Mini 1875: Pine's Death Trap Post Game - Town win!

[Rautherdir]

I kind of have to agree with you there RC. I know I said to delay the lynch until Sunday, but now...

Yeah, sorry Fro99er.

VOTE: Fro99er

Why did you vote Fro99er here?

P-edit: Thank yee, viewed the game and LQ was there. The game we played together, he told me he can scumhunt using how people structure their posts. I've done it successfully with Alisae, as he posts run on sentences and has cute fluffy spam; however as scum, Alisae is on task and concise.

The main thing I'm doing with you right now is experimenting and seeing if how you format your posts here in this game, match up with your game in that one using timestamps as my independent variable.

That was when Fro99er was pretty much begging to be lynched. He even self-voted a few posts later.

It would be interesting to see if I alter my sentence structure in a future game where I am scum. Or even a game where I'm not a PR...

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Spoiler: I hate midterms

[Cooperative Sheep]

My reaction to Rauth this last page was a lot more negative, specifically because he committed my personal pet lie tell of providing a silly amount of details to a story that didn't need them. But before you go 'then why no vote move!?!' my reply is 'I also don't like MBG's one mislynch commentary' because that also reads iffy to me, and maintains his scum lead.
I think it's safe to say that no scum targeted Rauth with a kill.
It is not safe to say that they didn't target RC.

I guess my point is, it is absolutely safe to say that *either* Rauth and MBG have one scum in them *or* we have 5 town PRs.
Besides Nancy I see no one arguing the second.
So why is this lynch so painful? We should just flip one, either we're heroes, or we get scum tomorrow.
I'd trade a PR for a scum any day of the week outside of lylo.
It's not lylo as far as I'm aware, though maybe MBG and his indeterminate sized scum team has a different opinion.

[mattblackguy]

Not a "bad player" mate.
I just thought your two reads contradicted the decisions you made N1/D2.
I flagged this as suspicious.
I still don't think you fully grasp what I am asking for.
Nevertheless, I will unlikely be voting you today, because sometimes the obvious answer is the correct answer: 'the no night kill was likely down to you'

If my response didn't answer what you were asking then yeah I have no idea what you were asking then.

I don't even know what you're trying to say here.

Makes two of us - I was stating that I don't get how/why you're saying we only have one mislynch left. How do we only have one mislynch left?

lol I guess you haven't been reading any of my posts. Not surprised really. I did say I was suspicious of LUV before, and I was even voting him earlier. Rauth hasn't done anything all of day 3. That's why I kept pressuring him to get some reads out there. I don't think he actually reread through the game like he said he did. His reread post was just stupidly bad, and he doesn't even say he thinks Frogger is scum. I don't think Town!Rauth makes that kind of post at this point of the game. I know he's still kinda newbie, but that doesn't mean he's that bad.

Are you basing this on experience with town Rauth, or just a presumption of what town Rauth would do?

I said if I am lynched today then we have 1 mislynch remaining. I haven't personally played with town Rauth, but I looked at his previous town game. In that game he also revealed as a PR, but after revealing he was more open with his reads, and thoughts. He hasn't been like that at all after revealing. I had to force him to contribute, and when he did do a catchup it was a vote for a silly reason especially at this point in the game. I don't buy his "I don't know why I voted Frog" story either. Just makes him look worse.

[Grendel]

I am prepared to make a leap of faith that goes against my previously held stances.

VOTE: Ruath

I wrote Ruath off as town for cock blocking JarJar yesterday, but nothing Ruath has done today inspires further reason to town read him. And when a new player starts OB!towning it usually doesn't

stop

overnight. Ruath comparatively has been way too under spoken today for my liking. His votes today were also really bad.

[RadiantCowbells]

I feel like if I were playing this game a year ago I'd know exactly what to do but I don't and it feels really terrible.

[Cooperative Sheep]

I feel like if I were playing this game a year ago I'd know exactly what to do but I don't and it feels really terrible.

I hit my high point of confidence about 1-2 years into playing the game, the more you play the more you tend to self bury in wifom in my experience.
For me the Rauth question really boils down to 'does he strike me as scum clever enough to fake the result and hope town bullies him about it' and to that my answer is 'no'.
At that stage the only sane move is to vote MBG, who, as much as people are bemoaning the tepid Rauth input for the day, isn't exactly exceeding that standard much himself, while being objectively a more seasoned and capable player to do exactly that. Which, again, speaks to my vote.
I may be derping, but the logic feels sound.

[Fro99er]

Let me know when we lynch someone

still voting MBG. nothing new to add

[nancy]

Fro99er, vote Rauth. mbg's reaction to the hammer was real, mbg is Town. Go read Rauth's Town games and come back and vote the slot when you realize what's up.

Pine picks JK over Backup Cop 9/10 times. Pine likes JKs and he loves WIFOM. This is easy.

[Fro99er]

Whatever

VOTE: Rauth

I don't agree with this

[RadiantCowbells]

Not not okay with this but hold the fk up

[Fro99er]

Yes?

[nancy]

rauth no lynch is kinda scumclaimy just saying

This is actually a good time to reread anyways, so...

UNVOTE:

When I finish rereading I should know who to vote.

Finished rereading and... I know who I'm voting for now.

VOTE: Fro99er

Asking to be lynched is rather anti-town.

Transparent unvote when I pressure him on scummy behavior. Votes Fro99er without reasons, doesn't even know why later.

The NK doesn't add up with scum!mbg. It adds up perfectly with scum!Rauth. This is clear-cut.

[nancy]

I'm inevitably coming back to the conclusion that the backup cop is the fake PR claim.

[RadiantCowbells]

Am I the only person who feels like Alisae is a LUV kill?

[RadiantCowbells]

Like who else in this game makes that nightkill.

[RadiantCowbells]

Ok, so here's MY RADIANTCOWBELLS POINT OF VIEW OF THE GAME.

Let's look at the PRs.

Bulletproof - Standalone. No comparison to anything else.

Jailkeeper - Sorta standalone. Links up positively with bulletproof.

but then we have

COP
BACKUP COP
MOTION DETECTOR

3 INVESTIGATIVE PR CLAIMS

what, 2 invest
NO
3 INVESTIGATIVE PR CLAIMS.


We lynch Rautherdir.
If he's scum, we lynch Cooperative Sheep and continue from there.

If he's town, we just won the game because the last two scum are MattBlack and LUV.

*drops mic*

[RadiantCowbells]

Also MBG's iso is just flat out a millino times better than Rautherdir's

[RadiantCowbells]

matt on scumflip you jailkeep cooperative sheep, luv replacement motion detects at discretion.

[RadiantCowbells]

damn I really hope I'm right here because this felt good. that reread felt like mafia felt back when I was at my best. I was seeing things making connections none of this trying to make a reasoned case bullshit just feeling it y'know

[RadiantCowbells]

Rauth, I really can't see the universe where you with an inno on me played this the way you did then lurksauced the entire day phase.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

3246 RC in a nutshell

[mattblackguy]

Just going to say this now because I don't know if the day will end before I get a chance to post again. I'm jailing Sheep tonight, so if I die tonight then he's not scum.

p-edit: yeah RC was just gana say that

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Remove V/LA plz, midterms over and it's spring break time. I can cough up lungs on my own time now