In post 74, drealmerz7 wrote:I don't think it is the RP that is bothering, I think it's just that it seems forced and overdone and that is not ever good because 1 it skews an ability to read you (and so just comes off scummy)
In post 74, drealmerz7 wrote:I don't think it is the RP that is bothering, I think it's just that it seems forced and overdone and that is not ever good because 1 it skews an ability to read you (and so just comes off scummy)
it's a nuanced thing, RPing
You are correct, i see where you are coming from with the skewed read thing. I was planning on only doing this until things moved out of the silly starting on the game phase and so now i am switching to actual posting.
My first vote was just pure RVS, my second was because i had to take the opportunity to make a pun, and my unvote is because Zach was at three votes and it takes 5 to lynch iirc and i didnt want to be on a wagon that was voted up for no reason.
In post 74, drealmerz7 wrote:I don't think it is the RP that is bothering, I think it's just that it seems forced and overdone and that is not ever good because 1 it skews an ability to read you (and so just comes off scummy)
it's a nuanced thing, RPing
You are correct, i see where you are coming from with the skewed read thing. I was planning on only doing this until things moved out of the silly starting on the game phase and so now i am switching to actual posting.
My first vote was just pure RVS, my second was because i had to take the opportunity to make a pun, and my unvote is because Zach was at three votes and it takes 5 to lynch iirc and i didnt want to be on a wagon that was voted up for no reason.
Ok, at least I understand why you were RPing, but why didn't you say this earlier? Why don't you want to take the initiative to take the game out of RVS?
You had a reason for your unvote, so why RP with your unvote instead of giving your actual reasons?
In post 91, Infinite Justice wrote:I'm not sure whether to give BnL townpoints for sticking to his guns or scumpoints for calling out such a small number of essentially fluff posts.
Depends on a few things; is there a world where he believes that his push is valid in your opinion?
Also why does the number of posts he called out lend itself more scummy and do you believe all fluff is unreadable?
There is a world where he believes that, it's just unlikely I guess.
No, I think significant amount of fluff in places where content is expected is scummy for sure. But content isn't really expected by page 4. Look at dunn and zach for example, no one's calling them out. And 3 posts of fluff in any case is not enough to be scummy, and most townies would agree with me I think.
When's content expected?
If you think someone should be calling out dunnstral and zachstralk why are you not calling them out?
Why does one need to be town to agree with you on what content is readable vs not? Personally I read by every word I possibly can, if you disagree that's theory, and I think that's where your push on bullet stems from.
Like, would you have found it more forgivable if he had called out a
larger
number of fluff posts, or didn't take issue with someone roleplaying awkwardly at all?