Mini 1856 - This Mafia Game is for pieguyn (Game Over)

[pieguyn]

OK.

I think there's a very good chance we're in 9-2-2, and for this reason I think an Aero lynch is best today. it absolutely is not 10-2-1, so speculation about that should stop, but lynching Aero would mean Cakez and Luna could reliably generate clears or force scum into no killing no matter what setup ratio we're in (him flipping WW means only one WW left, him flipping town means it's just a lone mafia who has been no-killing every night for some ungodly reason and will have to keep no killing or start generating clears).

I don't think it's 9-3-1, either, mostly just because GIF knows I think it's completely unfair and while I think he would troll me, I don't think he wants to make me legitimately suffer by making an unfair setup.

[Luna Fox]

Because blocking means tracks register nothing.
...Or am I completely wrong about how roleblocking works?

Yes, but if you're VT, your reaction would be that your VT so you wouldnt be tracked anywhere, block or no block.

[Gamma Emerald]

Because blocking means tracks register nothing.
...Or am I completely wrong about how roleblocking works?

Yes, but if you're VT, your reaction would be that your VT so you wouldnt be tracked anywhere, block or no block.

I was speaking outside of my perspective, because I wanted you guys to understand.

[Luna Fox]

im still wondering about the missing NK N1.
if it hit Aero and Aero's part of the 2nd scumteam then that means it has BP + ??? vs 2x Faith Haler vs All the crap we have.
Which seems a bit unfair for the red team...

[Gamma Emerald]

That's why I doubt 9:2:2, it's unbalanced.

[pieguyn]

I think it's time nahdia confirm herself

this is a horrible idea, btw; the way it is now, if scum kill Nahdia then I confirm myself, if they kill me then Nahdia confirms themselves. scum literally cannot kill either of us without cutting me off as a mislynch option for good.

[pieguyn]

10-2-1 and 9-3-1 are even more imbalanced.

10-3 makes no sense unless the lone mafia left in this game has decided to no kill, as solo scum, the entire rest of the game after N1.

[Luna Fox]

Or they've been shooting Aero and Aero has a full bulletproof instead of an X-Shot one.
OR Or, Aero shot a teammate N1 (is that even allowed?)

@mod: can mafia kill their own teammate?

[Luna Fox]

Although a full BP Vig is kinda OP ^^;;

[pieguyn]

ya that too. 10-3 would also imply that Aero has true claimed bulletproof miller vig, which feels really broken given the other roles we have and the fact that the scum team so far only has had two faith healers.

and I don't think scum would keep trying to fire shots at Aero hoping they can eventually hit on one of them, I think they'd lay off after the shot N1.

[Luna Fox]

I could also block Aero and we no lynch, and hope whoever's leftover decides to show up if any.

[SirCakez]

Nah we should lynch Aero and have you announce who you're blocking before
I'll track someone random

[pieguyn]

the only scenario where I can see that is if GE is the scum, tried to shoot again on N2, but gave up N3 at which point you blocked him. I don't know how likely that is, though.

p-edit: I don't particularly like no lynch here, given what an Aero lynch would do to clear up the gamestate.

[Nahdia]

Hmm.

This is weird.

[Luna Fox]

Nah we should lynch Aero and have you announce who you're blocking before
I'll track someone random

or you could track me, and then i dont announce who im blocking!

[SirCakez]

That too

[Nahdia]

No I won't be confirming myself today.

I suppose I'm down for an Aero lynch. No kill happening elsewhere despite a townie being blocked is odd. Like, why didn't Wisdom kill anyone night 1???

[pieguyn]

for the record, I want a few days to think about things a bit before we proceed with any lynch - no one put Aero at L-1 for the time being

[pisskop]

I dont support a lazy aero lynch

[pisskop]

weve done it pies way; shes not even confed town/

Time you listen to me now that youve spent a day murdering all my townreads

[Nahdia]

So who do you want to lynch?

[pisskop]

if its 9v2v2, and the red team is anything to go by I expect that the blue/purple team will have townish powers.

So I dont rule out cakez.

and if its 9v2v2, I dont rule out scum nokilling or being unable to kill due to the 'rule of pissoffpie'.

[pisskop]

I wanna kill gamma, asking from a kneejerk.

[pisskop]

Thats a silly question though. If I had a daycop or dayvig itd be on pie, oc.

[Nahdia]

I could potentially be down with Gamma. Problem is, he was just roleblocked. And a kill happened still. And we know the only kills we've been seeing have been from Aero. So there's like, a mystery missing kill from Wisdom (town was roleblocked that night) which is blowing my mind a bit. I guess he coulda shot Aero but that seems a bit weird. I'm ratning and not making any sense. Just, having trouble parsing info.

Thats a silly question though. If I had a daycop or dayvig itd be on pie, oc.

Well thank god you don't, because that'd be incredibly dumb!