Large Normal 197: Wordplay Mafia OVER

[Gear]

he believes dunnstral's "result on bins day 2 = 1-shot bp odd-night doctor!!!!" and then says "Bins - I am primarily worried because of the claim - odd night doctor, while the vigs are on nights 1 and 3."

you can't have it both ways, thnks for outting yourself as dunn's scum-buddy, as how I'ma read all that

So what do you think the problem is here?
For me the issue is that bins as odd night doc would be useful for scum to counteract the town day 1 and 3 vigs.

[Nahdia]

Nahdia, I'd like you also explain why you think that the town is stacked if all the claimed pr's are scum?

what

[Nahdia]

Much as I appreciate the effort in the final quarter, Gear, color me unconvinced.

[Nahdia]

Assuming you meant "why is town stacked if all claimed pr's are town"; it's a lot of PR's for us to have, including two relatively powerful investigative PR's.

Also

It really would have made more sense for bins to have protected Spyrex last night,

let dunns use his one-shot bp

, if necessary, and then we'd have more living players or dunns would still be bp.

On the other hand this seems like a mess for scum to deal with, so I think there is very likely scum in the bps. Trying to sort through this is why I think we should mass claim.

Where'd you read Dunn is a bulletproof?

[Gear]

Where'd you read Dunn is a bulletproof?

He fake claimed it at some point.

[Gear]

Assuming you meant "why is town stacked if all claimed pr's are town"; it's a lot of PR's for us to have, including two relatively powerful investigative PR's.

If you believed this, you would be pushing on Dunn.

[drealmerz7]

you can't have it both ways, thnks for outting yourself as dunn's scum-buddy, as how I'ma read all that

So what do you think the problem is here?
For me the issue is that bins as odd night doc would be useful for scum to counteract the town day 1 and 3 vigs.[/quote]
The problem is the progression of events - that when presented with the "deal" of "if bins flips town are you okay being the next lynch" dunnstral did not comply and the lynch did not go through on bins. If dunnstral believes bins to be scum, he would have continued the push on bins and complied with the deal. Instead, it fizzled into nothing and he instead led the charge on low-hanging-fruit.

[drealmerz7]

oops somehow fucked up quote tags

[Nahdia]

Assuming you meant "why is town stacked if all claimed pr's are town"; it's a lot of PR's for us to have, including two relatively powerful investigative PR's.

If you believed this, you would be pushing on Dunn.

The risk vs reward isn't there, my man. I already said we should be lynching outside PR claims for now.

[drealmerz7]

redo:

So what do you think the problem is here?
For me the issue is that bins as odd night doc would be useful for scum to counteract the town day 1 and 3 vigs.

The problem is the progression of events - that when presented with the "deal" of "if bins flips town are you okay being the next lynch" dunnstral did not comply and the lynch did not go through on bins. If dunnstral believes bins to be scum, he would have continued the push on bins and complied with the deal. Instead, it fizzled into nothing and he instead led the charge on low-hanging-fruit.

[Gear]

you can't have it both ways, thnks for outting yourself as dunn's scum-buddy, as how I'ma read all that

So what do you think the problem is here?
For me the issue is that bins as odd night doc would be useful for scum to counteract the town day 1 and 3 vigs.

The problem is the progression of events - that when presented with the "deal" of "if bins flips town are you okay being the next lynch" dunnstral did not comply and the lynch did not go through on bins. If dunnstral believes bins to be scum, he would have continued the push on bins and complied with the deal. Instead, it fizzled into nothing and he instead led the charge on low-hanging-fruit.[/quote]
And how does this relate to my alignment?

[Gear]

Assuming you meant "why is town stacked if all claimed pr's are town"; it's a lot of PR's for us to have, including two relatively powerful investigative PR's.

If you believed this, you would be pushing on Dunn.

The risk vs reward isn't there, my man. I already said we should be lynching outside PR claims for now.

Maybe, but you'd still be pushing him, and not posting things like:

VOTE: dunnstral

come with me if you want to live

is this a serious vote

[Nahdia]

I was asking if it was a serious vote because I can see good reasons to vote Dunn and was trying to see what I could coax out of him.

[Gear]

LOL

so his getting Transcend lynched was...

[drealmerz7]

And how does this relate to my alignment?

vote dunnstral with me and let me see how it relates to your alignment

[Nahdia]

You're serious grasping. Why the fuck would I not question him thoroughly if I'm trying to get a read on him? There are reasons to vote Dunn. There are also reasons to not vote Dunn. I wanted his full reasoning you dunce.

[Gear]

And how does this relate to my alignment?

vote dunnstral with me and let me see how it relates to your alignment

I want you to answer my question seriously.

[Nahdia]

Yeah I really like my vote.

[Nahdia]

I don't seriously believe the lines of thought Gear is having are lines of thought someone actually actively trying to parse the game would be having.

[Gear]

You're serious grasping. Why the fuck would I not question him thoroughly if I'm trying to get a read on him? There are reasons to vote Dunn. There are also reasons to not vote Dunn. I wanted his full reasoning you dunce.

I think that if you are looking for someone's full reasoning, you don't ask "Is this vote serious"? You'd ask something more neutral like "Why?"

You ask "Is this vote serious?" to disparage the person making the vote, which you wouldn't do if you agreed with it.

[Nahdia]

Thanks for telling me what tone I'm supposed to take.

[Nahdia]

Believe it or not, this is how I talk. Call the goddamn presses, fuckwit.

[Gear]

Thanks for telling me what tone I'm supposed to take.

If you were town, I wouldn't have to.

If you weren't voting for me, who would you be voting for?

[Nahdia]

lmfao, do I need to link my games to prove that this is my goddamn vernacular?

[Nahdia]

Do you wanna know why I felt like this town is stacked, Gear?