Weather Mafia -- Divine Intervention? Over

[Glork]

Vote Count:

Cyberbob 3 (hasdgfas, Gorrad, Blackberry)
Gorrad 2 (ChaosOmega, Porochaz)
farside22 1 (armlx)
Porochaz 1 (Cyberbob)


Not Voting: Bookitty, farside22, Iammars, Twomz

11 alive, 6 to lynch.

Day will end on or before Thursday, March 7, at 21:30 EST.

[Bookitty]

Armlx: If ChaosOmega is your primary suspect (as your posts seem to indicate), and your other suspicions are largely derived from that one, and since your vote is the only one on Farside at the moment, why are you voting her and not ChaosOmega? I don't disagree with your vote on Farside, and in fact might join you in it for the reasons I stated yesterday, but I don't really understand YOUR reasoning here. Especially since you've said yourself your reasons for suspecting ChaosOmega are contradictory and one of them was flat wrong; does that clear ChaosOmega in your view?

A few questions:

Porochaz, what do you think of Cyberbob?

Blackberry, what do you think of Gorrad?

Twomz, what's your take on Farside?

[Porochaz]

Cyberbob hasnt posted much and when he has I havent really felt its constructive, I realise that whilst saying this I havent posted all that much either recently, but feel that I do put more into my posts than he does. (not length per say just more content). I dont think however its vote worthy at this time, he is posting more content in this game and whilst his content involves voting me and the reasons are scraping the barrel, I don't find him necasserily scummy as long as he continues to regularly post content into this game.

[farside22]

@BooKitty: Have you read anything else I stated since that conversation yesterday or are you just fixated on me?
I still think one person on the Niv wagon was scum. Gorrad was on my list, but I took him off temperaley due to his comments on weather claim. However as I stated yesterday it's possible scum may have gotten a role that has to due with weather as well.
Armix: I'm not sure why you are flip flopping around with who you think is scum and then think is town. It's just odd.
I still haven't seen anything scummie coming from cyberbob at this point.

Vote: Gorrad

[hasdgfas]

I still haven't seen anything scummie coming from cyberbob at this point.

Did you think that maybe that was because we haven't really seen much of

anything

from cyberbob?

[farside22]

I still haven't seen anything scummie coming from cyberbob at this point.

Did you think that maybe that was because we haven't really seen much of

anything

from cyberbob?

He admitted to being busy with school. Yes he's been quiet, but I don't always think quiet is scummie. Sometimes it is and sometimes it's not. I have people tell me I'm scummie when I'm over aggressive so it is almost a lose, lose situation.

@Cyberbob:

Do you have a list of players and thoughts on each player thus far?

[Cyberbob]

I'm off to school in about 5 minutes (I really shouldn't even be on the computer right now), but I'll answer your question when I get home.

[Blackberry]

I'm off to school in about 5 minutes (I really shouldn't even be on the computer right now), but I'll answer your question when I get home.

scum

[hasdgfas]

I'm off to school in about 5 minutes (I really shouldn't even be on the computer right now), but I'll answer your question when I get home.

I sure hope so

[Twomz]

Twomz, what's your take on Farside?

I'll have to look over her posts to get one. Pretty neutral opinion off the top of my head >.>

[armlx]

Bookitty: Cite these wrong reasons, beyond the one accidental thing where I included CO in the group of you and Farside not voting for xtoxm.

Farside: I'm hardly flip flopping. I've determined the scum group is either

You
Bookitty
CO
Cyberbob

or

hasdfgas
Porochaz
CO
Cyberbob

It's just a matter of drawing enough info from people to determine which.

If you are referring to me not voting CO or Cyberbob now, I feel more info can be gained from the other people I mentioned.

[farside22]

@Armix: If CO and cyberbob are on both list as scum why wouldn't you vote for either one of them?

[Bookitty]

Bookitty: Cite these wrong reasons, beyond the one accidental thing where I included CO in the group of you and Farside not voting for xtoxm.

That's a pretty big one, isn't it? It pretty much undermined your entire theory, and you're acting like it was just a minor thing and continuing as if it didn't really happen.

And you're completely overlooking that I said this:

The likelihood of Monkey hitting two scum on two investigations is not very high, in my opinion. Thus, I think it likely that Xtoxm and Blackberry are town (along with Monkey, as a paranoid/insane cop).

Why would I vote for Xtoxm when I thought he was town? What constitutes pushing back against a lynch, in your view? If your past accusations are any indication, if there had been a concerted effort to prevent Xtoxm's lynch, then you'd have been right there, claiming that the people involved were scum because they "knew" that Xtoxm was town.

Why is not voting for a townie evidence that someone is scum?

[armlx]

The issue is you and Farside sorta disappeared for the end of the second day as xtoxm was ramped to a lynch. In that time, neither of you did anything to put suspicion on xtoxm, but you did nothing to help pursue alternate cases and possibly find a real lynch candidate.

It hardly undermines my theory. There's still a fair connection between the 3 of you (Cyber sorta did the scum lurk and snipe thing) that I feel deserves examination.

[Bookitty]

I can make the precise argument against you, in reverse, that you're making against me. Yesterday when I made a case against Farside, you attacked me and defended her, but realised you'd made too clear a link between yourself and her, so today you decided to bus her for distancing purposes, while trying to forge a nonexistent link between Farside and me and linking us in some nebulous way to other people who are vaguely scummy because they didn't vote for a townie as apparently they should have.

Last week I had a pretty nasty cold and I wasn't posting much ANYWHERE. That's verifiable by people who are in other games with me. So this is a nulltell, unless you're arguing that being ill is somehow scummy.

And saying that three people are linked because they didn't vote for Xtoxm and didn't push back against it hard enough, when one of them DID vote for Xtoxm, is DEFINITELY undermining your theory. Just saying, Oh, you're scummy and linked in other ways is not good enough. Explain HOW I'm linked to ChaosOmega. And explain what Cyberbob has to do with ANY argument you've made against me so far.

[armlx]

The main link between CO and Farside was the non-random vote early D1. You are linked to CO through farside.

I already said, Cyber is just being lurker scum.

[armlx]

EBWODP: Before Cyberbob complains, it is not how much you posted that makes you lurker scum, its what you did. You sniped at easy targets and just went back to hiding.

[Bookitty]

You are connected to Farside far more than I am, Armlx. I have not defended her; you have. So by your own logic, your behaviour links you far more definitely to her than mine; mine has at least been consistent. Yours seems consistent in only one way: it allows you to continue attacking me on highly dubious grounds.

[Blackberry]

Bookitty: Cite these wrong reasons, beyond the one accidental thing where I included CO in the group of you and Farside not voting for xtoxm.

Farside: I'm hardly flip flopping. I've determined the scum group is either

You
Bookitty
CO
Cyberbob

or

hasdfgas
Porochaz
CO
Cyberbob

It's just a matter of drawing enough info from people to determine which.

If you are referring to me not voting CO or Cyberbob now, I feel more info can be gained from the other people I mentioned.

BUT WAIT: --- I AM SCUM

Why isn't my

scum-mason-partner-in-crime

,

CyberBob

, dead yet?

[Blackberry]

LET'S DO THE SCUM DANCE!!

doot doot doot, doot doot doot doot, doot doot, doot doot doot

[Twomz]

Seriously, can we get a modkill or a replacement here?

[Blackberry]

Seriously, can we get a modkill or a replacement here?

On who?

[Blackberry]

XTOXM LYNCH:

Gorrad

, Cyberbob,

ChaosOmega, Twomz

...

Monkey, Xtoxm

NIV LYNCH:

Niv, Blackberry

, armlx,

Twomz

, Iammars,

ChaosOmega

,

Xtoxm

,

Gorrad

Tres amigos son scum?

[hasdgfas]

BB, let's see whether Twomz's claimed ability happens tonight before saying he's scum. I think we've already talked about this.

[Twomz]

Seriously, can we get a modkill or a replacement here?

On who?

You, you goat-sniffing woolheaded retard with about as much usefulness as a hoofless horse. (I've been reading too much Wheel of Time, and my insults are starting to stray to those veins)