Star Wars Rogue One [GAME OVER]

[Heartless]

UNVOTE:

[BBmolla]

It's probably TWIE

why do you think this setup is broken though, I'm curious

[BBmolla]

it also could be mastin because the role pms blatantly don't state anything about the Death Star

[BBmolla]

The flipped scum role pms

[BBmolla]

Like not even a REDACTED section that could be plausibly it

[BBmolla]

TWIE's hammer seems really fucking dramatic though tbh

[TheWayItEnds]

either us or mastin goes then it's back to the same thing tomorrow

are both of us in question to you? bc that's the only way NL benefits

its weird to me that both of you are here, yes.

like if molla isnt scum its pretty fucking obvious why hes here.

[BBmolla]

either us or mastin goes then it's back to the same thing tomorrow

are both of us in question to you? bc that's the only way NL benefits

its weird to me that both of you are here, yes.

like if molla isnt scum its pretty fucking obvious why hes here.

cause ive been a deadweight?

what a shcoking revelation

[TheWayItEnds]

well no its not.

its fairly obvious tbh.

[BBmolla]

youre an ass

[TheWayItEnds]

oooh an accurate read.

try for a second one.

[Heartless]

No lynch is definitely the way to go here.

why do you think this setup is broken though, I'm curious

It's not necessarily

broken

and I don't think it's as unbalanced as Anti does, but the balance may be a little off. Scum got a considerable amount of power for town only getting a maximum of 5 powers, one of which being of questionable utility. :S
It's why we were toying with the idea of there being some form of traitor for a while. If that were the case, BBMolla would make sense as scum since he's been the one dragging his feet the most on the past couple lynches and his power on a fragmented scum team wouldn't completely break the balance. That said, I don't think it's that plausible that a traitor would not lose with the main team being eliminated. Isn't that the convention?

[BBmolla]

Typically yes. Are you assuming mastin is telling the truth?

[Heartless]

Yes. The claimed Death Star powers seem like logical, plausible counters to town powers.
If mastina was lying about the abilities, she'd probably do it in a way that made scum appear weak to keep you in the lynch pool.

[BBmolla]

Why is TWIE's LYLO strategy to be a complete fuckwad

[TheWayItEnds]

its MYLO actually

[BBmolla]

Why is TWIE's MYLO strategy to be a complete fuckwad

[Heartless]

i don't think it's a "strategy" i think this is just how twie is

[mastina]

Suggestion.

Normally, in mylo, we have two options: talk it out and try to decide on a lynch...
...OR, we no-lynch, have a player nightkilled, and go into lylo.

Heartless has been obvtown the entire game, which would normally give me a strong bias towards working with them to try and figure this out. But they are not conftown.

...Yet this game has something which alters the status quo: the underutilized, frequently outdated, Last Will.
How about we say nothing in-thread (so go without discussion, as to prevent tipping the scum off)...
...Except all of us PROMISING that we've updated our last wills to accurately reflect reads if we are the nightkill?

Basically, my plan is this:
We say nothing about reads publicly here in the thread.
We all spend as much time as we need privately reviewing the game. Posting prod-dodges, funny videos, off-topic conversations as needed, if necessary.
When everyone says they are ready, when everyone says they have updated their last wills and done their homework, we no-lynch.
...And then, when the scum nightkill a player, we have that player's input in lylo. The full benefit of them still alive, without the drawback of paranoia. The scum can't kill strategically because they're taking a shot in the dark--they wouldn't know the reads of the rest of the town, and what input they would provide. They wouldn't know what 1v1s would come up, which battles they could win, or not.

Firebringer SAID he wished towns used that mechanic more.
And this seems like the perfect fucking opportunity to utilize it to its maximum value.

Is this viable?

[Heartless]

Alright-y.

Spoiler:

[BBmolla]

VOTE: no lynch

[TheWayItEnds]

Why is TWIE's MYLO strategy to be a complete fuckwad

doesnt it feel better to accurately reflect the gamestate?

should try it more often.

[Firebringer]

Vote Count 7.01

No Lynch [L-2] BBMolla,

Not Voting - [3] Heartless, TheWayItEnds, Mastina

With 4 Alive, It Takes 3 To Lynch.

Mod Notes - May the flavor be with you.

Day 7 ends in (expired on 2017-03-26 02:26:20)!

[BBmolla]

Why is TWIE's MYLO strategy to be a complete fuckwad

doesnt it feel better to accurately reflect the gamestate?

should try it more often.

Doesn't it feel better to not be a fuckwad

[TheWayItEnds]

i dunno.

maybe if no one needed to be condescended to we could try it.