California Trilogy - Dantès in Fresno (Game Over!)

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't believe DGB's claim unless he's hidden in his closet every night.

Sorry to say - but Zindie did not hide even once.

I really can't help that one. Those were his choices.

[Mr. Grey]

Vote Count:

5 to lynch.

Gaspar: 1 (DrippingGoofball/Zindaras)
DrippingGoofball/Zindaras: 1 (Setael)

[Gaspar]

Vote: DrippingGoofball

[Setael]

If Gaspar is telling the truth about his claim, he was not out of bed last night, since he's already killed Dantes, right?

So... if DGB turns out to be telling the truth, we know Gaspar is scum.

At this point I believe Gaspar over DGB. My only hang-up is that I really can't see a replacement coming in, not reading the thread and claiming THAT if he's scum. However, that hang up is outweighed by the fact that if he was town, he'd have given those results as soon as he claimed. The time between his claim at 1:16 and his results at 4:40 is plenty of time to look over the thread and make sure your results work with who was in the game when, etc.

Anyway, I'm happy with my vote on DGB.

[Sarcastro]

Silent Lee, Setael, IH, Dragon Phoenix. That's my preferred order. Feel free to claim early if you want.

[DrippingGoofball]

The time between his claim at 1:16 and his results at 4:40 is plenty of time to look over the thread and make sure your results work with who was in the game when, etc.

That's very very unfair. My husband was waiting for me to help him shop for a birthday present for his sister, so I was out shopping. I still haven't read the game. When I returned home, I posted in another game first, then checked this thread, and felt cold metal on my ample temple. Feel free to vote for me for any other reason, but that one is just too unfair. I play mafia a lot, but I am not a shut in, I have a son and a husband, websites to mind and a house to take care of.

[DrippingGoofball]

So... if DGB turns out to be telling the truth, we know Gaspar is scum.

I don't want to be hasty here - again I HAVE NOT READ THE GAME - but if that's true... wouldn't that explain Gaspar's rush to vote me?

I might be totally out to lunch, please bear with me, this is a very challenging replacement.

[Setael]

Actually, that logic makes no sense. If Gaspar is scum and you are telling the truth, he wouldn't want you lynched because if you come up town and were telling the truth, he's caught.

The "I'm busy and I have a life" excuse doesn't fly here imo. If you had time to post at all, to be online long enough to claim, then you had long enough to give your results. The only reason you wouldn't is if you were fabricating them.

[DrippingGoofball]

The "I'm busy and I have a life" excuse doesn't fly here imo. If you had time to post at all, to be online long enough to claim, then you had long enough to give your results. The only reason you wouldn't is if you were fabricating them.

My husband was standing behind me tapping his foot on the floor as I was claiming. I said, two more minutes, I want to finish this post. And to put things in context, I am a grown woman, and to make people wait while I play mafia is unbecoming and silly.

It's not an excuse. It's absolutely true. Vote me all you want, but not for this patently wrong reason. Do you want me to scan the two store bills I have with the time stamps? I also went to two stores and bought knitting yarn. If I post the bills, will that work for you?

[Sarcastro]

This is really not an important discussion right now. We can decide who's scum when everybody's claimed.

[DrippingGoofball]

Well to me it is. I want to set the record straight.



14:13 and 14:49 are the times of my purchases. We went to several shops.

Image removed. Please see the rules for acceptable tags. - Mod

[Setael]

Unvote. I need to think on that one.

Votes/Unvotes not appearing at the bottom of the post are not counted. Tags removed. - Mod

[Setael]

Unvote. I need to think on that one.

Votes/Unvotes not appearing at the bottom of the post are not counted. Tags removed. - Mod

[Sarcastro]

I changed my mind. Setael before Silent Lee.

Claim now, please.

[Setael]

Probably wise since Silent Lee doesn't seem to be in a real hurry. Leon S. Peters, Innocent and Boring.

Are you at all worried you'll out a doc? That would be bad.

[Gaspar]

....d'you think there's a second Doc out there, Setael?

[Setael]

Oh yeah, forgot about foolinc. Can you tell I was never sure about his claim?

[Talitha]

Let's get a roll on with the claims so we can lynch goofball. (Sorry Goofball... you are a darling for replacing.)

I am starting to feel more confident that town can win this game.

[Sarcastro]

Silent Lee, you're up.

And no, I'm not worried about outing anything. Protecting power roles is not nearly as important as finding scum at this point.

[IH]

I would say DGB's claim is extremely null. It feels more like a rolecop/hider, but it could just as well be something akin to a gunsmith/hider......

meh, I agree with SL claiming. Sarc as well.

[DrippingGoofball]

I still haven't read the game...

But I did find these quotes from the book with my name in it:

"But will no one remain in the house, my lord?" asked Baptistin.
"Yes, the porter."
"My lord will remember that the lodge is at a distance from the house."
"Well?"
"The house might be stripped without his hearing the least noise."
"By whom?"
"By thieves."

So Baptistin is just some butler, but he's obviously concerned about the possibility of thieves at night.

All was dark; one solitary, feeble light was burning in the porter's lodge, about forty paces distant from the house, as Baptistin had said. Monte Cristo leaned against a tree, and with that scrutinizing glance which was so rarely deceived, looked up and down the avenue, examined the passers-by, and carefully looked down the neighboring streets, to see that no one was concealed.

"All was dark; one solitary, feeble light was burning in the porter's lodge, about forty paces distant from the house, as Baptistin had said." Again, Baptistin is getting some information during the night. However, it is Monte Cristo that acts upon this information and inquires fully, not Baptistin himself. Baptistin stays away from the real action.

My role is extremely null indeed, but it makes perfect sense with the character. As you'd expect from a carefully planned Mr. Grey game. And I think, technically, it's more of a reporter/hider type of thing than rolecop/hider or whatever/hider.

Please see the rules for acceptable tags. Tags removed. - Mod

[IH]

gunsmith tells if a player has a kill or not?

Maybe closer to a watcher or nightwatchman.

but whatev

[Dragon Phoenix]

All this waiting until it's my turn to claim is nice, but I almost forgot to post at all to meet the 25 words minimum requisite. Corrected with this post. I have some thoughts about the claims so far, but I'd rather wait until everyone has claimed.

[DrippingGoofball]

Unvote. I need to think on that one.

Votes/Unvotes not appearing at the bottom of the post are not counted. Tags removed. - Mod

I'd be really happy to see that in bold.

[Gaspar]

So... I think I am going to start taking odds on whether SiLee shows up to post or ends up getting replaced himself in the next eight hours or whatever it is. This is getting a bit ridiculous and in the meantime, we're wasting our time. Can we have DP claim in the meantime or something?