not defend myself against what has happened it is better for the town to discuss other scums especially when all of those who are looking to lynch me are proven wrong.

AMEN

[Battle Mage]

thats of course only suspicious should you actually be a Doc. lol
and besides, ive hardly been out to quicklynch you today. I didnt bandwagon immediately, i looked at all the information. You can criticise me all you want, but fact is, theres about 6 other players here who were far more keen to quicklynch you earlier. Now i think we've found scum, i'm happy to join them. Its not a quicklynch cutting off discussion. Its a scumlynch which we dont want to get distracted from.

BM

You are question Pooky about coming out with the info and stating that I should just be lynched. As much as I can not defend myself against what has happened it is better for the town to discuss other scums especially when all of those who are looking to lynch me are proven wrong.

AMEN

We can cross that bridge when we come to it. Pooky, made that list yet? or are we going to have to wait till 2 days before deadline to hear your information?

BM

[petroleumjelly]

I (sadly) have to agree with BM. Pooky mentioned his results last Thursday; people have had time to claim if they were going to do so. If Pooky intends on revealing, we are better off with that knowledge sooner rather than later. The last thing I want is a mad scramble at deadline.

[farside22]

I (sadly) have to agree with BM. Pooky mentioned his results last Thursday; people have had time to claim if they were going to do so. If Pooky intends on revealing, we are better off with that knowledge sooner rather than later. The last thing I want is a mad scramble at deadline.

The question becomes though who of the 3 are scum and why didn't they say anything sooner?

[Battle Mage]

im still not sure where u get "3" from.

[Holy]

I guess farside is kind of nervous, she's keep saying it 3, lol.
Well, I'm quite curious here, Pooky.

Regarding PJ's conversation with Beep!Beep!, I should say Beep's scumscore isn't quite balanced to me because it only looks from the voting patterns, on the other side, Beep kind of fair to admit it and still considering other aspects too (my assumption from watching his play), I also noticed that Beep isn't voting his top blindly just because his scum scores says so.

[Thesp]

Official D3 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (tyhess)

farside22 - 4

(Mastermind of Sin, Holy, Beep! Beep!, Battle Mage)

Not Voting - 10

(

Cult of the Couch (1)

, AmeliaSlay, farside22, hasdgfas, Iammars, MeMe, PookyTheMagicalBear, RossWilliam, curiouskarmadog, petroleumjelly)

With 14 alive, it's 8 to lynch.

Prodding everyone who hasn't posted in the last 72 hours, replacing non-responders.

[curiouskarmadog]

got prodded, wow..anyway, dont agree with the farside lynch at this point. Especially with Pooky's claim...this information needs to come out sooner than later. Been waiting for Pooky mostly beforing (re)voting.

[hasdgfas]

here, Pooky.

[farside22]

I thought Pooky said 3 people targeted tabitha. (shrug).
Thanks CKD. Just when I thought you actually had something more then the rest of the town you pull a comment like that.

[curiouskarmadog]

far, what are you talking about?..what is wrong with my comment?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Whoever got caught by Pooky needs to claim now so we can get back to lynching Farside. Cmon people...

[farside22]

far, what are you talking about?..what is wrong with my comment?

It sounds like you are saying you agree with everyone that I should be lynched. Since you were the only one questioning my inevitable lynch I didn't consider you to be one of the mindless zombies out there.
I have no clue who is scum any more. I question Beep beep WIFOM comments. Holy's lack of scum hunting and BM's comment about just lynching and worry about discussion later. GL I think you are going to need it with this group.