Open Game List (Players & Moderators) Archives

[mneme]

I stand by the argument I made while playing (scum, but my argument was genuine) in that game -- 2/1 kill/protect is a bum deal, and the way to "break" quack is for the town to avoid protecting entirely. The number of kills that are likely to happen due to the quacks far exceed the number the mafia can expect to make -- and without quack/doc being revealed on death, the mafia's lies don't have a good chance of being revealed unless they're dumb; there can always be hidden quacks among the dead doctors or vice versa.

By contrast, quack with revealed flavors on death probably -is- breakable, and probably -should- involve doctors protecting at some point before the endgame.

[skitzer]

Thanks. I have to wait till Saturday though. Right now, I'm comparing which list is longer, Open or Mini Normal.

[Sage]

/in for masons and monks

[Thesp]

Open 55 is full.

Vanilla 2:10

(Open 55)[/b] - 2 Mafia, 10 Townies, Daystart (12/12) - Mod: UltimaAvalon[/u]
Kate
pwayne66
Dracion
Jdodge
TylerJ
Tobiassen
DeathSauce
Elmo
d3sisted
Lowell
destructor
Jester

Still taking signups:

Masons and Monks

(Open 56)[/b] - 2 Mafia, 2 Werewolves, 2 Masons (non-Mafia), 2 Monks (non-Werewolves), 4-8 Townies, DayStart (10/12) - Mod: [/u]
farside22
pwayne66
kuribo
Jdodge
Flameaxe
Max
Oman
Draux
Gemelli
Sage

Quack Mafia

(Open 57)[/b] - 3 Mafia, 6 Doctors, 3 Quacks (will kill non-Mafia, but think they're Docs), DayStart (3/12) - Mod: [/u]
Oman
shaft.ed
Mastermind of Sin

[Thesp]

Open 53 is getting a new mod, and should have one by the end of the day. (gameshark1313 sent me the setup, and hasn't responded to subsequent PMs.)

Excuse me, but can 1st-time mods sign up here. JW because my three month wait is about over.

Absolutely! See the requirements here.

I stand by the argument I made while playing (scum, but my argument was genuine) in that game -- 2/1 kill/protect is a bum deal, and the way to "break" quack is for the town to avoid protecting entirely. The number of kills that are likely to happen due to the quacks far exceed the number the mafia can expect to make -- and without quack/doc being revealed on death, the mafia's lies don't have a good chance of being revealed unless they're dumb; there can always be hidden quacks among the dead doctors or vice versa.

By contrast, quack with revealed flavors on death probably -is- breakable, and probably -should- involve doctors protecting at some point before the endgame.

Discussion of the setup is probably best reserved for the Open Game Setup Discussion thread before the game enters signups, or during the game by the players.

[Mr. Flay]

Not poaching, honest- Thesp said I could do this!

Anyone who liked the Pie E7 format may be interested to know that we're trying it out for the next ten or so Newbie Games - be an IC or a newbie and help us test it to destruction!

Sign up there, not here, obviously... now back to your regularly scheduled queue.

[Hjallti]

I agreed to take on modding in Open 53 by the way so I guess I will be the mod there.

[kabenon007]

/in for Masons and Mafia

[Selande]

/in to mod

[Claus]

/in to mod

[Thesp]

I agreed to take on modding in Open 53 by the way so I guess I will be the mod there.

There were a couple who offered, but Hjallti got there first. Thanks!

[skitzer]

Well, here goes.

/in to mod.

I feel so accomplished now!

[Hjallti]

Open 53 - Near_Vanilla has not started yet but I already need 3 replacements:

shoe.
theopor_COD abandonded a game as mod
Shotgun_kitten abandonded illustrated mafia.

[TylerJ]

/in for Quack Mafia.

[thinktank]

/in for masons and monks

[TylerJ]

/in for masons and Monks

[TylerJ]

Also, I would like to be on the waiting list to Mod. I have played one game that has finished and another in wich I was killed, but isn't finished. Can I still be a mod, or do I have to wait for that game to finish?

[thedragonsprincess]

time to try something new.....
/in to mod

[Rishi]

My first Mini that I modded is over. I believe that means I can be on two lists at once to mod.

/in to mod.

[skitzer]

/in to replace shoe.

(if this is a real game, I don't want to replace in. Sorry for my confusionos.)

[Gemelli]

/out for Masons and Monks. Sorry about that!

[destructor]

/in to Mod

Also, wondering why Open 55 - Vanilla 2:10 hasn't started yet...

[Disciple Slayer]

/in for next

You cannot make another post with the exact same text as your last.

[Thesp]

Open 56 is full.

Masons and Monks

(Open 56)[/b] - 2 Mafia, 2 Werewolves, 2 Masons (non-Mafia), 2 Monks (non-Werewolves), 4-8 Townies, DayStart (12/12) - Mod: Samruc[/u]
farside22
pwayne66
kuribo
Jdodge
Flameaxe
Max
Oman
Draux
Sage
Kabenon007
thinktank
TylerJ

Still taking signups:

Quack Mafia

(Open 57)[/b] - 3 Mafia, 6 Doctors, 3 Quacks (will kill non-Mafia, but think they're Docs), DayStart (3/12) - Mod: [/u]
Oman
shaft.ed
Mastermind of Sin
TylerJ
Disciple Slayer

Also, I would like to be on the waiting list to Mod. I have played one game that has finished and another in wich I was killed, but isn't finished. Can I still be a mod, or do I have to wait for that game to finish?

Since you've been active on the site and completed one game, you may absolutely sign up to mod.

[TylerJ]

/in to mod.