If you're going to continue talking about lynching karnos then lynch me first because you literally have not read anything in this game.
Scum is Saru 100%, I am almost sure about Nero but I'll revisit and rebuild the case as well.
I hate building cases, it's tedious and I feel like I'm doing the work that other people should be doing, but let me hold your hand and explain everything for you on why Karnos is town.
Like I don't want to go through every single post but
389 ,
392 ,
411,
418,
pretty much clearly draw a line of who karnos is in this game. These are not scum motivated posts, and not posts that feel like a scum!karnos would make.
Then regarding saru, the posts I highlighted above make him look relatively scummy until :
515,
519, and
662.
These posts are super towny, at least I thought up until the point that thor flipped encryptor. I imagine it's possible that Saru received some coaching from daychat to formulate the posts I wrote above. I say this because Saru has remained extremely inconsistent. He says he's left handed but still writes with his right.
like
673, he indicates that KnightyKnight is a scum read despite the fact that knight's vote is parked on the Thor slot. Interesting that Saru says in 662 'I am almost certain that Thor is scum' and in the following post tries to FOS someone who is voting someone who voting a slot whom 'he is almost certain is scum'. Clearly a major slip here.
Major actions on why nero/saru are most likely scum this game:
1. Nero pushing the heavy mal lynch, off of his partners saru and thor. Yet he knows this is a slot that can't claim, we're lynching this slot for inactivity... Incredibly scummy wagon, yet he calls out karnos as scummy for voting thor with no chance for town to discuss even though we're discussing right now, so what's the issue? My belief is that this was because thor/saru are the PRs, like thor is obviously encryptor, but saru has to be roleblocker at this point.
Nero also made
772 which I would say clears penguin if nero flips scum, and implicates saru further.
2. Saru indicating
662 which was made sense up until it came time to stand by his words, he parked his vote on lowel, who was neither knightyknight, or thor, when thor was in hammer range. I.e.
1260 he says giving intent to hammer and he returns and doesn't hammer. Thor follows in with a scummy tracker claim and then saru makes this disgusting post in
1339 trying to pin the nl on lowell, when his inaction caused the result as well, using the tracker claim as an excuse LOL.
Now we're here in D4, nero is trying to ML karnos saying the quickhammer killed town discussion and disallowed scum hunting. This is a bullshit excuse and those of you that are buying it are fools because quick hammering in that situation DOES NOTHING but stop THOR WHO HAS AVOIDED BEING THE LYNCH FOR 2 DAYS IN A ROW FROM GETTING AWAY A 3RD DAY. AND WE CAN EASILY SCUM HUNT THE FOLLOWING DAY.
In all seriousness, please explain to me 1 reason why quick hammering there is so bad? What could we have done then that we can't do today? NOTHING.
So I say lynch between {saru, nero}, if either one flips town, we need to reassess the {lowell, penguin} pool, but at this point, town are in {bji, karnos, math}
