WWE Mafia - Smackdown! (Game Over - Off Television)

[DiamondSentinel]

Ooh pagetop

[Tywin Lannister]

Grey what's your case on Pepto? The guy seems pretty null to me, and I kinda scum read IaI D1 too. Not strongly, but a little. I think the creature shading is dumb, but it really isn't a scum tell.

[-Grey-]

Grey what's your case on Pepto? The guy seems pretty null to me, and I kinda scum read IaI D1 too. Not strongly, but a little. I think the creature shading is dumb, but it really isn't a scum tell.

Lazy bastard.

I know self meta is shit but it's my play style to hang back unless i have something to really go after.

This only means something if the posts you do make actually contribute to the game.

There is zero scumhunting in your ISO, just a bunch of setup spec and fluff.

VOTE: Pep

I'm good with starting the day here.

His vote going on IaI solidified my read because

Post 80 makes me think it would be bad to lynch IAI btw.

[I Am Innocent]

I don't usually like ending the day so early, but i also don't see anything in gamma's iso worth saving. I won't force my opinions onto the whole town but remember that letting gamma tap out would end the day 8 days early.

If we do kill him and he flips town, iai and creature are gonna be in need of some close watching. If he's scum, I still would watch creature, but not so much iai.

1) agrees that gamma is scummy

2) yet has his new reads ready when gamma flipped town

Hmmm who does that usually???

[I Am Innocent]

My primary theory is it rerolls the list of players in Smackdown and RAW.

VOTE: gamma

Throws on a vote too. So far the only scum read he has produced D1

(Only other reads up to this point is t vs t with Maria and Titus, which means if pepto is town prob 1 of them is scum cough cough maria)

[I Am Innocent]

Yeah that ISO is very weak and empty of reads. Dropped a few scum tells along the way.

vote pepto

At the group: any reason why each GM shouldn't redraft the players we just lost to the other thread?

To me it seems to be the surest way to keep the Town scum ratios from possibly getting too skewed to one thread.

[Leonshade]

VOTE: DiamondSentinel

I don't like that reaction to Grey's finishers. Not the negativity, but specifically going straight to the personal "you're so toxic" accusation. DS's knee-jerk reaction being about Grey's personality, rather than questioning his alignment, sticks out to me.

I'm sorry, but I don't like replacing into a game only for people to immediate discredit me and just not pay attention to what I am trying to say.

I had to ask every single one of you motherfuckers to read my intro post.

Allow me to ask more directly: what's your read on Grey? Your intro post puts him at noob-town with little explanation. You clearly thought that his behavior was anti-town, so why did you seem so convinced that he was toxic town, as opposed to scum?

I need to re-read if I want to be productive here, but my upcoming exam is killing my desire to read. I will prioritize Alban & Pepto's ISOs, first.

[Leonshade]

Oh, and the finisher on Raw was just a fancy hammer, Penguinos was getting lynched regardless. A finisher can't go through without the entire active portion of the town consenting (granted, on Raw active is a relative term...).

[-Grey-]

Oh, and the finisher on Raw was just a fancy hammer, Penguinos was getting lynched regardless. A finisher can't go through without the entire active portion of the town consenting (granted, on Raw active is a relative term...).

Kinda making my point for me.

[Leonshade]

I was disagreeing with DS, not you.

[-Grey-]

I know you are, but what am I?

[DiamondSentinel]

VOTE: DiamondSentinel

I don't like that reaction to Grey's finishers. Not the negativity, but specifically going straight to the personal "you're so toxic" accusation. DS's knee-jerk reaction being about Grey's personality, rather than questioning his alignment, sticks out to me.

I'm sorry, but I don't like replacing into a game only for people to immediate discredit me and just not pay attention to what I am trying to say.

I had to ask every single one of you motherfuckers to read my intro post.

Allow me to ask more directly: what's your read on Grey? Your intro post puts him at noob-town with little explanation. You clearly thought that his behavior was anti-town, so why did you seem so convinced that he was toxic town, as opposed to scum?

I need to re-read if I want to be productive here, but my upcoming exam is killing my desire to read. I will prioritize Alban & Pepto's ISOs, first.

Because he's done the same things that Dwlee did multiple times over his first few games here. I know it's not AI (and I paid the price for thinking it was in Cyberpunk), but if he's scum, we can also kill him at our leisure, as he's not much of a threat.

But don't get me wrong. I don't think he's scum right now. I'm just saying if he is, that'll be easily remedied.

[-Grey-]

Allow me to ask more directly: what's your read on Grey? Your intro post puts him at noob-town with little explanation. You clearly thought that his behavior was anti-town, so why did you seem so convinced that he was toxic town, as opposed to scum?

I need to re-read if I want to be productive here, but my upcoming exam is killing my desire to read. I will prioritize Alban & Pepto's ISOs, first.

If you have so many questions about me, why are you prioritizing two

other

players in your re-read?

[Tywin Lannister]

I'm gonna ISO Pepto again. I did it D1, and it only took a few minutes with how little content he posted, but I'll do it again just to be sure. I bunched him, Alban (diamondsentinal), and KT in together as useless lurkers at the time, with the thought being at least one is probably scum for it. KT always struck me as just useless period, which is why his NK just doesn't make sense to me. In my mind, NKing that would mean newscum. The one player that legitimately wanted KT policy lynched over anything else was Alban. He said so during the RVS stages, and he basically begged for it. I could see alban's slot sending in an NK for KT just to get him removed. I could also see Pepto being newscum enough no send that in as well. At the moment, I have zero issues with lynching either, but Pepto is probably the better bet. Vifam is gone, but where is MariaR? She was the other pretty strong SR, but has been MIA since D2 started. I also don't TR grey, but I'm not SRing him the same way I did D1. I just didn't like the Titus/grey interaction there, but I like grey's D2 posts enough to lean more townish than scum now. Regardless, I don't think he's the best lynch, and given the choice between Pepto/diamond/grey, I'd choose Pepto over the others.

Anyways, I'll ISO him sometime today when I get some time, and then I'll vote there if I find enough to warrant it. The main problem with Pepto on D1 was that he was so useless that he had no content to really analyze. That's obviously changed after the gamma flip, but I haven't been paying enough attention to this game after the work week I just had. Today is my only day off, so I'll catch up and give updates reads probably later tonight.

[Creature]

VOTE: MariaR

Alternative: Peptobislawl

[Creature]

I'm prob wrong in one of my townreads (it'd be good if MariaR and Peptobislawl are both scum and there's just a traitor elsewhere).

[-Grey-]

VOTE: MariaR

Alternative: Peptobislawl

Be a pal and flip those around.

[Peptobislawl]

I don't usually like ending the day so early, but i also don't see anything in gamma's iso worth saving. I won't force my opinions onto the whole town but remember that letting gamma tap out would end the day 8 days early.

If we do kill him and he flips town, iai and creature are gonna be in need of some close watching. If he's scum, I still would watch creature, but not so much iai.

1) agrees that gamma is scummy

2) yet has his new reads ready when gamma flipped town

Hmmm who does that usually???

Was expecting this. My reads were stated before gamma flipped, thanks. Plus, you're forgetting that Gamma did something incredibly scummy before i voted him. Yes he was town, but I had a valid and stated reason to vote him before i did. You didn't. You attacked him on nothing but nitpicks and misrep, leading up to the convenent mistake that finally got him lynched. Thanks for the OMGYS, by the way, helps make me more confident in my vote.

[I Am Innocent]

I don't usually like ending the day so early, but i also don't see anything in gamma's iso worth saving. I won't force my opinions onto the whole town but remember that letting gamma tap out would end the day 8 days early.

If we do kill him and he flips town, iai and creature are gonna be in need of some close watching. If he's scum, I still would watch creature, but not so much iai.

1) agrees that gamma is scummy

2) yet has his new reads ready when gamma flipped town

Hmmm who does that usually???

Was expecting this. My reads were stated before gamma flipped, thanks. Plus, you're forgetting that Gamma did something incredibly scummy before i voted him. Yes he was town, but I had a valid and stated reason to vote him before i did. You didn't. You attacked him on nothing but nitpicks and misrep, leading up to the convenent mistake that finally got him lynched. Thanks for the OMGYS, by the way, helps make me more confident in my vote.

The reads where you said

Gamma is scummy
BUT
IF
I'M
WRONG
It's prob IAI or creature

Well you were coincidentally wrong, and I know your coincidentally wrong about one of those follow up reads

Oh wait have I told you I don't buy coincidences in mafiascum...

So call what I did OMGUS, I call what you did a scum tell since scum do that more often than not (it's called setting up future mislynches)

[DiamondSentinel]

I don't usually like ending the day so early, but i also don't see anything in gamma's iso worth saving. I won't force my opinions onto the whole town but remember that letting gamma tap out would end the day 8 days early.

If we do kill him and he flips town, iai and creature are gonna be in need of some close watching. If he's scum, I still would watch creature, but not so much iai.

1) agrees that gamma is scummy

2) yet has his new reads ready when gamma flipped town

Hmmm who does that usually???

Was expecting this. My reads were stated before gamma flipped, thanks. Plus, you're forgetting that Gamma did something incredibly scummy before i voted him. Yes he was town, but I had a valid and stated reason to vote him before i did. You didn't. You attacked him on nothing but nitpicks and misrep, leading up to the convenent mistake that finally got him lynched. Thanks for the OMGYS, by the way, helps make me more confident in my vote.

The reads where you said

Gamma is scummy
BUT
IF
I'M
WRONG
It's prob IAI or creature

Well you were coincidentally wrong, and I know your coincidentally wrong about one of those follow up reads

Oh wait have I told you I don't buy coincidences in mafiascum...

So call what I did OMGUS, I call what you did a scum tell since scum do that more often than not (it's called setting up future mislynches)

What about his "coincidentally wrong about one of those follow up reads"?

[MariaR]

Back from flight what's up DS

[DiamondSentinel]

Back from flight what's up DS

Nothin much. Just bein snarky.

Also watching Gargantia of the Verdant Planet. Good stuff.

[DiamondSentinel]

Oh, also, you should read my catch-up post. Most people haven't read it.

[Tywin Lannister]

Oh, also, you should read my catch-up post. Most people haven't read it.

It really is hard to read. The effort would be better placed in normal paragraphs. A running log is almost always a bad idea in forum Mafia, and the few players whom I've seen do it almost always get ignored for it.

[DiamondSentinel]

Oh, also, you should read my catch-up post. Most people haven't read it.

It really is hard to read. The effort would be better placed in normal paragraphs. A running log is almost always a bad idea in forum Mafia, and the few players whom I've seen do it almost always get ignored for it.

Well, it works better for my thought process. I think very erratically, so it's only natural.