Mini Normal 1888 - TwoFace Mafia - Game Over

[TwoFace]

Vote Count 3.01

WhemeStar - gerryoat (L-4)

Not Voting: DogWatch, FireScreamer, WhemeStar, ThinkBig, Eddie Cane, Barleycorn, Keyser Söze


With 8 players alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2017-03-31 09:24:40)

[ThinkBig]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

Occam's razor says that one of {Gerrygoat, Whemstar} is scum. I have a town lean on gerrygoat and so I think whemestar is probably scum.

[ThinkBig]

By PoE, the scum team is probably {WhemStar, FireScreamer, DogWatch}

[Barleycorn]

wheme is town methinks.

[ThinkBig]

Why do you think Wheme is town?

[Barleycorn]

where does your townlean on gerry come from?

where is the rest of your VCA? what specific conclusions did you get from it?

edit: as of now, just gut.

[Barleycorn]

btw tb i'm a mortfeld alt which i plan to kill after this game.

[ThinkBig]

I'm working on the rest of my VCA right now.

P-edit: Oh hello mortfeld <3

[Barleycorn]

where does your townlean on gerry come from?

[gerryoat]

who cares where it comes from, he's right. whether hes maf or town lol. one less mislynch for you to worry about

[Barleycorn]

^ troll quiet please

[gerryoat]

Not troll if it's true lol

[DogWatch]

in the process of catching up, sorry.

are we still popcorn claiming? what happened to that?

[DogWatch]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

this doesn't point to wheme being scum though.. if it's 10:3, we'd have to vote twice on him for scum to sweep the rest

[DogWatch]

it also doesn't clear anyone else in your post... so if you're town you're basing your reads off of a vote count mistake

[DogWatch]

your slot and wheme's were my biggest scum slots but I don't see you as partners at this point

come to think of it, after looking back at gerry's vote, I would expect scum!wheme to make a bigger fuss out of it.. he strikes me as the kind of player who, as town, would say fuck it and move on... he's like a slightly more coherent version of Momo in that regard, who I was obviously misreading

so maybe I'm leaning more wheme!town? ehh

[Keyser Söze]

Going to work down my D1/D2 town reads (obviously excluding Barleycorn - confirmed town).

First, DogWatch ISO.

[Barleycorn]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

Occam's razor says that one of {Gerrygoat, Whemstar} is scum. I have a town lean on gerrygoat and so I think whemestar is probably scum.

completely missed this argument somehow.

your scumread of wheme is mechanical. but with 8 alive it's 5 to lynch, which means that one vote by itself cannot lead to a quickhammer. so do you still scumread wheme, knowing that scum could not quickhammer town!wheme with just town!gerry's vote?

also, still waiting on explanation of where your town lean on gerry comes from.

hm, also curious how you used occam's razor to narrow your scumset. explain?

[Barleycorn]

VOTE: Aronagrundy

im town. this maf

You're playing different to town-gerry

elaborate please?

[Barleycorn]

wait i remember, you do elaborate. lemme read that.

[Barleycorn]

so who is mafs everyone?

'i'm not going to scum hunt mafs tee hee
and i'm going to make it look i don't cares'

keyset still scumreading gerry. i'll let you know when a townread develops.

bleh rereading this maybe arona(wheme) is scum. 252 is gross on its own. then arona actually ignores keyser's 347 (see 363 etc. where the eddie idea is completely dropped).

obviously can't ask arona about this, but why did you not follow up on 347 keyser?

369 looks like scum!arona trying to discredit town!keyser

376 looks like scum!arona backing off after town!keyser responds logically to his attempts to discredit. yet maintains "eh demagoguery is a thing"

fine gerry can be townish for 394 and maybe 387

ok i can get on board with scum!wheme. arona looks not good in these interactions. still would like to do more sorting.

[Barleycorn]

wait i remember, you do elaborate. lemme read that.

have to go so i'll find where your sr of gerry shifts later, unless you do it for me.

[Keyser Söze]

@Barley
Re: post 347 - forgot about this but it was a good question raised by me (I was looking at if he was asking to wagon Eddie based on his own read on Eddie or others) but re-reading the game his next-page subsequent attack on me (and weird vote on Gerry) naturally DIVERTED my attention.

[WhemeStar]

I'll try to reread sometime and figure something out. No promises though

Gerry get your vote off me

[WhemeStar]

Intent to vote: WhemeStar

Today is MyLo and I assume we are dealing with a standard 10:3 team. Gerrygoat places a vote on WhemStar nearly 24 hours ago. If WS was town, the scum team would have almost certainly have quick hammered WS by now (assuming GG is town). Eddie Cane and KS have also not shown any signs at a quick hammer.

Occam's razor says that one of {Gerrygoat, Whemstar} is scum. I have a town lean on gerrygoat and so I think whemestar is probably scum.

This is dumb btw