Mini 527 - Doom in Valencia - Game Over!

[Sikario8]

BTW, gorc...

MORE TOWNIE POINTS!!! +42.1568

unvote
vote neko

I would be more hestitant...wt4kever...

Mod Vote Count:
Selande (1): McStab
RideTheBomb (1): MeMe
soupfly (1): SirWario
Sikario8 (1): Neko2086
neko2086 (3): gorckat, soupfly, Sikario8
SirWario (1): Guardian

not voting: Pra, Archaist, Selande, Deathguise

[neko2086]

Wow, am I the only one that doesn't like it when people don't explain their votes? Seriously people. Sik, if anyone was going to explain their vote on me, it should be you, otherwise, this just looks omgusy. But, welcome to the bandwagon. This should prove useful on Day 2.

That said, I'm not giving up yet. I'm just surprised there's this many people going against me with so little argument. To answer your question, Sik, I think the lurkers should be pressured yes, but lynched? wow that's a bit extreme.

And Pra, nice to meet another Minnesotan. I'm down in Mankato. Looking forward to hearing your input on this game. Good luck.

[neko2086]

Hm, looking back Sik, you were already voting for me, just so you know. Jenter had his post count on pg 9 wrong.

Last time you voted for me was right after I voted for you, but you almost had a good reason, so it didn't look too omgusy. This time...

[Sikario8]

Wow, am I the only one that doesn't like it when people don't explain their votes? Seriously people. Sik, if anyone was going to explain their vote on me, it should be you, otherwise, this just looks omgusy.

But, welcome to the bandwagon

. This should prove useful on Day 2.

That said, I'm not giving up yet. I'm just surprised there's this many people going against me with so little argument. To answer your question, Sik, I think the lurkers should be pressured yes, but lynched? wow that's a bit extreme.

And Pra, nice to meet another Minnesotan. I'm down in Mankato. Looking forward to hearing your input on this game. Good luck.

•

This was not the reaction I had hoped for, neko. Why can't you jusy be scum and get it over with? Why must you ruin all my fun?

unvote neko

Now we have to go back to lookin'...
::looks to gorc::
Are

you

scum?

[gorckat]

Woah. I though Oman replaced in.

To answer your question, Sik, I think the lurkers should be pressured yes, but lynched? wow that's a bit extreme.

Without the threat of lynch, what pressure is there? There is no pressure if there is no threat of lynch. How can you have any pressure if you won't lynch! [/lame Pink Floyd meat and pudding joke]

That said, I'm not giving up yet.

I should hope not, after only 2 or 3 votes.

sik: What reaction were you expecting to confirm neko as scum?

[soupfly]

@oman, you read my case on neko? do some metagaming on neko and see if he's always so "nice" in his other games.

[SirWario]

I just did some quick metagaming on Neko and in newbie 468, he has more or less the same playing style as here(his posts all come off as very courteous and "nice").

Anyhow, I doubt Neko will react differently to any pressure vote now after he has faced 2, one from sikario and one from soupfly earlier, and seen how his calm attitude produces less suspicion towards him in the end.

[MeMe]

I'm fighting off a fever atm

So I need to replace Mcstab and deathguise, and the rest of you (particularly Selande, Arch, Wario and Soup) need to up the posting a bit.

Ok, I'll get looking for replacements now.

Process of deduction says that Pra is in for Sammich.

~still kinda twiddling, but am certainly more hopeful~

[Guardian]

Still here, still think Sir Wario's scum.

[Sikario8]

Woah. I though Oman replaced in.

To answer your question, Sik, I think the lurkers should be pressured yes, but lynched? wow that's a bit extreme.

Without the threat of lynch, what pressure is there? There is no pressure if there is no threat of lynch. How can you have any pressure if you won't lynch! [/lame Pink Floyd meat and pudding joke]

That said, I'm not giving up yet.

I should hope not, after only 2 or 3 votes.

sik:

What reaction were you expecting to confirm neko as scum

?

•

Don't really know, it was a half-ass attempt that worked before in another game; however, this is obviously not that game so I'm back to Square 1...

[Pra a Funkee Homo Sapien]

So far I can't really find anyone suspicious. I'm sure everyone here will be a pretty decent player so finding an obvious gaffe or mafia tell will be pretty difficult.

that said, has anyone been conspicuously idle or lurked conspicuously?

[Sikario8]

So far I can't really find anyone suspicious. I'm sure everyone here will be a pretty decent player so finding an obvious gaffe or mafia tell will be pretty difficult.

that said,

has anyone been

conspicuously

idle or lurked

conspicuously

?

•

Still

here

,

still

think

Sir Wario's scum.

•

Try him on for size

[Pra a Funkee Homo Sapien]

Hmmm.

pressure

vote Guardian

why is Sir Wario scum?

[Guardian]

Nothing's changed since my first post of this game.

Sikario8, do you think I am suspicious, or did you want to direct Pra's attention to me?

[Archaist]

pressurevote Guardian why is Sir Wario scum?

he isn't being particularly helpful while looking like he is trying to be

That said, while I think it's pretty clear why Guardian is voting Sir Wario, I also think that his explanation is pretty lacking. Do you have any posts in particular that made you think Sir Wario is actively lurking? Furthermore, you yourself seem to be actively lurking, especially with this post:

Still here, still think Sir Wario's scum.

Even if your suspicions on Sir Wario hadn't changed, you could still have made some useful comment on the posts of other players. Saying "I'm here and my suspicions haven't changed" isn't being very helpfull, so voting for Sir Wario because "he isn't being particularly helpful" is pretty hypocritical.

[Pra a Funkee Homo Sapien]

Nothing's changed since my first post of this game.

Sikario8, do you think I am suspicious, or did you want to direct Pra's attention to me?

Exactly, as I may reiterate Archaist's comments, what exactly hasn't changed?

[Guardian]

pressurevote Guardian why is Sir Wario scum?

he isn't being particularly helpful while looking like he is trying to be

That said, while I think it's pretty clear why Guardian is voting Sir Wario, I also think that his explanation is pretty lacking. Do you have any posts in particular that made you think Sir Wario is actively lurking?

Where did I say he was actively lurking? And no, it is a general impression from the whole game that he is trying to appear helpful, while not being so. I can't point to one specific post for that.

Furthermore, you yourself seem to be actively lurking, especially with this post:

Still here, still think Sir Wario's scum.

How so? I'm waiting for the lurkers to be replaced.

Even if your suspicions on Sir Wario hadn't changed, you could still have made some useful comment on the posts of other players.

Which I did, in my opening post. And then said that the scum could very well be among the lurkers. It isn't useful to me to analyze all the players when a couple of scum could easily not have posted in the game.

Saying "I'm here and my suspicions haven't changed" isn't being very helpfull

No? I'd have thought it would cause others to look at Sir Wario.

voting for Sir Wario because "he isn't being particularly helpful" is pretty hypocritical.

I'm not voting for him because he isn't being helpful -- I'm voting for him because he isn't being helpful while trying to appear as such.

Scum try and make paragraph posts where they discuss facts, and name some names, and not really leave anything meaningful. I made one post with my very limited thoughts on the game, and that's it. I am not doing what I accuse Sir Wario of, which is trying to appear helpful while not being helpful. I'm actually trying to be helpful.

[Guardian]

Nothing's changed since my first post of this game.

Sikario8, do you think I am suspicious, or did you want to direct Pra's attention to me?

Exactly, as I may reiterate Archaist's comments, what exactly hasn't changed?

My suspicion of Sir Wario.

[Jenter Brolincani]

1 more definite replacement, hoping to find the last soon.

[SirWario]

Guardian, saying your being helpful does not constitute you being helpful. Have you still only skimmed the game or are your suspicions on me based upon a further read?

[Pra a Funkee Homo Sapien]

What is suspiciuos about him? His general lurking? That's not much to go on. Seems like you are stacking a little bit of false evidence against him, or at least trumping those charges up.

[gorckat]

I stumbled on that last inconsistency by neko- that he suggested I was opportunistic scum for 3 voting Archaist, but didn't unvote Archaist himself (I think that was left out of my last post. Apologies, if it was in there).

I agree on Guardian calling out SirWario.

[Sikario8]

Guardian, saying your being helpful does not constitute you being helpful.

Have you still only skimmed the game

or are your suspicions on me based upon a further read?

•

You haven't posted

that

much, SirWario. It's fairly easy to go back and read all of your posts.

[Jenter Brolincani]

Arakorn replaces McStab.

[Guardian]

Sikario8, do you think I am suspicious, or did you want to direct Pra's attention to me?