Undertale Mafia: Friends & Corpses [GAME OVER]

[MathBlade]

But I will PM this to Skull.

[Not Chara]

Would a miller return as is/was capable of killing even if they could not kill.

Nope nope nope they wouldn't

'a miller'. we're not talking about the wiki's miller, we're talking about the miller in this bastard game. was Skull answering for the generic 'miller' or for a universal miller? or did you specifically ask about Shiro's flipped miller role?

pedit: that.

[Narna]

This a50 is reminding me of caught a50 in deathnote mafia.

this would be a lot easier if that was the case.

1) his theorizing in that game was more grounded in mechanics that were actually possible, though it was an attempt at replicating his town meta. and this wasn't my influence, because he was doing that on his own.

2) i doubt he'd resort to a tactic i just saw him try as his hydra partner in this game.

3) besides that, they don't look similar to me. can you be more specific.

I'll look into it when I'm not on my phone. I remember him trying to discredit me using Wake's massive when I pointed out that doc was far more likely to be a scumrole with the deathnote mechanics.

[MathBlade]

So three options exist in order of likelihood:

1) Town derp -- What I believe
2) A Framer
3) Narna is scum and therefore Gio is as well.

[MathBlade]

Seriously with all the cops in this game Miller would have to operate differently than the wiki else it is almost useless.

[Almost50]

Would

a

miller return as is/was capable of killing even if they could not kill.

Nope nope nope they wouldn't

That was EXACTLY my point. "A" Miller would not. THE Miller Shiro had as a modifier would. It IS in the wiki page, just under "variants". You asked a "general question" and you got a "general" answer.

That is correct for the wiki version of Miller. However Shiro's version of Miller he explicitly said guilty on all investigations.

Exactly!

[Narna]

Would a miller return as is/was capable of killing even if they could not kill.

Nope nope nope they wouldn't

'a miller'. we're not talking about the wiki's miller, we're talking about the miller in this bastard game. was Skull answering for the generic 'miller' or for a universal miller? or did you specifically ask about Shiro's flipped miller role?

pedit: that.

Skull is linking kids the wiki page when they inquire about the miller, but it's not the miller from the wiki? How is that not intentionally misleading?

The wiki says that there can be specialized millers for roles that aren't gs or cop. The flip does not indicate anything of the sort.

[MathBlade]

So hence Narna is town derp for checking a claimed miller. No way scum buddies let Narna do that or claim to.

Which brings us to the Gio/Nahdia/Creeps/Narna town block. I am making an assumption here Gio isn't a liar here but I think with all the pressure he had that is okay.

[Narna]

Seriously with all the cops in this game Miller would have to operate differently than the wiki else it is almost useless.

Tell me our vanilla cop was anything but useless as well. The miller role would still more than likely force the miller to claim. It's more impactful than the vanilla cop in that regard.

[MathBlade]

Would a miller return as is/was capable of killing even if they could not kill.

Nope nope nope they wouldn't

'a miller'. we're not talking about the wiki's miller, we're talking about the miller in this bastard game. was Skull answering for the generic 'miller' or for a universal miller? or did you specifically ask about Shiro's flipped miller role?

pedit: that.

Skull is linking kids the wiki page when they inquire about the miller, but it's not the miller from the wiki? How is that not intentionally misleading?

The wiki says that there can be specialized millers for roles that aren't gs or cop. The flip does not indicate anything of the sort.

Because it answers exactly what you asked assuming Skull gives me the same answer.

[PeregrineV]

So great, we got two days until deadline

My vote will be on the highest of

Narna
Not Chara
Creature
SirCakez
Peregrine V

I do have a busy IRL. You have my scumreads.

I am not voting anyone else unless desperation. I townread everyone else.

Hey look, Creature scum is peddling disinterest to continue doing nothing or tunnelling me.

[MathBlade]

Seriously with all the cops in this game Miller would have to operate differently than the wiki else it is almost useless.

Tell me our vanilla cop was anything but useless as well. The miller role would still more than likely force the miller to claim. It's more impactful than the vanilla cop in that regard.

It probably was unless someone here is VT. Maybe Titus gets her token 1 VT thing she spouts odd but I don't believe is required.

[PeregrineV]

Of course.....

[PeregrineV]

@mathblade

- did you kill Titus?

[Almost50]

@NC:

Well, not responding to you directly should've told I concede and have no argument. If I didn't I do one of two things:

1- Respond back rephrasing my argument (as I was doing with Math a few posts ago);

OR

2- Respond sarcastically ridiculing yours and making it known that I refuse to accept it.

Come on.. you still have a few things to learn about me. Maybe in our NEXT hydra game (which I'm already looking forward to)

[MathBlade]

@mathblade

- did you kill Titus?

Considering I wasn't in the game yet no I did not kill titus and neither did Creature. I can't kill.

[MathBlade]

Lol and Peregrine V invents time travel

[Narna]

Whatever, I'm over it.

We will see.

Did you kill zakk math?

[MathBlade]

Like I am in the middle of a laughing and coughing fit right now.

I do not and never have I employed time travel in a game.

[MathBlade]

Whatever, I'm over it.

We will see.

Did you kill zakk math?

Again just said can't kill.

[PeregrineV]

@mathblade

- did you kill Titus?

Considering I wasn't in the game yet no I did not kill titus and neither did Creature. I can't kill.

Lol and Peregrine V invents time travel

you know what I mean. Your slot.

want to lynch Not Chara and probably Maxous.

[PeregrineV]

And I've played at least 3 time travel games I can recall right away.

[MathBlade]

@mathblade

- did you kill Titus?

Considering I wasn't in the game yet no I did not kill titus and neither did Creature. I can't kill.

Lol and Peregrine V invents time travel

you know what I mean. Your slot.

want to lynch Not Chara and probably Maxous.

Maxous is getting rope today just letting people get caught up.

[MathBlade]

And I've played at least 3 time travel games I can recall right away.

Okay I can't breathe you gotta stop PV. This hurts so much.

I did not kill anyone on any night. I am a tank.

[Not Chara]

@NC:

Well, not responding to you directly should've told I concede and have no argument. If I didn't I do one of two things:

1- Respond back rephrasing my argument (as I was doing with Math a few posts ago);

OR

2- Respond sarcastically ridiculing yours and making it known that I refuse to accept it.

Come on.. you still have a few things to learn about me. Maybe in our NEXT hydra game (which I'm already looking forward to)

sure :>

but can you really fault Mathblade for thinking you weren't listening. if you didn't really respond to me?