Mini 547 - Youthville - Abandoned on Day Three!

[TrustGossip]

The 'What did I tell ye' Votecount

Voting

shaka!! – 0 (

)

Curt

– 2 (

Greasy Spot, Monkey

)

TrustGossip

– 2 (

Cyberbob, CFK

)
Rime Ice Fury – 0 (

)
Vel-Rahn Koon - 0 (

)

Cyberbob

- 1 (

OhGodMyLife

)
Greasy Spot – 0 (

)
Cephrir - 0 (

)
CFK – 0 (

)

Monkey

– 1 (

Cephrir

)

angelmouse

– 1 (

Curt

)

OhGodMyLife

- 2 (

TrustGossip, Rime Ice Fury

)

Not Voting

– 3 (

angelmouse, Vel-Rahn Koon, Shaka!!

)

For starters, my vote on Trustgossip still stands. I have included the reasons why in my earlier posts (#53 & #65).

My original reasons for voting Cephir stemmed from how he made me uncomfortable with his playstyle. Most of his reasonings for his arguments came were deferred from a preexisting ruleset (reliance on the wiki) instead of taken as face value.

At the current time, there hasn't been much further development from Cephir and consensus for pressuring him is low, so there's really no need for me to continue binding my vote to him.

Unvote

Will hunt around for the most suitable candidate shortly.

[Cephrir]

My original reasons for voting Cephir stemmed from how he made me uncomfortable with his playstyle.

Playstyle. Exactly. I may try to come up with someone to vote for soon, but studying for mid-terms takes precedence. Probably.

[Nekka-Lucifer]

Curt has not picked up his prod, replyed to his prod or posted in this game since the prod and so am seeking a replacement for him

[Cephrir]

Mod

, please prod Vel-Rahn Koon if you haven't recently.

[Nekka-Lucifer]

pickemgenius will replace Curt. Effective on confirmation.

[Greasy Spot]

Since we will have a new Curt, hopefully.

unvote Curt

[angelmouse]

I really don't think i have much to say to be honest. The whole game seems to be a series of over reactions to over reactions, which isn't altogether bad, just thats as far as we have gotten. Although i do have one point.

OMGMY does seem to be voting for people who voted him though since he came back in a OMGUS kinda way. RIF votes him for lucking, (which i have to say is not the best reason for voting at all. voting lurkers shouldn't be a reason unless their posts are few and very far between, but enough to keep them in the game, and unhelpful), then OMGMY votes for him for this reason. Cyberbob then says

I didn't like the way OhGodMyLife tried to hide his OMGUS behind a few fairly empty accusations (the lurkervoting in particular being false), either.

FOS:OhGodMyLife

and then OMGMY changes his vote to him stating it was about the flimsy way he got behind a TG waggon. Sadly i see the reasons you voted Cyberbob as just as flimsy as Cyberbob's reason for voting TG which puts gives you a

FOS: OMGMY

from me.

[angelmouse]

Also Greasy you have been very inactive and then you come back only to add

Since we will have a new Curt, hopefully.

unvote Curt

The last couple of posts have been banter about Monkey getting maried and nothing substantial really for a long time, which bothers me. I know i have been unactive for a couple of pages but that was down to person reasons which i stated in the thread and before that i was active. You on the other hand have had no reason to be quiet and have been active elseware on the site....something i find odd and slightly suspicious. If anyone deserved a lurkers vote it's you.

Also Hello to pickemgenius.

[pickemgenius]

sup all

[Greasy Spot]

@ Angelmouse: As you stated everything seems to have quieted down. Everything seems to have come back full circle from the beginning. No front runners and not enough to go on to cast a full fledged vote.

@pickem: Welcome. I hope you are more into game play than your predecessor.

[pickemgenius]

@pickem: Welcome. I hope you are more into game play than your predecessor.

away for 3 months and still average 4 posts a day.

posting won't be a problem.

on that note, i'll be doing my analysis crap later tonight.

[pickemgenius]

If the Mod hasn't told us, then it's a closed setup game and he won't tell us. Usually tho, there's 3 Mafia in a 12 player game, although I've seen as many as 5 in 1 scum group. There's also the possibility that we have a SK in addition to the Mafia, so we could see multiple night kills.

Didn't he ask how much mafia were in the game? Why bring up the SK?

Two trains of thought occured to me aswell upon reading VRK's post.
Your thinking was what I first thought of, and a legitimate question at that, and what to me appears to be a springboard to kill random voting almost. (but random voting is soooooo fun! ) Town vibes from this post.

Random

Vote: angelmouse

Didn't he ask how much mafia were in the game? Why bring up the SK?

Why not? He's a relatively new player, he may not know SKs are a possibility in Minis, etc.

I would have liked to see VRK give me this answer Ceph, but this was indeed the second line of reasoning I thought of upon reading the post.

Unvote, Vote: Curt

for not following the mod's directions in confirming.

Seems like a great place to start a bandwagon

.

Random early bandwagons-good.
Reasonless early bandwagons-bad.

Well, if we're lucky, maybe he won't follow the mod's directions when trying to place a kill tonight (that is of course IF he's mafia).

One could hope, right?

Can't say that I concur with it being a great place to start a wagon though, but good try.

Unvote: RimeIceFury

Funny gut like stuff from this.

I was only trying to get started. I'm not the biggest fan of random voting or simply reading too much into random voting either. I was only trying to provoke a reaction, which it did from you. Now i can

Unvote

knowing that at leat we have started off a discussion.

Not a huge fan of the unvote (no danger of a QL with 3 votes only) but otherwise I approve of your reaction getting from monkey.

Liking post #37(Cephrir)

I never stated that I thought that he was in danger of lynch, what I did state was that with him being run up @ the time,

I was more afraid of a town's role being revealed earlier on

(If I remember correctly), as that's something I've seen happen in a few games that I've read here on the site .. You know mass claims and the like only give scum the upper hand.

Thanks for calling me town.

Ceph wins the TG/Ceph tussle.

How ever you barely pressured, you voted, you got one reply and you unvoted.

QFT

2 things on this:
1.

ANGEL HAS GOTTEN MORE THEN ONE REPLY FROM HER VOTE/UNVOTE DAMMIT!

2. Solid posting by Monkey

Boo post 65 (TG)

Sorry for the inactivity. I have been involved in some other games and a lot of work too. I will read thru everything and post a little later.

It's a little later now .. like 25 hours later since the last post of this game was made. I'll make the assumption that the majority of the players are waiting on you Greasyspot ....

more of letting TG getting "attacked" and Monkey sitting in the background not say anything.

Not digging Greasy's weird posting on page 3...

Page 3 was an extension of 2 with more animosity towards each other. I think

you guys

jumping on Angelmouse is premature.

FOSmonkey

Underlining mine ...

Yet I'm the only one who receives an fos

Did you read the game, really Greasy Spot?

That's all you got?

I know it's only an fos, and by no means am I completely upset by it, but had you only fos'd one other player who questioned the angelmouse bit, I'd be asking you the same questions.

Alot of this appears to have already been said before by someone else. More sitting in the background not saying much here.

I found this a little reaching as well but I'm not going to FoS you, I think you are just a townie who is a little out of their depth

huh?

In general digging alot of Bob's posting on page 4.

I'm OK with CFK's attempt to get more from greasy(who fails to comply).

Vote: Curt

The inactivity in this game is very hard to deal with, so I suggest voting out one of the players who is so inactive, since our mod doesn't seem to want to prod/replace these players.

Curt's last post was on the 13th.

And when exactly was your last meaningful post?

Actively lurking is way worse...


why isn't monkey dead yet exactly????

VOTE: MONKEY

[TrustGossip]

Noticed something.

Vote: Rime Ice Fury

for voting lurkers on two different occasions and for the scummy way he voted for TrustGossip.

And Cyberbob barnacling to RIF's reasonings is ignored? Especially since the case mostly consists of "this last sentence has two meanings!!!".

Response required from all three of you.

[TrustGossip]

@pickem: Monkey's going to say: "There's nothing to comment on." Much like most of the players in this game.





P.S. THIS IS A SUPER SECRET PLOY TO GET MONKEY TO SAY SOMETHING USEFUL INSTEAD OF THE ABOVE POSTULATED COMMENT.

DON'T SAY ANYTHING, OUR LITTLE SECRET.

[pickemgenius]

@pickem: Monkey's going to say: "There's nothing to comment on." Much like most of the players in this game.

I noticed his activity levels have been as such:

b
e o
e o
e o
w o

start: end.

It's like when people started to say stuff about him, he kind of just sideskirted the issue, and then something new arose, and he just sat in the background and didn't say anything at all.

he needs more deadness...

[Cyberbob]

And Cyberbob barnacling to RIF's reasonings is ignored? Especially since the case mostly consists of "this last sentence has two meanings!!!".

You would be correct were it not for the fact that I'm not, and it doesn't. Try reading it again.

As for a Monkey lynch... yeah, I can see that. I want to see how he reacts to these accusations before changing my vote, though.

[TrustGossip]

I don't quite understand here, as in your earlier post you said that Cephir was full of WIFOM and then proceeded to FOS him. Now the arguments that I used to convince you that Cephir was being WIFOM are WIFOM in themselves?

Sorry, I got confused; I mixed yours and Cephrir's posts together a little bit in my mind.

I'm not inclined to believe your powers of recall are effective at all, so maybe

you

should reread it again.

[CFK]

In general digging alot of Bob's posting on page 4

How exactly?

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Sorry again folks. RL work slam.

I'm still not happy with TG, especially this:

My original reasons for voting Cephir stemmed from how he made me uncomfortable with his playstyle. Most of his reasonings for his arguments came were deferred from a preexisting ruleset (reliance on the wiki) instead of taken as face value.

At the current time, there hasn't been much further development from Cephir and consensus for pressuring him is low, so there's really no need for me to continue binding my vote to him.

Unvote

Will hunt around for the most suitable candidate shortly.

Why unvote based on what everyone else is doing?

Welcome peg! I'm not too convinced as to Monkey's scumminess. I see exactly what you're pointing towards in post 161, but his join date makes me hesitate to vote based on that fact that he could just be making noob mistakes.

If I had to vote right now I think I would vote for TG, but with the first 4 pages being a lot of craziness that we're not even through sorting out, voting at this point would be premature for me.

[TrustGossip]

Why unvote based on what everyone else is doing?

Because I realize my analysis of Cephir was overly aggressive and some points were tenuous, but given the amount of information available at that stage of the game, I still stand by my initial suspicions.

At this stage though, I'm more displeased with Cyberbob. You peeked back after a period of inactivity and that was the best answer to my inquiry that you could come up with?

-_-

FOS: Cyberbob

[Cyberbob]

At this stage though, I'm more displeased with Cyberbob. You peeked back after a period of inactivity and that was the best answer to my inquiry that you could come up with?

-_-

FOS: Cyberbob

O noze, anything but your

displeasure

!

[shaka!!]

If I had to vote right now I think I would vote for TG, but with the first 4 pages being a lot of craziness that we're not even through sorting out, voting at this point would be premature for me.

Would you care to share some of that craziness with the rest of us? I'm keen for some discussion right now.

[pickemgenius]

Welcome peg! I'm not too convinced as to Monkey's scumminess. I see exactly what you're pointing towards in post 161, but his join date makes me hesitate to vote based on that fact that he could just be making noob mistakes.

Noob mistakes only count(for me) in newbie games...

[TrustGossip]

At this stage though, I'm more displeased with Cyberbob. You peeked back after a period of inactivity and that was the best answer to my inquiry that you could come up with?

-_-

FOS: Cyberbob

O noze, anything but your

displeasure

!

Gee! Your post was ever so helpful to the town! You deserve a gold star for grade A scumhunting! I'm so glad you aren't one of those people so blinded by OMGUS that they fail to make any meaningful contribution!

Yay!

[TrustGossip]

In other words, please don't wave away my argument because you think it's crap. Tell me why it's crap. Convince other people it's crap. If you really like this wagon on me, convince other people to vote me. Shoving a dismissive one-liner in my face isn't helping anyone.