Open 674: Duck Duck Goose [Game Over]

[havingfitz]

why do you think that hapa is more likely to contribute or self-incriminate?

creature is amazing at scumhunting d2 onward as town -- id sheep town!Creature d2 unquestioningly in fact, and i just dont do that
so why do you think hapa is the better choice here?

i know why /i/ do and that is irrelevant, i want to know why you do

Based on what I have seen so far in this game. hapa actually appears to be making an effort with his posts wrt convincing others of his opinion (for what they are worth). And posting more content if he is scum (as I suspect) will eventually catch up to him. Creature based on what I have seen is all over the place and doesn't interact well with others (ex. question responses). I see effort from hapa but not Creature.

And as far as Creature's D2+ prowess is concerned...my limited experience with him is town!him mislynching town!me for a scum win. We have another game where he was town and I was scum but I don't recall his play there.

I have no experience iirc with hapa

[Creature]

Ok, just for you I'll try to scumhunt.

[Creature]

I think you and havingfitz are town, I might flip-flop, but I'm currently leaning town.

[Creature]

hapa still hasn't improved much.

[Creature]

KidAmn can be also scum.

[Creature]

Hawk hasn't done anything special tbh.

[Creature]

Maybe after hapa, we could go for Hawk.

[Creature]

Moogin posts a little then disappears.

Scum

[Creature]

Hey, so my scumreads (not PoE) so far are:
hapahauli
Hawk
MooginSoosy

That's already good.

[Creature]

Yet, again Aubrey + Kop + outoforder + Rels + doomfeathers + me isn't enough to solve the game.

Take Kop out and replace with cassielle and havingfitz.

[Creature]

Aubrey + cassielle + havingfitz + outoforder + Rels + doomfeathers + me is enough to solve the game.

[Creature]

Yeah, and KidAmn and Kop are just nulls.

[Creature]

Now it's just a matter of whether you think this is my genuine town self or you think I've gone crazy as scum and decided to do that.

[Creature]

We could stick with hapa wagon or we could change it for Hawk.

[Creature]

Not sure how much effect switching the wagon to MooginSoosy will happen.

[cassielle]

you got me convinced
im willing to give you another shot, good to see town!Creature around again

why hawk? why moogin?

[Creature]

Hawk looks unspecial, like nothing makes me say "this is town!Hawk"

[Creature]

Moogin posts a little then disappears.

Scum

[cassielle]

that feels thin, esp if the gamestate was boring enough to give you the scum!Creature look

why couldnt it just be bored & uncertain!Hawk?

and i think we should stick to activity being NAI for this dayphase, you pinged me with the posts you did make not the ones you didnt

[Creature]

hapahauli flipping scum should help a little.

[cassielle]

well lets be sure about that first yeah? an early end to the day and all -- remember newbie 1769? we should be careful there

what about rels, why is that a townread? i dont get it personally, that slot feels exceedingly, artificially dull to me, which i find to be a sign of scum
scum (and doctors, but thats not a concern in this setup) want you to not read their posts
town wants you to clap them on the back and say how brilliant they are

[hapahauli]

This is your daily reminder that no one actually has reasons to call me mafia.

[Creature]

Oh right, the doubting.

Back to disinteress.

[cassielle]

Oh right, the doubting.

Back to disinteress.

if i doubt your reads its because i havent heard what you have to say about them
or ive sorted them after hearing what you had to say and found it wanting

my doubt is "explain to me why i should believe" not "this is why you are wrong". i give my reasons for my reads to see if you can find a flaw in the reasoning

i know youre a good scumhunter -- my issue is your d1 play, and im trying to help direct it a bit so we get more out of it. this is not the same as casting doubt on you in general

if that is enough to make you disinterested idk man

[Creature]

Hmm, I don't know how to explain Rels.