Undertale Mafia: Friends & Corpses [GAME OVER]

[Creature]

So what's your opinion on how Narna acted after being hammered?

[SirCakez]

Actually I could see Almost scum
I can't remember any of his posting from days previous which is a bad sign (town Almost is usually pretty outspoken)

[Nahdia]

Actually I could see Almost scum
I can't remember any of his posting from days previous which is a bad sign (town Almost is usually pretty outspoken)

That would be because he's a recent replacement.

[SirCakez]

He replaced in almost two weeks ago tho

[Nahdia]

man was it really that long ago.

either way it was half way through yesterday and he spent most of yesterday catching up so my point stands.

[massive]

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

[Not Chara]

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

i agree with this.

those scumreading Almost: i'd like to vouch for him. he wouldn't avoid posting because he's scum. more likely, he's been busy, so you aren't seeing the activity that might be usual for him. plus, Gamma was town.

if Titus won't become a healthy wagon, Shiro and Creature are fine options.

[Creature]

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

Let's see if their opinion will change if Narna catches one of them.

[Almost50]

Almost, I want you to respond to what Narna said, because I don't think it's nonsense at all.

I already did though. Thank you very much.

[Almost50]

So what's your opinion on how Narna acted after being hammered?

[Almost50]

town Almost is usually pretty outspoken

I've been telling you FACTS ever since I replaced in, but you're just not reading, which is a great portion of why I'm scum reading you. Both Nahdia & Chara have been paying attention, and that earned them town points.

P.S. My "town points" are granted to those who know me well and have played more than one game before. I do not expect those who never played with me (or played me maybe once) to understand so they neither earn town points nor scum points for failing to understand my OBVIOUS messages.

[Skullduggery]

Day 3, Vote Count #13

Current Vote Count:

(0)

SirCakez

(1)

Giovanni il Pellegrino -- PeregrineV

(0)

Maxous

(2)

Creature -- Almost50, Not Chara

(0)

PeregrineV

(1)

Titus -- Creature

(1)

Shiro -- SirCakez

(0)

Nahdia

(0)

Firebringer

(6)

Not Chara -- Ankamius, Andrius, Titus, Firebringer, Maxous, massive

(0)

Ankamius

(0)

SlySly

(1)

SnarkySnowman -- Nahdia

(0)

Narna

(1)

Almost50 -- Narna

(1)

Leonshade -- Giovanni il Pellegrino

(0)

Andrius

(0)

massive

Not Voting:

SnarkySnowman, Shiro, Leonshade, SlySly

With 18 votes available, it takes 10 votes to hammer.

Leonshade is V/LA until 11/13.
PeregrineV is V/LA until 11/14.

Day 3 Will End on Sunday, November 20th, at 9 p.m. eastern time.
Countdown: (expired on 2016-11-20 21:00:00)

[Creature]

So what's your opinion on how Narna acted after being hammered?

I think it was more likely how town reacts after being hammered. What about you?

[Titus]

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

i agree with this.

those scumreading Almost: i'd like to vouch for him. he wouldn't avoid posting because he's scum. more likely, he's been busy, so you aren't seeing the activity that might be usual for him. plus, Gamma was town.

if Titus won't become a healthy wagon, Shiro and Creature are fine options.

Five points to anyone who sees the problem(s) with this argument.

[SlySly]

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

I just feel like Leonshade had enough town cred that opening himself up to be scumread for governing Narna would be a bad move. I don't feel like Narna's claimed role is THAT critical for scum to keep around and waste town cred over.

i agree with this.

those scumreading Almost: i'd like to vouch for him. he wouldn't avoid posting because he's scum. more likely, he's been busy, so you aren't seeing the activity that might be usual for him. plus, Gamma was town.

if Titus won't become a healthy wagon, Shiro and Creature are fine options.

Five points to anyone who sees the problem(s) with this argument.

1. Assuming Narna is scum, her "claimed role" is fake and not a factor in scum decision making.
2. NC agrees with this nonsense.
3. NC goes out of way to "vouch" for Almost unprompted.

What did I miss?

[Titus]

15 points, 10 of which I did not see. (2 and 3)

4. It implies scum would believe her role is legit and scum and useless. Namely, that Narna's role fits the pattern of useless roles and if Narna was scum, they'd let a kill detector die.

[massive]

I understand Narna's claim may be fictitious if Narna is scum. Narna's result, however, is an actual result. You are asking me to do some high-level tin-foil hoop-jumping to get to a point where I don't at least believe Narna has access to that result. Calling it "nonsense" is just you trying to alienate me. Is that your game plan here?

[Titus]

I understand Narna's claim may be fictitious if Narna is scum. Narna's result, however, is an actual result. You are asking me to do some high-level tin-foil hoop-jumping to get to a point where I don't at least believe Narna has access to that result. Calling it "nonsense" is just you trying to alienate me. Is that your game plan here?

That result access just means she's scum and you're town. Gunsmith is easy to fake as scum.

We should be publicly dictating who Narna checks. Worse case scenario, we get associatives. Who do you think she should check?

[Nahdia]

...You.

[Creature]

If it's possible to fully clear someone from being scum...

[Titus]

I am cool with that if that's what's needed to get scum NC roped.

It's not the most optimal as I am useless, but if it's needed to pull the thread together, we lynch NC/Leon and Narna checks me.

[Nahdia]

I mean, that'd be my preference anyway. Clearing anyone would be nice, but being able to trust you in particular would be very much welcome.

[Nahdia]

Course I'd probably just end up paranoid ranting about possible redirectors.

[Titus]

I mean, that'd be my preference anyway. Clearing anyone would be nice, but being able to trust you in particular would be very much welcome.

My results come in terms of [Player Name] is vanilla/not vanilla, so Narna's should come the same way. If Narna is town, they would know of redirectors.

[Creature]

Oh right, redirectors.