Right off the bat it this doesn't make sense: Scum and Town can both get hung up or make bad assumptions about flavor.In post 169, shaddowez wrote:I'm kind of against either Jason or Shaziro having it at this point. It seems kind of odd that neither of them are really considering the mod could have changed up the items at all from what they're expecting.
[Replies to Jason in {post=#8574941]177[/post] and 183}
This is a tad overworded for my taste and the question at the end isn't very good.
Just is kinda how I think scum approach pushing town like "do you really" is just keeping the conversation going about the same thing and doesn't seem like something shad as town would care about that much.In post 177, shaddowez wrote:If the flavor makes it that much more obvious, do you really think its more helpful to town to be this secretive about what it does?
But moreover he's apparently scumreading jason for disagreeing with him which is ehhhh.
{post= 309}
Fair to vote Pine for the item given what went down that day but there's an undertone of knowing that Dunn's town by saying "he's unlikely to be NK'd".
Like miller claims hardly come from scum yea but there's certainly a lack of paranoia about it.
{post= 369}
Fair vote but the justification is kinda making me scratch my head "i can't fathom how that could ever come from a town mindset" like continuing the same trend of subtly knowing dunn's alignment; pretty weird.
{post= 497}
Transistions into a scumread on Pine for head-scratchy reasons:
Townread on me is because "Vedith wouldn't replace out as scum" -- alright.In post 497, shaddowez wrote:A lot of his actions seem townie in nature, but they're coming across as forced. More detail coming on this.
Says my push on shaz is good -- alright.
But this:
Is scumsville. He's essentially saying "unless this is scum/scum I don't think this is scum/scum."In post 497, shaddowez wrote:and unless this is Scum theater, I don't see this as SvS.
Not a real thought.
This is also a 'what' kinda thought process.In post 497, shaddowez wrote:My other scum lean right now is Jason, he seems to be trying to hide behind the source material. Shaz is doing the same thing, but the key difference to me is how they acted in regard to the amulet once that came into play.
{post= 515}
Commentary - okay question to kuror - commentary.
{post= 517}
Fair all around but I kinda dislike how he's pretty 'aware' of how he hasn't really addressed why he himself is scumreading pine.
{post= 527}
This is a bit contrived imo?In post 527, shaddowez wrote:378 is terrible, as it's saying "I'm going to call you scum, but not strong enough scum to want to lynch you, I'd rather waste a vig shot on you". If there's a scum BP or scum doctor, and they're scum together, that's an easy out also.
411, 412, and 419 all throw shade at Dunn, yet he still never votes for him.
Like Pine clearly has a sort of, what's the word, different theory take on millers than you do apparently? (Even though earlier on he said that dunn likely wouldn't be NK'd based on his claim???) But he's taking that theory dissagreement and making a pretty flaccid and over-justified scumread out of it.
Shall I continue or can I get a couple more shadow votes?
