The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[Internet Stranger]

Heh, it looks like someone doesnt read the mafia games he is on (Gurgi).

Uraj is right, there is nothing special about me. Im no different than anyone else. Just remember to check up on Coolbot and Korais, that hasnt changed yet. That doesnt mean for cops to check them either, they can do whatever the hell they want. Im just leaving a legacy in case of an involuntary departure.

Im also surpised this day hasnt ended yet. I remember the old days being a hell of a lot more vicious.

[Lord Gurgi]

oops Never targetted again? sounds a little funny.

[Tigris]

*agrees with IS* let's end the day and get replacements for anyone that doesn't respond to a pm

Btw, can I use my extra vote on koraiss on jedi as well ^_^ *feels special for the ability to have two votes for some reason ^_~*

[mikehart]

Vote Count

jediknight

( 11 ) -

Corsato, coolbot, Jaylen, MMCL, Gaspode, Argoti, Internet Stranger, the silent speaker, Tigris, Rick, Flying Dutchman

Flying Dutchman

( 2 ) -

Lord Gurgi, Murk

Lord Gurgi

( 1 ) -

jediknight

Yaw

( 1 ) -

korais666

korais666

( 2 ) -

Mr. Flay, thesilentspeaker

Ibanez asked to be replaced so i will look for one

[drummer97531]

Tigris, I assume that has something to do with your role? And have all those people posted yet?

[mikehart]

no Tigris has no extra vote, it was my mistake.

[indentureddjinn]

sorry still reading thred, get back to you tomorrow

[MMCL]

FOS: Indentureddjinn

He's been reading the thread for ages

[Corsato]

It can be usefull, you should try it for a change....

[Yaw]

Alright, I'll compromise to avoid this dragging out. My vote will go back on when both Uraj and indentureddjinn have posted actual content, or 24 hours after this post. I don't expect to hear from the other people on my list, and expect most of them will be replaced shortly.

[mikehart]

Effective immediately, Yggdrasil will replace Ibanez

[Mr. Flay]

I suppose I understand what people are saying about IS, so I'll drop the issue barring some evidence to the contrary. He's too good to lose on a hunch, it seems...besides we agree on one point: I still think Korias666's theories stink and will keep an eye on him, but jediknight is a dead duck at this point. Ural45 and IndenturedDjinn have had plenty of time to read, either they're clueless or stalling.

Since we seem to be only at 11 votes still (I thought I counted 12), I'll

unvote: Korias666

and

Vote: JediKnight

to put him out of our misery. Yaw or somebody else who retracted their vote can decide when they're done waiting.

[Yggdrasil]

Hello, I'm the replacement for the replacement. I just did a quick read-through which confused the hell out of me, but I'll try to post some innitial thoughts.

Just based off of my quick read-through, I'm inclined to vote jediknight just because his role claim seems out-there. Even if he is telling the truth, the role doesn't seem much use to us unless we want to have a cop confirm his innocence and/or have Thorin (an important character in the book IIRC) claim, both of which are not good ideas. However, I'm hesistant to put that vote before I look at everything else more closely.

[Uraj45]

I did indeed post my opinions on the bandwagon as well as on IS and his strategy. Don't really know why you guys are saying i haven't posted any content. . .

[Internet Stranger]

Why is Uraj lurking? I want the mod to prod him.

[Lord Gurgi]

Heh, it looks like someone doesnt read the mafia games he is on (Gurgi).

Right back at you.
What's going to happen to jedi? Someone vote, Unvote?

[mikehart]

Vote Count

jediknight

( 12 ) -

Corsato, coolbot, Jaylen, MMCL, Gaspode, Argoti, Internet Stranger, the silent speaker, Tigris, Rick, Flying Dutchman, Mr.Flay

Flying Dutchman

( 2 ) -

Lord Gurgi, Murk

Lord Gurgi

( 1 ) -

jediknight

Yaw

( 1 ) -

korais666

[drummer97531]

I will be out of town from Sunday the 25th until wednesday or thursday.

[Corsato]

OK. so we're waiting for someone else to vote?
Of the 9 players not voting there must be someone who actually has a thought about this??

[Yaw]

Well, 24 hours is up and I'm a man of my word.

Vote: jediknight

SATH: indentureddjinn

for non-participation. We can determine if that's scummy rather than annoying tomorrow.

[Mr. Flay]

Does dragonmaster know mikehart as well? There are 0 posts from him in the queue. This thing with no in-thread confirms from people who know mikehart is annoying...

Anyway, since we're in twilight, I'll ask: Yaw, what is SATH? "Suspicious As The..." is all I could get out of it. I agree though, Indentureddjinn has had plenty of time to figure *something* out. Even Yggdrasil posted actual content already.

[Yaw]

Well, I confirmed by PM too, but that's personal choice.

SATH = Smack Across The Head. I needed something while in Paced Mafia (now finished) to indicate that I was annoyed with someone who at the time was pretty much a confirmed townie, so I invented that. It doesn't indicate scumminess, it indicates that the recipient of the smack should get their head out of their ass.

Note that I don't mean to imply here that indentureddjinn is a confirmed anything. I'm merely saying that he has to participate more and stop procrastinating, because the lurking is annoying. He may have legitimate reasons for it, I don't know. Just expressing my displeasure.

Feel free to use and proliferate SATHs.

[Yggdrasil]

SATH: Yaw

for assuming we knew what a SATH was.

I think I will enjoy SATHs

[Shivan_Dragon]

Hey everyone...I just got home about 2-3 hours ago, and I just glanced through the thread. Of course, there is a lot I might've missed, but this is what I've picked up so far:

IS - I've never played with him, so I don't know a thing about his style, but accusing 2 people on day one seems scummy to me.

Jedi - I don't buy your Galion role claim. I don't think he had an important enough role in the book to actually be put in this game, and your overly defensive arguments about Gollum "possibly" having a pro-town role makes you seem suspicious.

About the kills, we know that:
Smaug died to lightning (I can't think of anyone other than Gandalf; Sauron didn't appear anywhere in

The Hobbit

unless I'm very much mistaken).
The Troll died to Smaug...not much to say about that...
Nori had his head snapped (My first impression was Gollum, although I can see that the trolls could kill that way too. I doubt that the wargs would form a separate mafia group as they are supposedly very loyal to the goblins. I wonder how the eagles would kill if they are in this game at all...but I can't imagine them as anything but pro-town...)
And Elrond was gutted by a schimitar (Definately the mark of a goblin kill - that's the only way I see it as)

About the other roles, Bard would be in the game (I would presume a vig, probably now just a normal townie), since Smaug was in the game.
Beorn would probably be in the game too, considering the role he played in the book.

Lastly, a few questions:
Jedi, who did you target on night 1, if you targetted at all?
Does anyone have the role of the Elven King? It might help me decide whether or not to vote for Jedi.

I still have to read the thread in more depth...7+ pages, and I'm kinda tired, so I probably missed some stuff. I'll give my vote when I've had more time to read it through.

[MMCL]

Err... it's twilight by my count.... So I'm going to bed early.