Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[farside22]

farside, you realize that Alko is defending you, right?

Yes, but that doesn't change my mind on his play. Should I applaud someone I felt on my read didn't really offer much in his defense because he is defending me? Beside it seems the votes against me are a game that Pooky wants to play and if people are serious about it I better get a good reason.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Alko

The answer is in those three posts you just quoted

Look at them again. Look at what he is saying.

[Battle Mage]

see V/LA thread

[Monkey]

I'm not really understanding Pooky's plan so to speak .. meh.

I'll keep my vote on wolfcrier's replacement for now, it's been more then three hours.

[al_kohaulec]

@Pooky,

I can see a possibility of it when reading those posts, but to me it's not enough evidence, yet. I would prefer to see more from their interaction (which regrettable isn't possible anymore) before acting on it, but I feel that evidence is inadequate to convince me.

[curiouskarmadog]

CDK:

What part of Al-Ko post 577 was adequate? Really the only one to say it was adequate and joined this game of Pooky's. Really don't get the game.

I found his overall statement exceptable and I thought it could make sense.

[curiouskarmadog]

unvote

though.

not seeing farside's play as scummy, seems to be contributing and actively scum hunting (even though it is against the grain)..Pooky, your thoughts on Far's last 2-3 posts?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Scum can seem to actively scumhunt.

Not really much of an indicator of anything imo.

kill her.

[RossWilliam]

pooky you're gonna have to put it into extremely simple terms before I vote her. I'm the confused one, remember? it's actually a pretty accurate depiction right now. how does lynching farside work?

[curiouskarmadog]

Scum can seem to actively scumhunt.

Not really much of an indicator of anything imo.

kill her.

what about jdga? wasnt wolf one of those that "crumbled" under your pressure?

[farside22]

@pooky:

Do I get to have questions answered or do you ignore me for the rest of the game?

[Talitha]

unvote: wolfcrier's replacement
vote: farside22

a) This is a deadlined day, we need to lynch somebloddy.
b) After a little consideration, I think she is less likely to be the jester than my previous vote
c) The 3 CB posts that Alko quoted in 771 were interesting. I believe it's likely that when someone says they are equally happy voting either of two players they are lying and one of the vote options is a scum partner. The 3rd post was interesting too after the 2nd one.. no vote switch or threat of vote switch.
d) But mainly a).
But also
e) Pro-Pooky bias.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

*huggles Tali*

Alas Farside, the rest of the game for you will be very soon.

[Sarcastro]

Hey guys, let's see if we can actually lynch Farside before the deadline.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Let's look at Wolfcrier/RossWilliam Interaction.

Wolfcrier:Vote RossWilliam
RossWilliam:Nearly Nothing.

Now Capt. Bandwagon jumps in with a comment "I think Wolf and RW r bussing. VOTE RossWilliam"

Frankly it's the most BS way to support a scumcomrade I've ever seen, "I think he is bussing someone, I think he's scum, so let me put my vote with his vote and support him and push rosswillaim towards a lynch"

Something here does not click. Frankly that statement is full of crap. I'd love to know why scum would decide to "bus" their partners on day one of a closed set up where they have no idea how many baddies are out there and whether bussing would help their cause considering that they could end up being easy targets for a nightkill by a rival group if they should look protown.

Basically what happens if RW gets lynched and shows up town? OH WELL I GUESS WOLFCRIER WASNT BUSSING, it sets up the "RW wasn't scum, thus WC wasn't bussing thus WC is innocent" faulty line of reasoning for later.

It's one of those supporting attacks that not only sets up for when RW shows up innocent but pretty much scripts it out.

But lastly, EVEN IF YOU DO BELIEVE WOLFCRIER IS BUSSING RW, you do not vote RW, you vote WC. Holding RW responsible for what you believe is "bussing" on WC's part is so ass-backwards it's ludicrous.

Yes.

This is the part where you go,

"WOW POOKY WHAT A BRILLIANT ANALYSIS OF THE SITUATION, YOU ARE FREAAAAAAKING GENIUS, I WISH I COULD BE PART OF YOUR FANCLUB"

and then vote this cartoon dog.

[curiouskarmadog]

couldnt it be that it was faulty logic from a less than stable/permenant player? Wouldnt lynching wolf tell us more about the situation?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

How does lynching Wolf tell us more?

[RossWilliam]

pooky, i get what your saying, and i'm glad you spelled it out, because i wouldn't have thought of that, and now that I see it, it's enough to make me vote farside. I feel really bad cause you just replaced into a really bad spot, and didn't really have much chance to change things, but you gotta do what you gotta do. Sorry farside.

vote: farside22

[tyhess]

could we possibly get a vote count??? thanks....

[al_kohaulec]

Let's look at Wolfcrier/RossWilliam Interaction.

Wolfcrier:Vote RossWilliam
RossWilliam:Nearly Nothing.

Now Capt. Bandwagon jumps in with a comment "I think Wolf and RW r bussing. VOTE RossWilliam"

Frankly it's the most BS way to support a scumcomrade I've ever seen, "I think he is bussing someone, I think he's scum, so let me put my vote with his vote and support him and push rosswillaim towards a lynch"

Something here does not click. Frankly that statement is full of crap. I'd love to know why scum would decide to "bus" their partners on day one of a closed set up where they have no idea how many baddies are out there and whether bussing would help their cause considering that they could end up being easy targets for a nightkill by a rival group if they should look protown.

Basically what happens if RW gets lynched and shows up town? OH WELL I GUESS WOLFCRIER WASNT BUSSING, it sets up the "RW wasn't scum, thus WC wasn't bussing thus WC is innocent" faulty line of reasoning for later.

It's one of those supporting attacks that not only sets up for when RW shows up innocent but pretty much scripts it out.

But lastly, EVEN IF YOU DO BELIEVE WOLFCRIER IS BUSSING RW, you do not vote RW, you vote WC. Holding RW responsible for what you believe is "bussing" on WC's part is so ass-backwards it's ludicrous.

Yes.

This is the part where you go,

"WOW POOKY WHAT A BRILLIANT ANALYSIS OF THE SITUATION, YOU ARE FREAAAAAAKING GENIUS, I WISH I COULD BE PART OF YOUR FANCLUB"

and then vote this cartoon dog.

WOW POOKY WHAT A BRILLIANT ANALYSIS OF THE SITUATION, YOU ARE FREAAAAAAKING GENIUS, I WISH I COULD BE PART OF YOUR FANCLUB

That first part was the explanation I was looking for. I'm kind of disappointed I missed something that simple.

Vote: Farside

This is what I have for the vote count

D2 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (tyhess)

JDGA - 3

(hasdgfas, petroleumjelly, Monkey)

RossWilliam - 1

(Holy)

Monkey - 1

(Mastermind of Sin)

QuickBen - 1

(MeMe)

farside22 - 5

(PookyTheMagicalBear, Sarcastro, Talitha, RossWilliam, alky )
alko - 1 farside

Not Voting - 6

(QuickBen,

Cult of the Couch (1)

, Iammars, JDGA, Battle Mage, curiouskarmadog)

[Holy]

@farside22: Well my lady, although not "huge", I believe I've sound my concerns clearly and regularly. And welcome to the town. Btw, I believe your PBPA is unfinished, please carry on... ~.^

Hiyas!

Oh, hello there!




Hm, I must admit, I'm quite interested with Pooky's case ~.~;

[MeMe]

unvote: QuickBen
vote: farside22

L-3

[MeMe]

L-4. Whatever.

[curiouskarmadog]

Now Capt. Bandwagon jumps in with a comment "I think Wolf and RW r bussing. VOTE RossWilliam"

Frankly it's the most BS way to support a scumcomrade I've ever seen, "I think he is bussing someone, I think he's scum, so let me put my vote with his vote and support him and push rosswillaim towards a lynch"

Person A(CP) votes Person B (wolf) beause he thinks that B is bussing C (RW). But then votes C beause A think B and C are scum together...

no I guess you are right...voting person B will not give you any more information about A and C....I think I got the formula wrong with the replacements...

I bow to your genius...I guess.

vote farside

[farside22]

Well I want an opportunity to say something since this is a deadline and no one is giving me a chance I am allowed to claim. IF you choose to lynch still go look at pooky and the person I voted against before he conviently changed his vote to lynch me.
I agree with GS this game sucks if no one listens.

I am the doctor.