Mini 530: Guitar Hero Mafia: It's Finally Over

[Atticus]

I had expected there to be Christmas lag, but it seems prods are still in order. Prepare yourselves.
Also, we have several people in need of replacement, yet my requests have gone unanswered.
This is obviously a problem, and please, if you know people who would replace, that'd be great.

[hasdgfas]

I really think we need more people to post. I'm tired of the 4/5 of us saying things, but not being able to do anything since we can only get like 3 votes on someone. Please do some replacing too, Atticus. We need it.

[Haschel Cedricson]

[quote="DeliciousGoldfish]

Okay, but how looooong ago had I actually posted that initial quote?[/quote]

Actually, both quotes were from the same post, a couple of sentences apart. At the moment, I'm starting to postulate that you and d3s are scumbuddies and you're trying to save him from today's lynch by getting attention onto Natude.

[ChaosOmega]

At the moment, I'm starting to postulate that you and d3s are scumbuddies and you're trying to save him from today's lynch by getting attention onto Natude.

Does that mean you think Natude is not scum?

But I don't like the way DeliciousGoldfish responded to that. Something to keep an eye on.

[Haschel Cedricson]

[quote="ChaosOmega"[/quote]

Does that mean you think Natude is not scum?
[/quote]

Not necessarily. I'm just mentioning a possible connection that I see.

Now, I certainly believe that Natude is not USEFUL, but that wasn't your question.

[Haschel Cedricson]

EBWOP: Dammit, why can't I quote people properly?

[hasdgfas]

EBWOP: Dammit, why can't I quote people properly?

Just click the quote button on one of their posts, then delete what you don't need. It makes it easier.

[Natude]

At the moment, I'm starting to postulate that you and d3s are scumbuddies and you're trying to save him from today's lynch by getting attention onto Natude.

That was a good catch, but I just did a quick reread and I think it's really the only thing supporting your pair.

hasdgfas: Good catch on d3sisted. Maybe ChaosOmega and d3sisted are scum! Wouldn't that be nice to catch 'em both so quickly...

And I definitely do NOT believe that there even is a jester. That was a joke about how d3sisted is still making scummy moves so early in the game...

These are reasons why this is not a pair.

I'll try to do a better reread tomarrow and spell out my suspisions.

[Natude]

Okay, I just did a reread, and will try to break down my thoughts on the players.

Thanatos:

I like what I see of him so far. He's lighthearted, He has good logic, and he's careful not to get to close to lynching before we're confident of the offenders alignment. He's been asking good questions to get more information, and he always gives his reasonings for what he does.

My thoughts: Pro Town

Haschel Cedricson:

Not posting that much, but when he dose, he has somthing to say. His logic's pretty good, but I don't agree with half of it. He makes good observations, but sometimes it looks like he's serching for somthing to be suspisious of.

My thoughts: 40/60 Pro Mafia

Jex:

Very few posts, but good posts. Whenever she posts she's getting somewhere. Sometimes to do something that needs to get done (like unvoting), sometimes asking questions, sometimes giving her thoughts... The problem is that she has only posted twise after the random voting stage, and we haven't heard from her since page five. Mabey we need a prod...

My thoughts: Leaning Town

DeliciousGoldfish:

I like the questions she's been asking throughout the game so far, and I see nothing scummy in what votes she placed and when. She has good logic in her posts, and will make jokes at the same time. I've yet to se a mafia who will do that.

My thoughts: Pro Town

ChaosOmega:

He starts out on a really bad note with post 40, after that comes the vote Jex out of nowhere. Once that is over, he comes back to look pretty good. I like his logic and he asks good questions. He's had his smack in the face, I say we should stop brewding on it.

My thoughts: Leaning Town

hasdgfas:

Not asking many questions, but his logic is great. When he sees something scummy, He'll jump on it and keep it going until there's no reason to continue, and he knows when to just leave somthing alone. These are good traits for a scum, but he dosen't do it in a way that seems scummy.

My thoughts: Toss Up

Gorrad:

We're really not getting much out of this guy. He's been asking questions and making comments, but I can't find any tells. He's hard for me to read. The only tell I can find, is think this was Sparta for a bit. I don't think a mafia would pay that little attention.

My thoughts: 60/40 Pro Town

Cole:

He's like Gorrad for me right now. Not much content in his posts, and I can't get any tells. The only thing I have on this guy right now is gut feeling. -,-

My thoughts: 60/40 Pro Town

perfect628:

He's doing what I'm doing but with less posts. I can see why you guys get on my case for lerking, but this guy's even worse.

My thoughts: Leaning Mafia

SilverPhoenix:

Not giving us anything. He's lerking as much as me and perfect628. He seems to dismiss everything by everyone as not scummy, and I don't like that

My thoughts: Leaning Mafia

d3sisted:

The first thing I don't like is the flip. Espesealy since there were only seven posts in between. After making what he thought was a L-2 vote, he says that he's not "pushing hard" and just wanted to put on some presure. Then says it was not a flip, then "I am jester" (The heck?), then he says he only made one contradicting post, then he says ChaosOmega "wasn't in any danger whatsoever of a lynch", then he accuses Thanatos of voting him on a "Lynch the obvscum" basis, then he admits it

was

a flip, then he votes perfect, saying "he hasn't actually done anything but follow" (This one's sort of pro town). After this whole sequence I think we should lynch him.

My thoughts:

Vote: d3sisted

[Gorrad]

I'm back from vacation. I'm really having NOTHING to say recently. Natude's looking strong pro-town to me, I support 197 and his list is well thought-out, but other than that I haven't had anything change in my eyes.

[hasdgfas]

As much as I hate to say it, I think we need a deadline. Nobody's talking and it seems like we need something big to promote discussion. Whether mass prodding, replacing, or a deadline, something needs to be done.

[Thanatos]

I agree with Has. We need a deadline. This is one of the slowest day ones I've ever seen..

That said, I like Natudude's post. It seems very well thought out. It gave suspicions without real finger pointing.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Can we get a vote count? I think I miscalculated again.

[ChaosOmega]

If I didn't mess anything up, I think this is the votecount up to now:

d3sisted (4): Thanatos, Natude, Gorrad, Haschel Cedricson
Natude (4): ChaosOmega, cole, hasdgfas, DeliciousGoldfish
perfect628 (1): d3sisted

With that said, Natude's post 208 was a refreshing change of pace. I'm going to leave my vote where it is, but I'll be more apt to change it at a later point.

[ChaosOmega]

If I didn't mess anything up, I think this is the votecount up to now:

d3sisted (4): Thanatos, Natude, Gorrad, Haschel Cedricson
Natude (4): ChaosOmega, cole, hasdgfas, DeliciousGoldfish
perfect628 (1): d3sisted

With that said, Natude's post 208 was a refreshing change of pace. I'm going to leave my vote where it is, but I'll be more apt to change it at a later point.

[Natude]

Err... Atticus?

You still here?

[Thanatos]

Well we're mod abandoned. How bout the scum claim, and we all have a good laugh and a few beers over this, what do you say?

[hasdgfas]

I think the mod's playing freebird, actually. How'z about I prod the mod and see what's up with him.

[Gorrad]

Heh, the players prodding the mod. I'm down with that, tell him to post or be replaced : D. In all seriousness, though, is there a backup mod with the setup? Or someone willing to take this over if we all forward our role PMs? I'd like to keep this party rocking.

On that note, clearly the Natude or d3sisted wagons can't both stay, I don't think it'd be possible for the day to end. Any Natude-haters want to switch? He's looking pretty bloody protown to me, I don't really see a case.

[hasdgfas]

The mod is prodded. I don't know about any backup mods. I'll gladly switch to the d3sisted wagon as the Natude vote was pretty much a pressure vote to get him to stop lurking

unvote, vote: d3sisted

[hasdgfas]

our mod hasn't posted anywhere since Jan 3rd. If we have a backup mod, he/she probably needs to show up.

[Natude]

Which is kind of sad, because it was only 20 posts ago...

[Atticus]

Sorry guys, I'm an ass. I apologise. Though I can't expect you to accept that. I'll put effort into replacing and prodding and whatever needs doing.

[Atticus]

"They Should Call Me Assicus"
Vote Count

d3sisted

(5):

Thanatos, Gorrad, Natude, Haschel Cedricson, hasdgfas

perfect628

(1):

d3sisted

Natude

(3):

ChaosOmega, cole, Delicious Goldfish

Not Voting (3): perfect628, SilverPhoenix, Jex,

Yes, I'm working on the problems.

[Thanatos]

What's the number needed to lynch? 6 or 7?