Mini 1891: Fat Boy Mafia [Over]

[TwoFace]

Well I don't really trust anyone else's opinion

[TwoFace]

I'll have to go back and look at the game I played where grey was scum and lynched. I don't remember that kind of reactions you are saying

[Persivul]

I'll have to go back and look at the game I played where grey was scum and lynched. I don't remember that kind of reactions you are saying

That would be good. Mine's from ongoing so I can't say more.

[-Grey-]

FWIW, Grey's reaction to his wagon seemed normal for him.

p-edit: I don't think so. In my albeit limited experience with him, scum!Grey would have panicked. Grey is generally overly concerned with his own standing as town, so I expect some reaction, but he didn't go overboard.

Without going into detail... do you really think I'd make the same mistake twice?

[Persivul]

Without going into detail... do you really think I'd make the same mistake twice?

Sure. People repeat mistakes all the time.

[-Grey-]

TIL how to pocket Persivul.

[TwoFace]

I challenge you grey to find evidence that my standard opinion of you is always scum.

Just throwing it out there cause it's impossible to do.

We have 2 completed games together. You were lynched as scum in 1, I was scum in the other. Any other game is ongoing but even if you could reference them, they wouldn't help you.

[-Grey-]

I don't give a fuck what you have to say, it's not going to stop me from believing what I believe and I'll make the same comment in any other games we play in together because you will jump to a scumread on me over stupid superficial bullshit so you might as well get used to seeing it.

[TwoFace]

So you just admitted you lied. So yeah scum caught. Thanks

[-Grey-]

Lol. You're about as simple as a first grade math book.

[Nosferatu]

which reminds me

@nexus

, you missed my vote in the VC (assuming there's no shenanigans).

Desperado remains an excellent vote.

pieg is town. Persivul is town. Wheme looks somewhat town, but not as town as I thought he likely would if he was town so we'll see. massive is likely town. Fire's decently likely town, his early tone felt off but i like his reads.

these kind of posts never bode well imo

yeah, it sucks, having to carry yet another game as town

thanks, I feel like I'm never heard with my struggles

[Nosferatu]

i think you're a townie quavering against the sr in your gut

Why is implosion town?

tone doesn't suck and i like his reads

you like them because his read of you is actually the most bullshit I've ever read in a sentence

[Nosferatu]

Grey
Pine
Implosion

Nosferatu
Fire
Prana
Persivul
TwoFace
Wheme

---------<--- line of lynchability

Desperado
Alz


VOTE: desperado

come on guys, most of the people on this list hadn't even posted yet, you cannot turn around and interpret this as a legit readlist

[Nosferatu]

the fact that pieg is perpetuating a read implosion has of him that he obviously knows is faulty is awful
VOTE: pieg

[Persivul]

I was already there and no one seemed to care. Maybe you'll be heard.

What do you think of Pine talking in memes?

[Nosferatu]

I was already there and no one seemed to care. Maybe you'll be heard.

What do you think of Pine talking in memes?

It's dumb and hopefully he'll stop. I don't see scum motivation. I seem to remember Pine playing along with the "moist" shenanigans that happened in our last game together so I'm pretty sure he just likes to fuck around in the early game. Probably just NAI.

[Alz]

His original reaction to getting run up, specifically the way he reacted to your vote specifically. Now his reaction to you again. They give me bad vibes

He was at L-2 on page 3. He questioned Percivul on why he put him at L-2 so fast. What seemed scummy to you in that?

[Nosferatu]

I was already there and no one seemed to care. Maybe you'll be heard.

What do you think of Pine talking in memes?

It's dumb and hopefully he'll stop. I don't see scum motivation. I seem to remember

Pine playing along with the "moist" shenanigans that happened in our last game together so I'm pretty sure he just likes to fuck around in the early game

. Probably just NAI.

nix that last bit. Still probably just NAI.

[TwoFace]

His original reaction to getting run up, specifically the way he reacted to your vote specifically. Now his reaction to you again. They give me bad vibes

He was at L-2 on page 3. He questioned Percivul on why he put him at L-2 so fast. What seemed scummy to you in that?

There was a conversation between them where grey's response and reaction didn't seem townie to me. It seemed more nervous scum. Let me go find it.

[TwoFace]

The L-2 didn't concern me. You being happy to put the wagon there on page 3 with nary a word of notice did because it put the wagon in lolhammer territory.

Ah, so two more people would have had to vote you without counting for an lolhammer...but it would have been

my

fault as the third-to-last guy for not giving a VC. Got it!

Considering you were the fifth vote in three pages with the other four spread out and not instantly visible to the next players to vote, yes your vote was fairly opportune. The way votes were rolling along, it is quite within the realm of possibility that two other players could have come along and joined the wagon for shiggles before I pointed it out myself. Which is why I did, because nobody else was going to.

And you can't exactly say d1 flash lynches never happen. And you also can't say scum is caught from them.

So yes, I do hold you more responsible for your position on the wagon than, say, WhemeStar.

This post. But the 2 right before it also didn't seem town to me either

[Persivul]

While I hate defending Grey, and he denies it himself, I think a lot of that is just Grey being unable to admit fault in any way.

[TwoFace]

We'll he's my strongest scum read ATM so I'm good with my vote. Nobody is making a compelling case to change my mind or vote

[implosion]

Re: pieg's early reads list. Note how all of the people who hadn't posted were lumped in the middle... they sorted everyone who had posted at that point, and it was the same way i'd lean for each person who had posted (except maybe pine). Desperado's reaction made it seem like pieg had completely arbitrarily listed people, which is clearly not true given that those who hadn't posted were in the middle. I also have no idea what he means by his "calling card."

Re: Wheme, I can't really describe my understanding of his style well; on a very vague level he seemed sort of like a generic new player to the site in the sense that he didn't really want to put him out there that much as scum, and straight asking people if they're scum feels sort of too overt of a thing for him to do as scum (I don't mean that in a too-scummy-to-be-scum way). It's not really that important; I suspect he'll make himself more readable in time. Again, it's not a strong read.

[Nosferatu]

how about pieg willfully letting implosion have a read that he knows is faulty in reasoning?

pedit: then why are some people who haven't posted in the readlist while some people aren't? Desperado frequently uses that readlist. If you can't see that as RVS idk what to tell you. HE EVEN JOKES ABOUT IT IN HIS NEXT POST.

[TwoFace]

Can I have a piece of your birthday cake?

Happy birthday btw