Mafia 72: Peril in Panama - Game over!

[Patrick]

Votecount

Lowell (3) -- Porochaz, Setael, Dragon Phoenix

Not voting: Lowell, Battle Mage, Mastermind of Sin, pete d
7 alive, 4 to lynch.

[Battle Mage]

meh. not sure i trust Setael's claim too much atm. I mean unless MoS is scum, i cant see why I wouldnt have been NKed, if Setael was a Cop. On the other hand, if he is scum, while im wasting my shots protecting him, he can have pick of the NK's.

But, Lowell gives me scummy enough vibes to make him lynchworthy.

Vote: Lowell

Gd'night everybody.

BM

[Patrick]

Final Votecount

Lowell (4) -- Porochaz, Setael, Dragon Phoenix, Battle Mage

Not voting: Lowell, Mastermind of Sin, pete d
7 alive, 4 to lynch.
-------------------------------

Wow. You people are definitely eager! Four of you pretty much drag Lowell out of bed, overpower him and string him up without letting him say a word, no doubt on the grounds that defences are overrated. When he's dead you all search his property and his corpse, and discover that he was yet another simple villager, who had no part in any conspiracies or killings.

Lowell - Panamanian Villager - lynched day 5

Night 5. The usual deadline applies.

[Patrick]

Day 6, in contrast with yesterday, is rather gloomy and rainy, and your numbers have been cut down to 5. Setael didn't make it through the night. A search reveals that she owned a gun, but she's been too afraid to use it in this game. The reason is that her role wasn't vig, but cop. And now you'll have to save the village without her.

Setael - Cop - killed night 5

Day 6. With 5 players alive, it's 3 votes to lynch.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Vote: Battle Mage

No amount of WIFOM bullshit will get you out of this one, BM. And DP is going down with you, scum.

[Porochaz]

I am suprised at no doctor... it certainly seems like an easy win now...

vote Battle Mage

[Lowell]

Wait, you killed me? Boo.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Yeah, it was a retarded lynch, Lowell. I apologize on behalf of the rest of the people who did it, even though it wasn't my fault at all.

Also, Battle Mage, don't even try to argue that you think I'm scum because I could be a godfather. I saw you try to lay the seeds of doubt a few pages back. The godfather is already dead, that won't work on us.

Porochaz, pete d, and myself are all cleared by the dead and confirmed cop. You should've killed Setael a night earlier and sacrificed yourself if you wanted a chance. You could've killed me last night, and it would've been Porochaz, Shanba, pete d, Lowell, and DP alive, with only Porochaz and Shanba cleared. pete d would've gotten lynched, probably, and DP would've killed Shanba and gotten Lowell lynched to win the game. You guys screwed up big time on the numbers here. BM couldn't look past his own survival to see that he had to sacrifice himself earlier to win. GG y'all.

[Battle Mage]

shit...
Not alot i can say. Of course, i'm confirmed town barring a doc counterclaim, but i did fuck up last night. Anyway, this game should be wrapped up tomorrow.
Lynch DP then, and we should still win. Oh and MoS, you are officially a moron. I find your last post deeply insulting, and when you see your mistake, i fully expect an apology.

BM

[Porochaz]

UNVOTE

Could we have a case of naivity umongst the cop? I mean I was initially inclined to believe Setael but 3 innocents in a row could suggest it...

[Mastermind of Sin]

Your reaction right here just convinced me that there's no way you are NOT protown, so it would have to be pete d if that was true. Regardless, I think it's better play to lynch DP first, since he's scum with BM or pete d, probably.

Unvote, Vote: DP

BM, don't call me a moron when you fucked up at being a doc

yet again

(or you are lying to begin with). I'm not going to apologize for anything, because you didn't even bother to offer an alternative to you being scum. Porochaz actually thought about it and came up with a reason for why you might

just

be the worst doc to ever exist in a mafia game. I still don't really believe you, because you didn't even reveal who you targetted, and you act like there has to be a doctor in the town, so that somehow confirms you because there was no counterclaim. Maybe if you actually fucking played the game, it wouldn't look like you were obvscum. Try that on for size sometime, it'd probably fit nicely.

[Dragon Phoenix]

Come on... BM conveniently forgets to protect the cop in the same night that the scum tries to take her out?

Vote battle mage

[Patrick]

Votecount

Dragon Phoenix (1) -- Mastermind of Sin
Battle Mage (1) -- Dragon Phoenix

Not voting: Porochaz, pete d, Battle Mage
5 alive, 3 to lynch.

[Battle Mage]

UNVOTE

Could we have a case of naivity umongst the cop? I mean I was initially inclined to believe Setael but 3 innocents in a row could suggest it...

I highly doubt this game would contain a cop of retarded sanity. and if it dead, im certain it would be revealed on death.
DP is the last scum.

Vote: DP

BM

[Mastermind of Sin]

I think we have two scum left. 3 mafia is too small.

[Porochaz]

Well I hope that the sanity isn't the case cause I think it would be unfair if it was... however

vote DP

[Dragon Phoenix]

And so ends my last game on scum. Good luck town. Can't believe you are letting BM getting away with this.

[Patrick]

Final Votecount

Dragon Phoenix (3) -- Mastermind of Sin, Battle Mage, Porochaz
Battle Mage (1) -- Dragon Phoenix

Not voting: pete d
5 alive, 3 to lynch
-------------------------

Another lightning fast lynch. Dragon Phoenix wishes the town good luck before they get rid of him, yet another panamanian villager. Everyone is feeling rather sad now about all the green blood.

Dragon Phoenix - Panamanian Villager - lynched day 6

Night 6 has started. The usual deadline applies.

[Patrick]

Three of you wake up to the seventh day in Panama to find that MoS has been shot, and is very dead. He was a villager. The three of you know that today must be the final day. The fate of the village, and more importantly the game, hangs in the balance. Hmm.

Mastermind of Sin - Panamanian Villager - killed night 6

Day 7 begins. With just 3 players alive, you need 2 votes to lynch.

[Battle Mage]

hmm im pretty confident that Pete D cant be the scum. Ive checked, and he hasnt posted on site in the last 48 hours, and that was only in his own game. Plus Porochaz's voting history isnt exactly flattering. What i dont get though, is his insistence of cop sanity issues. It seems kinda wierd if he was scum.
I'd like to hear from both of you before i vote though.

FoS: Porochaz

in the meantime.

BM

[pete d]

Setael got innocents on myself and porochaz. Setael was a COP. If she was naive, we would have been told. Therefore,

vote: BattleMage

. BM, feel free to claim something ridiculous, because this one is a no-brainer.

I thought that bookitty was too trusting of the Doc-claim after what happened in Boringtown...

[Porochaz]

If Setael got a sane on me and MoS is now confirmed sane, I think this pretty much confirms it...

vote Battle Mage

[Patrick]

Final Votecount

Battle Mage (2) -- pete d, Porochaz

Not voting: Battle Mage
3 alive, 2 to lynch.
--------------------------------

In light of very compelling evidence, pete d and Porochaz feel comfortable lynching Battle Mage at record breaking speed. He struggles wildly, but with two others alive, the rules of the game prevent Battle Mage from using his gun, and he is soon overpowered. Battle Mage's last breath also marks the last breath of the mafia presence in the village, and pete d and Porochaz can go home safe in the knowledge that nobody will be killing them during the night. You guys took a fairly scenic route, but you've destroyed the mafia.

Battle Mage - Mafia Goon - lynched day 7

pete d - Panamanian Villager - Survived
Porochaz - Panamanian Villager - Survived

Town wins!

[Patrick]

Roles

Mafia Godfather (Immune to investigations and nightkills): Bookitty
Mafia Goons: Battle Mage, curiouskarmadog
Cop (sane): Streeflo/Setael
Masons: Albert B. Rampage, Gage/Shanba
One shot Vigilante: Kakeng/vollkan
Panamanian Villagers: Everyone else

Nightactions

Night 1
Mafia kills nobody
Streeflo (cop) investigates Mastermind of Sin (innocent)
Vollkan (one shot vig) doesn't kill

Night 2
Mafia kills nobody
Streeflo (cop) investigates Setael (innocent)
Vollkan (one shot vig) kills Setael

Night 3
Mafia kills Albert B. Rampage
Setael (cop) investigates Porochaz (innocent)

Night 4
Mafia kills Shanba
Setael (cop) investigates pete d (innocent)

Night 5
Mafia kills Setael
Setael (cop) investigates Dragon Phoenix (innocent)

Night 6
Mafia kills Mastermind of Sin

[Patrick]

A few thoughts about the game:

I feel the setup pretty clearly favours the town. I think it would be balanced with 2 fewer vanilla townies and without the vig, which would make it the same as a mini normal I ran a while back. I played a small part in helping Aimee review it, and was pretty sure the game was supposed to contain a mafia roleblocker and one other difference, but Aimee apparently changed it late on without telling me.

As for the game itself, I thought the mafia was screwed early on, when Battle Mage was the only one left and with the luggage of being a claimed doctor which stopped him killing the cop easily. I was suprised that the mafia failed to send in any nightkills at all for the first two nights. I was also suprised that Battle Mage wasn't lynched as soon as Setael was nightkilled, even though it was reasonable to see Dragon Phoenix as a possible accomplice. Battle Mage seemed to be the obvious lynch there. But there was no real way he could have talked himself out of the endgame anyway.

Thanks to everyone who replaced into this game and made my job easier (doubly thanks to Setael). I hope it was enjoyed despite the somewhat unbalanced setup.