Mini 1859: D&D Curse of Strahd Mafia - Game Over

[Shaziro]

Did SlySly just hammer Pine? Holy fuck I wake up to this shit?

Okay, golden liquid potion of glibness, not something I ever encountered but given that the golden potion we found gave a charisma boost and was called "Youth" by the night hags in the Old Bonegrinder (An old windmill they used to grind up kids bones to make pastries that give good dreams until you stop eating them, which causes horrible nightmares) I can see it being true. Claim seems real, and since it's an adventurer role I think it's town, just has the potential to be anti-town if used wrong. I'll try and figure out any other possible baddies it could be, but if that's the role it seems legitimate enough.

The Govern! Okay, so Strahd can probably govern, but so could any "party leader" class or any of the Burgomasters. Governing isn't necessarily town or scum from Mafia Game Theory that I recall, but if it tends to be one or the other that is probably the best way to lean on this. Lore won't give us a solid answer here. Given that he apparently just hammered Pine, though, I'm leaning scummy as fuck.

Dreal, if you can't resist ad hominem shit, at least direct it somewhere else. I'm sick of it.

[SlySly]

Oh, it's real.

VOTE: Pine

DONT DO THIS TO ME SLYSLY

[kuror0]

If that's true doesn't it mean we end the day in a no lynch? That's what the wiki said.

[Pine]

Governing this close to deadline is anti-Town. Period.

PEdit: There are variations. It might end day, but if not I'm getting my vote in place because we don't have time to wait for Clumsy

[SlySly]

If that's true doesn't it mean we end the day in a no lynch? That's what the wiki said.

That's not been my experience. My experience has been the day just resets.

[SlySly]

And my experience would also mean Shadow can't be lynched today.

[kuror0]

why would you save shaddow if it is true and you are actually town sly? You can't possibly be a governor and have some confirmation of his alignment so you are just canceling the lynch because... ??

[SlySly]

Now who's claim is crumbly? You don't know what I did last night, I do. Creature was killed by a vig.

[kuror0]

plus I thought you were claiming something else and that's why you wanted Pine's item but if you are a governor there is no way it is good for town to give that item to you. You basically just crippled us way too hard depending on the rules or how this works.

[kuror0]

ok lets speak honestly. You are claiming both vig (which you heavily crumbled and that's why I stopped going after you) and also governor? what is your class and again why did you save shaddow?

[SlySly]

I didn't claim anything. Nice try, again, at putting words in my mouth.

Why did I save Shadow? Simple, I used to have a cat named Shadow. Sentimental gesture.

[drealmerz7]

no ad. hom. here, zero

[Andrius]

Sly i thought what we had was special

[Persivul]

I know I'm town, Culted got cleared for now, Pine is town on my reads. (Honestly no one countering a cleric claim or a doc claim makes me almost certain he is what he says.

I thought that both Pine and Dreal claimed protective, and we've already had one protective flip. This doesn't bother me particularly because the game is role madness on steroids, but your reasoning here is bad.

[SlySly]

Sly i thought what we had was special

When you pull the loaf from the oven this time, all you will smell is sweet perfume.

[Pine]

Calling it - Shaddow is Strahd, scum lose if Strahd is lynched

Drealmerz denied protective. Andrius was the one who said it, drealmerz denied. Read the game please.

[Persivul]

Just after I stole the item was when someone cleared.

IIRC I cleared before Culted got the item - that's partly why he got it.

[Clumsy Phoenix]

Calling it - Shaddow is Strahd, scum lose if Strahd is lynched

Drealmerz denied protective. Andrius was the one who said it, drealmerz denied. Read the game please.

It seems unbalanced to have scum die if one member dies. Maybe if they have a -lot- of ways to protect Strahd?

[Andrius]

Sly i thought what we had was special

When you pull the loaf from the oven this time, all you will smell is sweet perfume.

[Shaziro]

Calling it - Shaddow is Strahd, scum lose if Strahd is lynched

Drealmerz denied protective. Andrius was the one who said it, drealmerz denied. Read the game please.

It seems unbalanced to have scum die if one member dies. Maybe if they have a -lot- of ways to protect Strahd?

Alt slip, my b.

[Pine]

Calling it - Shaddow is Strahd, scum lose if Strahd is lynched

Drealmerz denied protective. Andrius was the one who said it, drealmerz denied. Read the game please.

It seems unbalanced to have scum die if one member dies. Maybe if they have a -lot- of ways to protect Strahd?

Like governor?

[Shaziro]

One doesn't seem enough, unless it's multiple shots. Is it possible to have an X-shot but only one shot per day or something?

[Pine]

It's POSSIBLE that is have a power that causes rainbow leprechauns riding purple unicorns to fly out of the arses of scum so I can skeet-shoot day vig them. It's just not likely or balanced.

[Shaziro]

Fair, I guess. I don't think a single governor is enough to justify a team losing if one person gets lynched, though.

[Persivul]

Calling it - Shaddow is Strahd, scum lose if Strahd is lynched

Highly unlikely.