This game is messed up. Even if we lynch scum today I'm not sure how it plays out tonight if Gamma is not the NK. If he actually is the vig then a scum lynch today would at least enable him to try another shot tonight and town would still have a chance.
I'm pretty sure a mislynch results in end of game, unless there were only 2 scum in this game to begin with which I highly doubt with as powerful town has been. Also...if we mislynch and by some miracle Gamma is not NK'd (and he is an SK)...then I do not think the game would be over. But that just makes my head hurt thinking of how that could play out. Pretty sure town assured a loss regardless of what Gamma is if we mislynch today though.
And Gamma...with as powerful as the town has already proven to be with PRs...I highly doubt you are a vig. But don't get all defensive about that because I have no interest in voting you. The only way I could envision you being voted is if there were 2 more scum flips and the game was not over yet. And it was you and 2 others still alive. Then you would of course be the lynch.
Gerry...that case you presented on me is terrible. If you look over my game...at some point I have suspected everyone in this game. Even you. So shifting my reads around because of rereads or actions by others is not scummy.
Looking at the voting today, fmpov of course, gerry was at L-1 for a decent amount of time while Cloud was posting.
IF...gerry is town....there was no reason for scum!Cloud to not hammer. Other than the fact that it would have been basically sealed his fate if there was another day. But I do not think there would be another day if we mislynch today.
So if gerry is town....I think Cloud is town.
But I do not think they are both town.
They could both be scum (my current hypothesis) or Cloud could be town while gerry is scum with LUV or TwoFace.
The only way (fmpov) that gerry and Cloud are BOTH town is if TwoFace and Luv are both scum just waiting for Gamma or Cloud to lay a vote down on gerry so TwoFace can hammer for the win.
So possible pairings IMO:
gerry and Cloud
gerry and TwoFace
gerry and LUV
LUV and TwoFace
I would be really surprised if gerry and TwoFace were scumbuddies. I would begrudgingly have to give them props. So I hope that is not the case.
That would leave:
gerry and Cloud
gerry and LUV
LUV and TwoFace
gerry (and LUV) still make up 2/3rds of the possible scum teams so I think odds still have him as the best lynch for today.