Newbie 1768: Party Mafia - Game over!

[JaeReed]

This whole situation sucks, by the way. Knowing how Jae loves to defend their townreads, I was hoping they'd recognize the GL wagon as an indirect way to save her. It was a desperate measure but I'm pretty convinced that Lemon is PR so desperate measures are called for. Jae didn't recognize it and Titus has RL issues so now we're probably going to mislynch for no reason. Still, a part of me wants to believe Titus about Lemon/GL. I guess the flip will be telling.

I defend my hard townreads. The ones I get where I feel that there's no chance it flips scum at all. No one's pinged me that way in this game.

I also wouldn't do it indirectly if that

were

the case.

[Revan]

I'm going to fix up a quick readslist right now before I'll be done posting for D1.

[Revan]

Town: Tojam, Bowdown

Townlean: EL, Titus, JaeReed

Scumlean: GL, AgentSparkles

Scum: Nancy

[Revan]

I don't like how nancy is voting for lack of content, rather than analyzing someone's content then trying to discern their alignment. It looks like scum looking for an easy way out. At first, I just thought this was newbtown, but nancy looks like she gets the game pretty well.

[nancy]

Reed, you've overlooked something.
Since you're thinking that the scumteam is 2 newbs, I'll leave it up to you to figure out what it might be.
Right now, please don't post your findings, if any.
Scum already have too much information.

Jae, you're so convinced that you'll die tonight, and yet your leading D1 has ultimately been ineffective. Your townread is getting lynched, and by your posts you are clearly not a PR. I don't think you're much of a threat to anybody.

[nancy]

I don't like how nancy is voting for lack of content, rather than analyzing someone's content then trying to discern their alignment. It looks like scum looking for an easy way out.

Are you selectively reading my posts because you are scum or because you are inattentive?

[JaeReed]

There are 5 newbie slots in the game.

VOTE: nancy

Bottom part of that is a crapton of shade. I only just figured out the game last night, so yes, it is a little late to move it, but I can certainly try. I also mentioned that I might be wrong on it being Agent as your partner, but you're clearly scum.

[Revan]

VOTE: nancy

Flash wagon!

[Revan]

If there isn't enough support for this in 2 1/4 hours I'll switch back to EL.

Nancy all your "scumhunting" is just lazy or bullshit.

[nancy]

Look and think more carefully, Jae. Assume I'm Town as say a thought experiment and try again.

Revan, please answer my question.

[Revan]

I'm not selectively reading your posts. Show me one place where you analyze someone's content and say they're scum. Go on, do it.

[JaeReed]

3 more votes on nancy, please.

@Titus, GuiltyLion, tojam2, EccentricLemon, bowdown

EL especially, you should vote nancy to put her at L-2 and make her into a proper counter to you if you're town.

[nancy]

You're selectively reading my posts and misrepresenting me, whether intentionally or unintentionally. 469 clearly states a GL scumread based on based on

content

.

Revan, your posts have been frequently incomprehensible and scattershot, and now you're making me do your work for you. Scumreads: 138, 180, 207, 270.

[nancy]

JaeReed, why are you being wilfully blind?

[Revan]

469 isn't clear at all. What's scummy about it?

[JaeReed]

JaeReed, why are you being wilfully blind?

A scumslip is a scumslip is a scumslip.

Who's your partner?

[bowdown]

VOTE: Nancy

Quickly here, will be on more later. Also will be here a couple hours before lynch time.

[SirCakez]

Votecount 1.11

nancy (3) - JaeReed, Revan, bowdown
Revan (3) - GuiltyLion, Agent Sparkles, EccentricLemon
EccentricLemon (2) - Titus, tojam2
GuiltyLion (1) - nancy

Not voting (0)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch someone.

nancy is V/LA through Sunday.

(expired on 2017-01-16 11:14:00) remain until day end

[nancy]

125, where GL unvotes EL shortly after she gives off a bunch of scumtells and votes bowdown for weak reasons while accusing him of slipping knowledge of Lemon being Town. (If Lemon is scum, this is especially bad.) 182 looks like more for show than anything, as with most. He pokes around a little and asks a few questions but ultimately contributes nothing solid. 277 is a bit of a wishy-washy scumread and doesn't present anything new about why Revan is scum. 348 is good scumhunting, but it's also opportunistic because you were behaving pretty scummily at that point and the wagon against you was solid. The rest of his posts are more of the same nothing much. He hasn't contributed significantly to anything Town has done, he hasn't started anything, he's just sat back mostly, kept up appearances, and otherwise done a little helpful SE'ing. This is a scumread I'm moderately sure of.

[nancy]

JaeReed, why are you being wilfully blind?

A scumslip is a scumslip is a scumslip.

Who's your partner?

It wasn't a scumslip. Try again. Look more closely.

[nancy]

SirCakez

I'm back home so you can take me off V/LA.

[nancy]

Timezone differences - it's a new week here already.

[Revan]

everyone else still pretty null. I like to let some conversations between other players breathe a bit because I find I generally make better reads from observing interactions rather than driving them. Whenever I replace into games, my reads are usually better than games where I'm posting from the getgo, and outside of RtR I have a bad habit of tunneling on town in D1. Newbie games I like to slow down and pace myself a bit more, partially because the games tend to get more involved in the "theory of mafia" anyway.

[Revan]

@nancy that's from GL, btw.

[nancy]

I read that post in both of my recent re-reads of GL's ISO and I'm not inclined to meta-clear. If you're into meta, both Titus and Jae commented that GL has been abnormally unresponsive.