Mini 527 - Doom in Valencia - Game Over!

[SirWario]

Mcstab hasn't even posted in this game for two weeks. I think some serious prods/replacements are necessary.

Mod, prod deathguise, Mcstab, ridethebomb, selande, and sikario8

[soupfly]

agreed. this sucks.

[RideTheBomb]

Neko, I'm voting for MeMe because she's voting for me. So MeMe, why did you vote for me?

You deserve it.

And what exactly did I do to deserve it?

[Sikario8]

For my first insightful point, I would like to state, declare rather, that souply is scum - it says so right above his avatar. I'd also like to say that this is not my best reasoning; however, it must suffice for the time being.

[gorckat]

Random stage II!

Coming soon to a game near you

[Sammich]

I give Random stage II a 1 out of 5.

[soupfly]

For my first insightful point, I would like to state, declare rather, that souply is scum - it says so right above his avatar. I'd also like to say that this is not my best reasoning; however, it must suffice for the time being.

why are you giving us away? don't you realize that it also says scum above your avatar? its amazing nobody's figured it out yet...

[MeMe]

And what exactly did I do to deserve it?

Read your posts and explain to me why you

don't

deserve to be voted.

[gorckat]

And what exactly did I do to deserve it?

Read your posts and explain to me why you

don't

deserve to be voted.

Burden of Proof?

[MeMe]

Oh, brother. Classic example of why I hate the wiki.

I didn't say he was scum. I said he deserves to be voted. Do you

not

the think the burden of being non-voteworthy is his?

[gorckat]

Hey- I'm willing to be enlightened

Now I see your unstated distinction between

scum

and

vote-worthiness

. I had simply thought that since we'd pretty much passed the random stage (at one point, anyways) that any vote by an active player was an indicator of suspicion.

[Sammich]

why are you giving us away? don't you realize that it also says scum above your avatar? its amazing nobody's figured it out yet...

OMGNOWAI
VOTE SAMMICH HE GOT SCUM ABOV HIS AVATAR HE IS ScUM OBVOBVOBVOBVOBV

[RideTheBomb]

And what exactly did I do to deserve it?

Read your posts and explain to me why you

don't

deserve to be voted.

Well, if you want to keep going in circles over here that's fine with me. Read my posts and explain to me why I deserve to be voted.

[Sammich]

One thing, I guess I'll

Unvote.

Two,

FOS RideTheBomb

. Why get so up in arms over one vote? Meme hates lurkers, and I'm guessing she says you deserve it for not contributing to the game.

[RideTheBomb]

She's given me the impression she has a reason for casting her vote, I'm simply curious as to what it is. If Meme felt I was lurking when she voted, why not simply say so when I asked her?

[neko2086]

I'm a bit surprised that sikario didn't get any more than sarcastic comments for his "first insightful point." As long as we're talking about who's lurking and who's actually trying to contribute, I'd actually make the argument that sikario is doing more lurking than anyone else. He has posted more than some of the others, but nothing of any real content.

I think there's a huge difference between ignoring the game and actively lurking. In other words, we don't really know if some of the people who haven't been present are making the decision to lurk, or maybe they're just busy/lazy/whatever and aren't posting yet. Sikario, on the other hand, is present, but making contentless posts to skate by. A well-deserved

FOS

for him.

Actually, I have a question for you now, Sikario. You admitted that your reasoning is crap, but that it has to do for now. May I ask why that's all you have? Do you have more coming up? (In other words, what the hell?)

[Sikario8]

While I support your use of a vote as a catalyst, I don't believe this should be excersized so freely. I do agree with your 21-question technique, though, if the questioned chooses to answer (which I'm trying to do). I've been busy; however, when I checked in, I saw that no one had contributed crap and so I put in a quick post to imply my being alive and semi-well and went on about my business.

I would like to FOS MeMe and RTB for circular reason. We're never going to kill any mafia if we can't get organized. I actually believe it'd be more constructive if every individual were to vote for whom they thought was scum.

Vote Sammich

(In case you hadn't noticed, he has

scum

right under his avatar!

)

[neko2086]

Hm, well, the best way to be organized, I would think, is to have discussion long enough until someone does something really scummy, then discussion can be focused on that. With that in mind, unless I'm an idiot and cannot understand your reasoning, I'd say you've pretty much confirmed my argument that you're posting for the sake of posting. Not only are you posting nothing but filler, but you're also basing votes off of it now.

And uh, if using a vote as a catalyst shouldn't "be exercised so freely," then I would try assume you're voting sammich for a good reason, but apparently, you are not.

I'd be hesitant about voting for you, but nobody is, currently, so there's no danger yet. I think you've deserved a

vote:sikario

until you can convince me otherwise

[Sikario8]

Heeded and, to some extent, understood. I was hoping for someone other than yourself to comment; however, beggars can't be choosers. I still don't believe that we're going to get anywhere by you posting by yourself, so I'll keep my vote on sammich unless it becomes a problem, in which case I hope a discussion will be brewing.

RTB, MeMe, gorkat, soupfly, Wario, what do you think of my voting sammich?

Sammich, how upset are you that I voted you?

[gorckat]

Eh, I hoped we were past random crap. I'll look at the last couple pages and see what I think.

[SirWario]

.
RTB, MeMe, gorkat, soupfly, Wario, what do you think of my voting sammich?

If you gave some reasoning, then maybe I would take some time to think about it. In my opinion we're past the random voting and all votes placed should have at least some explanation.

FOS:Sikario

Give us something useful.

[Sammich]

Sammich, how upset are you that I voted you?

Crying a river and then drowning in it.

[MeMe]

Well, if you want to keep going in circles over here that's fine with me. Read my posts and explain to me why I deserve to be voted.

Do you really think I'm going in a circle? I believe

you're

being obtuse in your unwillingness to simply take a look at your posts and either say "oops -- yeah, I guess I

do

deserve a vote" or "nope -- and here's why."

I'll go ahead and show you (and everyone else who hasn't bothered to check you out).

When I voted you, your sole post was...

Confirm

I switched my vote to you because, unlike the other two non-posters at that point, there was

no

question of you receiving your role since you'd confirmed in the thread. The fact that you put this up just two posts after my vote switch...

MeMe and Gorckat, we meet again.

...pretty much confirmed your presence and non-excusability for your lack of help for the nearly 7 days the game had been declared open by the mod.

Your next post -- 5+ days after your last -- was...

Vote: MeMe

Good to see this is finally getting rolling.

Awesome. An OMGUS and a comment that's just plain weird -- seems like an "about time" sentiment, when you were a big part of the problem.

Then, you posted...

Neko, I'm voting for MeMe because she's voting for me. So MeMe, why did you vote for me?

...in which you explain your vote is OMGUS and act interested in my reasons for voting you more than 8 days prior.

Your three posts since that time have all been variations on "what did I do?" The fairly obvious answer to that query is "absolutely nothing."

So -- who thinks my vote is ill-placed?

[MeMe]

RTB, MeMe, gorkat, soupfly, Wario, what do you think of my voting sammich?

Nothing.

[RideTheBomb]

Yes MeMe, I do think you were going in circles with me. I had to ask "what did I do?" three times because you didn't give me a straight answer until now. That being said, I now understand your position.

Unvote: MeMe