1558 and 1559.In post 1699, Nero Cain wrote:What is your case on me besides "didn't vote Thor"?
A few reasons --In post 1701, Nero Cain wrote:Why did you feel the need to answer for Iron?
In post 1700, bji wrote: What happened between your day 1 vigor where you made posts like 284 and started wagons and such, and today, when you can't even be bothered to read the game?
You never showed that.In post 1704, Nero Cain wrote: I mean you have argued (and Iron) that I'm scummy for pushing Mal but as I have shown I've lynched scum for this exact same reason so why is it scummy that I'd think Mal could be scum for the exact same reason?
This is me showing where I have successfully flipped scum using the "there are posting elsewhere but ignoring this game" tellIn post 1085, Nero Cain wrote: As an example, this game had a player that flipped scum while constantly posting elsewhere.
but its just one example!
There are more but I don't feel like slogging through my past games to find them. Its a somewhat common scumtell.
In post 1704, Nero Cain wrote:Why do you think Karnos couldn't have known Mal was town?
this is a lie. I didn't flip them but they were still scum that was posting it up elsewhere while ignoring that game.In post 1711, Nero Cain wrote:This is me showing where I have successfully flipped scum using the "there are posting elsewhere but ignoring this game" tell
I'm ok with him claiming though I'm p sure that was a fake venge kill claim.In post 1709, bji wrote:I'm curious to know what you think of iron's claim. Don't you want to know what his actual role is? You haven't expressed any interest.
How can I be sure that you haven't been in 100 other games where you mislynched 100 town players for the same dumb reason? How can I be sure you didn't just cherrypick the one or two cases to present here where you got lucky and caught scum instead?In post 1711, Nero Cain wrote:This is me showing where I have successfully flipped scum using the "there are posting elsewhere but ignoring this game" tellIn post 1085, Nero Cain wrote: As an example, this game had a player that flipped scum while constantly posting elsewhere.
but its just one example!
There are more but I don't feel like slogging through my past games to find them. Its a somewhat common scumtell.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=60340
^
that too. It was Ika
Why do you think iron would fake a venge kill claim? Why do you think he would fake any claim?In post 1715, Nero Cain wrote:I'm ok with him claiming though I'm p sure that was a fake venge kill claim.In post 1709, bji wrote:I'm curious to know what you think of iron's claim. Don't you want to know what his actual role is? You haven't expressed any interest.
In post 1716, bji wrote:Huh? Are you quoting yourself and admitting you lied?
By the way just to be clear, I don't even know what a "fake venge kill claim" is, all I am sure about is the "fake" part, I am assuming that the rest means some kind of "revenge kill" thing where if scum kill him then the scum who fired the shot dies too.In post 1717, bji wrote:Why do you think iron would fake a venge kill claim? Why do you think he would fake any claim?In post 1715, Nero Cain wrote:I'm ok with him claiming though I'm p sure that was a fake venge kill claim.In post 1709, bji wrote:I'm curious to know what you think of iron's claim. Don't you want to know what his actual role is? You haven't expressed any interest.
He's scum that thought he'd claim a role that could maybe explain why he's not dead. He's derp town that is doing a useless fakeclaim since thats in vouge these days. IDK. Remind me what you think he claimed.In post 1717, bji wrote:Why do you think iron would fake a venge kill claim? Why do you think he would fake any claim?In post 1715, Nero Cain wrote:I'm ok with him claiming though I'm p sure that was a fake venge kill claim.In post 1709, bji wrote:I'm curious to know what you think of iron's claim. Don't you want to know what his actual role is? You haven't expressed any interest.
I probably have lynched town for this, does it matter? The point is there's possible scum motivation in ignoring a certain game. So explain to me what the town motivation is?In post 1716, bji wrote:How can I be sure that you haven't been in 100 other games where you mislynched 100 town players for the same dumb reason? How can I be sure you didn't just cherrypick the one or two cases to present here where you got lucky and caught scum instead?In post 1711, Nero Cain wrote:This is me showing where I have successfully flipped scum using the "there are posting elsewhere but ignoring this game" tellIn post 1085, Nero Cain wrote: As an example, this game had a player that flipped scum while constantly posting elsewhere.
but its just one example!
There are more but I don't feel like slogging through my past games to find them. Its a somewhat common scumtell.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=60340
^
that too. It was Ika
If I'm supposed to be evaluating whether or not you are likely to have believed that going after someone for possible V/LA abuse is a strategy that you had seen work more often than not, then unless I can verifiably know how often you have seen it work, I cannot even make that evaluation. And I cannot verifably know how often you have seen it work versus not work.
This is why I don't read external games. It is a useless exercise.
In post 1713, Nero Cain wrote:If you think PP is scum why were you up in arms about my assertion that scum would and could bus Thor?
In post 1712, Nero Cain wrote:In post 1704, Nero Cain wrote:Why do you think Karnos couldn't have known Mal was town?
First, I was not "up in arms" about your assertion that "scum would and could bus Thor", I was expressing disbelief that you could be genuine in your argument that anyone lynching Thor would have been doing so for "town cred", when there was really zero town cred to be gained from carrying out a lynch that was really just a formality at that point.In post 1713, Nero Cain wrote:If you think PP is scum why were you up in arms about my assertion that scum would and could bus Thor?