Large Normal 197: Wordplay Mafia OVER

[gerryoat]

Nahdia what is your read on me?

[PeregrineV]

@PerV, Refreshing change in your play. I like it. Withholding comments until I hear from others.

Meh, not sure if I do.

I am aiming for most posts this game, as a secondary goal.

[PeregrineV]

[Titus]

@Gerry, I would like your reads.

[BigYoshiFan]

Sorry I've been lurking guys... I have so much on me right now.
I feel so rushed to catch up when I come back, that after I read through everything it goes out the other ear. I might even request a replacement.
Going over everything I missed, I no longer like my vote on drealmerz. His argument on Dunnstral was quite compelling in my opinion, but I still have a strong townread on him because, well, I don't see how Dunnstral gains anything by outting a partner like that. Personally, I think scum wouldn't be trying to lynch someone who outted a scum member. I do also like Gear for the quality of his posts.
Looking at Gerry, something I didn't like after Transcend's flip was the interaction they had at the beginning of the game. I don't know, seems like something they would do with how Transcend has played this game. Also, I don't like how Gerry is defending himself against PV in 1806 by saying he tunneled Transcend. I was a victim of his tunneling in a game where he was scum, and his tunneling then was some hardcore tunneling.
UNVOTE: drealmerz7
Hopefully more on PV later.

[BigYoshiFan]

Oh, and more on Nahdia too.

[drealmerz7]

I'd like to see groupings from everyone

which 3 scum-buddies make sense to you?

Dunn/PV/Gear

I'm going to go read gerry again after I get some food made, it could be a couple hours (or tomorrow because I could possibly pass out asleep after food), I am really trying to make the best choice that makes sense to me.

[drealmerz7]

Titus, we're kind of stuck, if you'd take your time and read the full thread and give an opinion then, it would be greatly appreciated. My HS has a different culture. A bullied hammer would never go over, the bully (transcend) would have been immediately PLed on D2, and even more possible with the DC we'd have probably just PLed yoshi immediately come D3, and we'd simply be somewhere completely different now and things would be a lot clearer. I had a hard time navigating for a bit, but I'm back with it, and I STILL feel like dunn is a good lynch, and the PL stuff is simply SUPPORT to the rest of the reasons.

I don't feel like anyone has made a good case for anyone else, but I'm open.

[Titus]

Drealmerz, as aggressive as I am, you aren't getting a wall flower. I rarely read the full thread upon subbing in, but you will not be getting a lazy woman.

[Dunnstral]

I feel as if bigyoshifan is our best lynch. I don't scumread gear

Why do people think he can't be with Transcend again?

[Dunnstral]

like let's look what he's done this game:

Quickhammered town pr without waiting for a claim

Votes Transcend after being asked to wait to end the day as fast as possible

[drealmerz7]

and did you express an issue with either thing at the time he did them?

[Dunnstral]

I wasn't even here when you guys quicklynched

Yes, I expressed an issue and then he voted to end the day anyway. Then I called him out on it and he left his vote

[Titus]

Dunn, your reads?

[drealmerz7]

Dunn, your reads?

"not me!" is his read

[Nahdia]

Nahdia what is your read on me?

lean town but willing to vote cause poe says even if i townread you independently you've got a good shot at flipping scum and im pretty tired of this game.

[Dunnstral]

Dunn, your reads?

Bigyoshi scum
peregrine scummy
Nahdia Null
gerryoat towny
Road Kamelot towny
You're town (your slot shot bp night 1)
Bins is probably town (1-shot bp odd-night doctor)

drealmer is really bad or scum

[drealmerz7]

nice omission of gear

[Dunnstral]

leantown on gear

[Bins]

From the POV of the claimed person let's not mass claim yo

[Gear]

My HS has a different culture. A bullied hammer would never go over, the bully (transcend) would have been immediately PLed on D2, and even more possible with the DC we'd have probably just PLed yoshi immediately come D3

Can you provide a link to a game that shows that this is true?

[gerryoat]

Nahdia what is your read on me?

lean town but willing to vote cause poe says even if i townread you independently you've got a good shot at flipping scum and im pretty tired of this game.

lol wot????????????????????????????????????????????? in what universe do you vote a tr

[Nahdia]

Nahdia what is your read on me?

lean town but willing to vote cause poe says even if i townread you independently you've got a good shot at flipping scum and im pretty tired of this game.

lol wot????????????????????????????????????????????? in what universe do you vote a tr

a universe where i've got too many tr's.

[drealmerz7]

My HS has a different culture. A bullied hammer would never go over, the bully (transcend) would have been immediately PLed on D2, and even more possible with the DC we'd have probably just PLed yoshi immediately come D3

Can you provide a link to a game that shows that this is true?

I can but I won't. Coming to MS I made it policy to not meta-mine anyone in games prior to my joining and reversely I desire to not be meta-mined in games prior to my joining. I don't know how long I'll try to keep my HS a "secret", but until I establish myself a bit more here I'm going to keep it on the DL. Honestly I went into a super-experienced group of players head-first into the deep end and am not proud of a lot of my play as I learned to play (I've only been playing a bit over a year - though I did have some good early games, I'm a bit ashamed of my behavior in a couple others, ya know, mafia drama shit that is stupid, it was some growing pains, and the last thing I want is someone to view that crap - ya know, FTSIQ moments and petty bickering that I'd rather forget.)

So as much as I'd like to inform everyone I play with on MS of my prior experience (and who doesn't like to show off a couple games where they're proud of their performance?), I'm tempering it with the realization that building a mafia reputation is meaningful and I am here to start afresh.

Do know that I still play on my HS (I just finished hosting my first game - a 17p large theme game) so it's not like I've been blacklisted or whatever. It's not like that.

I can answer more questions about culture and experience if you like, but I won't be sharing links or naming the site.

[drealmerz7]

Never had an ACTUAL FTSIQ moment, but, it's been close. We run some crazy games and it can be infuriating (ya know, games without deadlines and 0 flavor, no flips, undisclosed bastardry) - I don't know if there's anyone on the site that hasn't had some GRRAAHHHHHH (nod) moments.