Thespival Mafia (Denouement)

[wolfcrier]

well in my defence hasdgfas /PJ I would like you to notice this post I made

ok my bad the post started blending together and it was GREASY SPOT who is being hypocritical and illogical therefore Vote: Greasy Spot

Seeing as though I've said five times to reread that post and none of you had..... this probably won't change your minds but whatever, I contributed.

[hasdgfas]

that's

contribution?

[petroleumjelly]

The post you just quoted read to me more like a vote meant to solidify a Greasy Spot lynch than it read to me like a player who was interested in hunting scum. This is evidenced by my questioning your reasoning (that Greasy Spot was "hypocritical" and "illogical"), and as well as the context of your vote (eighth or ninth, or whatever it was).

Contribution =/= hunting for scum. Your posts have not given me any vibes of actually being interested in scum-hunting as of yet.

[Sarcastro]

I wish I knew how to tell the difference between newbie scum and newbie town.

[Thesp]

Official D2 Vote Count

Note:

Cult of the Couch Members:

1 (tyhess)

wolfcrier - 2

(hasdgfas, petroleumjelly)

RossWilliam - 5

(PookyTheMagicalBear, Sarcastro, Battle Mage, curiouskarmadog, Captain Bandwagon)

Monkey - 2

(Holy, Mastermind of Sin)

Sarastro - 2

(MeMe, Monkey)

Not Voting - 7

(Talitha, QuickBen,

Cult of the Couch (1)

, Iammars, wolfcrier, RossWilliam, al_kohaulec)

With 18 alive, it's 10 to lynch.

[Battle Mage]

up nvm disregard that question!

i wish i could remember who is an alt and who isnt. This guy COULD be a Jester. Ross on the other hand, isnt.

BM

[hasdgfas]

tyhess claimed.

[Battle Mage]

tyhess claimed.

yeh, but that doesnt mean it is necessarily true.

[hasdgfas]

you believe...?

[Battle Mage]

you believe...?

Im not quite sure why he claimed. Its not likely he was going to be NKed in the immediate future, and he might have been lynched. I can certainly see it as a role, but we cant be absolutely CERTAIN.

BM

[curiouskarmadog]

well, I am quite curious why he claimed..there was no reason to that I can see..Tyhesss, care to shed some light on it?

BM, is there any reason that you can think of that he would have claimed jester if he wasnt?

[Battle Mage]

Scum? lawl.

[Monkey]

EBWOP

Mod, could you please delete the prior post?

Prior post deleted to restore balance to the universe - only tag correction going on here. -Thesp

Sorry for the lack of posts, been working double time at work ..

An alt of who?

Nanookthewolf

I'll give you a hint. If Sarcastro is a good player, and he is scum, do you really think he will intentionally act as scummy as possible, UNLESS he is trying to come across as the Jester?

Are you positive that he's TRYING to act as scummy as possible, and not just slipping. Good players make mistakes too.

1.

So you think he is just a really shite mafioso who wants to get lynched???

2.

Dont give me that bull. If you think he is scum, at least come up with a credible motive for his play, instead of defensively disagreeing with everything i have said, as if its merely my opinion, and not basic fact.

1. Those are your words, not mine.

2. A credible motive for his play? I explained why I was voting for the guy, why do you continue to defend him? .. and for the record it is merely your opinion and not basic fact. You have not shown me one bit of objective material on Sarcastro, just subjective which is considered opinion.

I dont understand what you mean by that quote from MeMe. Please feel free to explain.

Actually Meme is the one who said it in the past, so feel free to ask Meme what she meant by it. On a serious note though, it just means that you are constantly answering for him, and I wouldn't mind hearing his logic behing what you call basic fact instead of hearing from you when you're not the person I'm "attacking".

I mean we're not in day 1 anymore randomly voting people.

Ehh, I really thought that we voted the scum on day 1 .

Yeah, so did I, the random voting was referred to the beginning of day 1 though btw.

Now in light of Tyhess's claim, and no counter as of yet .. I'm sticking with my vote for now.

[Monkey]

Sorry for the lack of posts, been working double time at work ..

An alt of who?

Nanookthewolf

I'll give you a hint. If Sarcastro is a good player, and he is scum, do you really think he will intentionally act as scummy as possible, UNLESS he is trying to come across as the Jester?

Are you positive that he's TRYING to act as scummy as possible, and not just slipping. Good players make mistakes too.

1.

So you think he is just a really shite mafioso who wants to get lynched???

2.

Dont give me that bull. If you think he is scum, at least come up with a credible motive for his play, instead of defensively disagreeing with everything i have said, as if its merely my opinion, and not basic fact.

1. Those are your words, not mine.

2. A credible motive for his play? I explained why I was voting for the guy, why do you continue to defend him? .. and for the record it is merely your opinion and not basic fact. You have not shown me one bit of objective material on Sarcastro, just subjective which is considered opinion.

I dont understand what you mean by that quote from MeMe. Please feel free to explain.

Actually Meme is the one who said it in the past, so feel free to ask Meme what she meant by it. On a serious note though, it just means that you are constantly answering for him, and I wouldn't mind hearing his logic behing what you call basic fact instead of hearing from you when you're not the person I'm "attacking".

I mean we're not in day 1 anymore randomly voting people.

Ehh, I really thought that we voted the scum on day 1 .

Yeah, so did I, the random voting was referred to the beginning of day 1 though btw.

Now in light of Tyhess's claim, and no counter as of yet .. I'm sticking with my vote for now.

[Sarcastro]

Out of curiosity, am I the only one for whom this whole page is formatted very strangely?

Anyway, I finally remembered to read the rest of the game. It was kind of a waste of time, really.

Dear MeMe,

Please stop voting for me.

Yours sincerely,
Sarc.

RW is still scum. Monkey, too. In fact, everybody expressing suspicion of Sarc should be shot, just to be safe.

[Thesp]

Out of curiosity, am I the only one for whom this whole page is formatted very strangely?

It was for me as well - the offending post has been deleted and humanity has been saved. Sorry, it was just a power outage from a car hitting an electrical pole.

[MeMe]

Dear MeMe,

Please stop voting for me.

Yours sincerely,
Sarc.

Dear Sarc,

OK.

unvote: Sarcastro

xoxo,
MeMe

P.S.

vote: QuickBen

[tyhess]

seriously MeMe?

[MeMe]

It's bolded and everything.

[curiouskarmadog]

tyhess please answer this question for me.

curious though, tyhess why did you tell us?

[al_kohaulec]

Yes, tyhess, I'm curious. Why did you share with us that you are the jester?

[Holy]

I wish I knew how to tell the difference between newbie scum and newbie town.

Their boldness with their mistakes or their feeble scumhunting, meh.

FOS: wolfcrier

for it.

[Battle Mage]

I'll give you a hint. If Sarcastro is a good player, and he is scum, do you really think he will intentionally act as scummy as possible, UNLESS he is trying to come across as the Jester?

Are you positive that he's TRYING to act as scummy as possible, and not just slipping. Good players make mistakes too.

Hammering a townie with no reasoning Day 1?
Making silly comments and ridiculous votes Day 2?
I dont think anyone sane would be able to call those 'slips'...

I dont understand what you mean by that quote from MeMe. Please feel free to explain.

Actually Meme is the one who said it in the past, so feel free to ask Meme what she meant by it. On a serious note though, it just means that you are constantly answering for him, and I wouldn't mind hearing his logic behing what you call basic fact instead of hearing from you when you're not the person I'm "attacking".

The words 'tough shit' spring to mind. If you attack based on bad logic, i'll call you on it, and request an explanation. I dont quite know how you think i am answering for Sarc-he isnt exactly going to come forward and claim Jester now, is he?
I dont understand your stubbornness on this. We both agree that his play has been scummy, yet you have neglected to put this into context.

I mean we're not in day 1 anymore randomly voting people.

Ehh, I really thought that we voted the scum on day 1 .

Yeah, so did I, the random voting was referred to the beginning of day 1 though btw.

Now in light of Tyhess's claim, and no counter as of yet .. I'm sticking with my vote for now.

No counter? Tyhess claimed Jester. Jester wants to get lynched. I dont think he actually gives a damn whether we catch scum or not. lol

Oh and while im at it, ive had another thought. Maybe Tyhess claimed Jester inexpicably in order to make us think 'why the heck has he done that' and vote for him, when he actually is the Jester. Just some WIFOM i thought of.

BM

[Sarcastro]

You know, I think I'm starting to like the new-and-improved BM.

For the record, though, I don't think it's fair to say that my D1 hammer had "no reasoning" behind it. The reasoning was that ten other people found Greasy Spot scummy and I felt that ending the day would be good. I don't like really long days, as anyone who's played with me knows.

And my "votes" today (all one of them) have not been ridiculous. So I jumped on a bandwagon. As I suspected then and have now confirmed, it was a good bandwagon, and we should lynch RW. And even if it hadn't been, so what? Did I misread the rules? Do we only get one vote for the entire day? I swear, some people are more conservative with their votes than Ann Coulter.

In conclusion, let's lynch RW. Also, Monkey is probably just newbie-town, but he's still really annoying me right now.

[Monkey]

Anyway, I finally remembered to read the rest of the game. It was kind of a waste of time, really.

Unvote: Sarcastro