Mini 1877: Spyro the Dragon (Game Over)

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I think not wanting to mass claim and the openly opposing it is blatantly anti-town in this situation

VOTE: MoI

This is a bad vote

[lane0168]

I think not wanting to mass claim and the openly opposing it is blatantly anti-town in this situation

VOTE: MoI

*Jackie Chan what?*

[eagerSnake]

You're wrong

Who's wrong?

&& Why is it a bad vote?

[Infinity 324]

You're wrong that being against massclaim is only scum-motivated because I am against massclaim. The vote isn't bad, the reasoning is.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I mean I'm still on the fence about it myself and I'm the bloody role cop

[lane0168]

Because you think only scum would be against a mass claim and he detailed why he thinks it's bad. There's no way only scum think its bad. I can't think of any reason scum would not want a mass claim. Not that outweighs knowing all roles and being able to deduce intentions of those roles

[eagerSnake]

eagerSnake - Town Vigilante (Spyro)
RadiantCowbells - Anon Messenger
Not_Mafia - Neighbor 1-Shot Role Cop
TheRealGin-N-Tonic - Neighbor 1-Shot Role Cop
Leonshade - "My role PM confirms existence of Spyro"
RagingSpammers (Cloudkicker + Alisae) - Day 2 Double Voter

MagnaofIllusion -
Flubbernugget -
SirCakez -
massive -
Infinity 324 -
lane0168 -
Ælla Was Spine (Lycanfire + Vifam) -

This is where we're at

I know at least that if we do mass claim now that scum will have a difficult time fake claiming, they won't be able to fake claim anything confirmable, and they won't be able to change their claim later, and we can probably turn this into a logic puzzle.

[lane0168]

I think I want to claim

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

So eager, what happens if there is a Mafia Doctor? What then?

[MagnaofIllusion]

I think not wanting to mass claim and the openly opposing it is blatantly anti-town in this situation.

And this is exactly why even if you are the Vig I'm never sheeping your judgement. If anything this reads as "How dare he hurt my feelings by questioning my wisdom and calling my reasoning on Negative Utility bad".

[lane0168]

Except I'm sure theres rb and/or redirect

[eagerSnake]

I think not wanting to mass claim and the openly opposing it is blatantly anti-town in this situation.

And this is exactly why even if you are the Vig I'm never sheeping your judgement. If anything this reads as "How dare he hurt my feelings by questioning my wisdom and calling my reasoning on Negative Utility bad".

Magna it was just a trap (rxn test) don't worry

[eagerSnake]

So eager, what happens if there is a Mafia Doctor? What then?

I highly doubt that's something we should be worrying about and this question pings me pretty hard tbh

[Infinity 324]

I'll respond to magna and after that ISO gin in an hour or so. In the meantime magna: Why didn't you respond to my accusation that it was bad logic to base such a large part of your read on me on such a small sample of meta?

[Infinity 324]

So eager, what happens if there is a Mafia Doctor? What then?

I highly doubt that's something we should be worrying about and this question pings me pretty hard tbh

Why

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

So eager, what happens if there is a Mafia Doctor? What then?

I highly doubt that's something we should be worrying about and this question pings me pretty hard tbh

How?

We're talking about mass claiming and you're ready to set up pushes based on what people claim. Have you never actually played against a Mafia Doctor as they are in fact a thing.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I'll get you a game when I can find it but Mastina actually won a freaking game as Mafia because she was able to claim Maf/Doc

[eagerSnake]

We should really mass claim

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

do a pro/cons on mass claiming

[Infinity 324]

Eager. Massclaiming d1 is dumb and gives way too much info to scum.

[eagerSnake]

If I could guarantee catching a scum with a mass claim then what would you say

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Then I would say this game isn't balanced and broken

[massive]

I would say you haven't been right about much this game, so why do you think you are now?

[lane0168]

Am I the only one that thinks day 2 double voter is ridiculous or...

[lane0168]

Alisae has ~100 posts elsewhere since her last post here. Was pretty active here when being pushed. Absent since pressure relieved. Wonder where that slot is