Mini Normal 1839 - Game Over!

[MathBlade]

Will work on my last will tonight but I want from everyone their list of reads in order of scumminess.
Exclude me and yourself.

Scummiest >> Towniest

@ironstove this question

[ironstove]

nero
penguin
saru
lowell
bji/karnos

[Foxbird]

Votecount 4.14

karnos

(1) - Nero Cain

PenguinPower

(3) - Saru, Lowell, karnos

(L-2!)

Nero Cain

(2) - ironstove, bji

Not Voting

(2) - MathBlade, PenguinPower

With

8

players eligible to vote, it’s

5

to lynch!

Day 4 will end in

(expired on 2016-11-30 07:11:29).

Mod Notes:

None!

[Lowell]

This is evolving for me, since I'm still getting used to the new reality of saru being probable town.

Penguin
Karnos
bj
nero
saru
iron

I still think math's case on penguin nails it, and I don't see anything he's done in response as town. Even if you buy his argument that the aron death was random, his attitude change today has been a 180. He looks like "thought he got away with it floating by being nice" scum.

[Lowell]

Also I don't understand those voting nero if you buy that the aron kill was intentional. Either karnos or penguin or both are scum. If that's true, worst situation we lynch both and one is town and we'll be down to one scum at lylo. Why throw that off by lynching nero first? Even if you think he's scum?

[PenguinPower]

I still think math's case on penguin nails it, and I don't see anything he's done in response as town.

It is a dumb case. As scum, I would want to keep aron alive since he townread me, FA townread me, so everyone that aron added to the neighborhood could more easily be convinced that I was town. What did I gain by killing him? Oh, that's right, my current situation.

Dumb case is dumb.

Even if you buy his argument that the aron death was random, his attitude change today has been a 180.

Please point out said attitude change.

Either karnos or penguin or

both are scum

.

Bolded for emphasis: I think this might be the dumbest thing you've said.

[ironstove]

lowell why do you think nero is town ?

what has he specifically done that makes you refuse to lynch him?

[ironstove]

At this point, I'm pretty sure penguin is town.

[ironstove]

I'm also pretty sure still that nero is scum. Would like to lynch nero if we have a mislynch, then this is where we should use it, lynch the person that you're not sure about because in mylo/lylo you want to lynch the person you're pretty sure is scum.

(I'm pretty sure he's scum but the rest of you 'seem' to be uncertain).

[PenguinPower]

Ok. If it's not karnos, it has to be Nero.

VOTE: Nero

[MathBlade]

Still missing Saru and Neros list.

[MathBlade]

Town

MathBlade

ironstove
Nero Cain

bji
Saru

Lowell

karnos

Scum

Penguin your vote is inconsistent. If Karnos is town you should be voting Lowell.

[PenguinPower]

Except that entire list changes with karnos not being scum. You should read my posts since.

[PenguinPower]

Basically, Nero moves to the bottom, Saru right after that and then Lowell, karnos, bji, and iron.

[MathBlade]

I still think math's case on penguin nails it, and I don't see anything he's done in response as town.

It is a dumb case. As scum, I would want to keep aron alive since he townread me, FA townread me, so everyone that aron added to the neighborhood could more easily be convinced that I was town. What did I gain by killing him? Oh, that's right, my current situation.

Dumb case is dumb.

Even if you buy his argument that the aron death was random, his attitude change today has been a 180.

Please point out said attitude change.

Either karnos or penguin or

both are scum

.

Bolded for emphasis: I think this might be the dumbest thing you've said.

Still with attacking Lowell. Then naked vote of Nero.

[MathBlade]

Which list do you believe in more. What you posted or assuming Karnos is town?

[PenguinPower]

Still with attacking Lowell. Then naked vote of Nero.

If you weren't the IC, I'd be seeing scum. That wasn't an attack on Lowell, that was a defense for me from his post. That wasn't a naked vote on Nero, I explained why I thought Nero was scum if karnos wasn't scum in previous posts. Please start reading before writing. It's the responsible thing to do.

[PenguinPower]

Which list do you believe in more. What you posted or assuming Karnos is town?

You are really killing my confidence that you are actually paying attention to this game.

[MathBlade]

Which list do you believe in more. What you posted or assuming Karnos is town?

You are really killing my confidence that you are actually paying attention to this game.

I'm working on a massive comprehensive last will that takes into account the entire game. So summarily yes I am paying attention. It is not clear which you support only a seemingly unsupported unvote and vote combo. Where you just say if Karnos is scum he can "have it". That is not a case of believing Karnos is town.

[MathBlade]

You want us to believe that is what you think but I'm not seeing the explanation for the switch. That is what I am getting at.

[PenguinPower]

Then you missed the comment on my scum read on karnos relying of tone, previous experience, and complex actions. K. Cool. Thanks.

[MathBlade]

Then you missed the comment on my scum read on karnos relying of tone, previous experience, and complex actions. K. Cool. Thanks.

I did not miss that post I referred to it above. That is not an explanation. Explain to me why you are reading Karnos as town.

[MathBlade]

Otherwise I could say I roll a dice and I scum read you relying on tone, previous experience, and complex actions. (The middle is non existent but the other two indicate that you are likely scum.)

[PenguinPower]

Explain to me why you are reading Karnos as town.

I read karnos as not scum based on what I previously said. If karnos is not scum, then what I said about Nero/Saru must hold true. Thus, I vote Nero.

[Foxbird]

Bump!