Designer Mafia 2007 - Game Over, Final Scene Posted!

[stark]

Comrades, I apologize with the utmost deepfeltness.

I have been faced with massive full scale failure of everything in my life lol.

But I'm doing a complete thread re-read.

Bear with me comrades,

And thank you supermuch for your patience

[stark]

Alright comrades, this is my re-read from my last contentful post, which was on page 12 lol. Massive failure. In addition, I do terribly uninsightful re-reads, so forgive me for that, but I'll do my best.

So I'll be writing things down as I read them. So if the things I'll be talking about have been resolved, and are now obsolete, forgive me, as I'll correct that once I'm done reading.

Page 12

So here we are debating Thyroid. My position at this point in time was that I don't believe that Thyroid should be able to lead the town around with such minimal explanation of his role as he had. However, I reduced my intensity of going after Thyroid after a few of his concessions in regards to information. As I read along the thread, my opinion will probably change, so bear with me.

Page 13

Thyroid seems to have an amazing amount of well-founded accusations lol (Although I haven't done research as they say on the street, so it might be taken completely out of context). Good job

Defeating someone's position with inane netspeak is a bit childish. Bad.

He deconstructed scenarios proposing him as an anti-town role, he's built a nice little case on foolinc above, he's attacked stark - yes, he's been scumhunting and defending himself.

Why is attacking me scumhunting again?

Come to think about it, page thirteen as a whole was a bit childish. Don't do that comrades.

Page 14

Some actually relevant discussion lol. Massive skills.

CDK, I don't know why I have two votes on me. That's why I asked.

Hopping on Zoneace for backtracking isn't really fair, as he wasn't really backtracking, IMo. He essentially did the same thing as me. The majority of his questions were answered, so he moved on to a more productive position. Ain't so bad.

Page 15

Zoneace discussion, in which I hold the same opinion as above.

Page 16

Uninteresting really

Page 17

What's your thing with me, CKD?

Page 18

I'm not quite sure if I missed something. Does saying his name trigger the meeping?

Page 19

I see, it's the meeping. Got it.
Or is it? Maybe the mystery of the pr is too great for human kind.

Page 20

Once again, the pain of the pr

Page 21

Waterbuffalo song was so awesome..

Page 22

LOL! Just read JediKnight's post about Nocmen's prospective role. He who shall not be named has been changed so.

Page 23

And we're back!

In conclusion, comrades, on my scum list is still Thyroid, although he is at the most bottom, still because I don't like him leading the town about, and then Nocmen in regards to the information we've received

I would also like to see this 23 page day one come to an end some time would be kinda cool.

[Nocmen]

Damn, that's a lot of people saying my names. I stand by with who I still think was scum before.

[JDodge]

Damn, that's a lot of people saying my names. I stand by with who I still think was scum before.

NOCMEN NOCMEN NOCMEN

[Nocmen]

No need to say my name for a while, unless I really have to say something. stark's reread seemed to not really pique my interests (I bet i used that word wrong). That, or I'm being stubborn again.

[Sir Tornado]

Ah, completed reading the game.

Thyro, can you tell us how many tickets you have sold currently and who have bought those tickets?

By my count:
Mneme
SirT
FaerieLord
SSF
Shanba
BattleMage
Belgarion
The mod doesn't actually count them until night.

if you don’t get a majority, nothing happens, right?

something like that.

If you don’t get a majority today, but tomorrow, you do, does “it” still work?

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to answer that question, so I'll wait to do so.

Also, I have a question. Is the effect that is helpful to the town something that can be built to over time, or does it have to be acheived on one single day (can the tickets be purchased over time by different people to help the town or for the effect to be beneficial do a certain number of people have to buy them all the same day)

The goal is to use this ability tonight.

Why the mass of question marks?

This is odd... very odd. If your "goal" is to use the ability tonight, why did you agree to my proposal to confirm you tonight and then buy the tickets tomorrow?

What do you mean by "I am not allowed to answer the question"?

I am leaning more towards "you just having to convince the town to go the the fair and you win" theory.

The meeps are based on saying his name as has been figured out. Anyone that says his name can be targeted by him at night...either to be investigated or vigged. One per night...

...

Why do I get the feeling that you might have just outed the viging cop?

Definately not all of us should say it. We should vote for those who do. Or, we could just use it as an extra lynch.

Why not?

Nocmen

, why did you not "meep" before your last two posts?

unvote

[jediknight]

Sir Tornado: Yeah...i think i did as well...I'm an idiot...unless he ends up being scum.

vote:schismatized

He's the one that pushed me to reveal what I might know. The whole fool me once thing...if it happens again I'll vote myself!

[Nocmen]

Who said that my role hasn't changed somewhat?

[schismatized]

So you voted me for trying to figure out if you/nocmen are possibly scum?

noted.

[mneme]

unvote
vote: Schtismatized

It's called role fishing, schitz, as you well know.

[schismatized]

i wonder what it is about my name that makes it impossible to spell.

[Nocmen]

I have some questions for schis, but I don't have the time to ask tonight.

[JDodge]

Unvote, vote: Nocmen

Twomz can wait

[Nocmen]

And why exactly would you be voting for me, JDodge?

[Belgarion]

going to be gone for the rest of the week, for the holidays.

[Thyroidectomy]

Unvote, vote: Nocmen

Twomz can wait

That's a terrible vote.

[Nocmen]

meep meep meep.

[ZONEACE]

yes nocmen?

[Nocmen]

This isn't very unlike JDodge, so I really can't say we are getting some vibes off of it.

Also, questions for schis:

1. Why did you say this:

You know, thats the real townie thing to do.

Why?

Let me start by asking: do you believe it's always a townie thing to explain your votes? Do you believe scum are more likely to not explain their votes than townies are?

yes to both.

and then:

DIE SCUM

vote: jdodge

vote CKD

Hypocrit much?

2. Why is the meeping "annoying"?

3.

in light of new evidence do we kill shanny, zoneface, or roid?

unvote dodgy dave

how many is that on zone?

These just scream opportune scum to me. Any chances of changing my mind?
4.

The two highest players on my scumdar atm are Nocmen and Thyroid. I think their roles pose the biggest threat to the town.

I understand thyroid, but how am I a threat?

[curiouskarmadog]

Ok, getting my bird on. Will have light posts for the rest of the day, then I wont return until Monday...posting it all of my games

[somestrangeflea]

Nocmen!

So, 23 pages into the game and we:
1. Have deduced a method to remove a post restriction.
2. Are still arguing over whether or not the fair is a good idea.
3. Haven't really said anything else.

Wonderful...

...

Why do I get the feeling that you might have just outed the viging cop?

/agreed

There was also a night restriction related to his name being said. I don't want to say too much in case i'm saying too much! lol

So, you say that you don't want to tell us too much, before going all out and telling us everything. That's kinda broken, innit?

[Shanba]

Hey flea - way to ignore the whole bandwagons on Thyroid, foolinc and schismatised. Pretty sure they qualify as something else. Your criticism of everyone whilst saying absolutely nothing about who you believe is scum is noted too.

[jediknight]

That statement really had nothing to do with saying too much per ce. I didn't want to get ban hammered. I got clarification and I shared. thats all...

[somestrangeflea]

That statement really had nothing to do with saying too much per ce. I didn't want to get ban hammered. I got clarification and I shared. thats all...

Oh, you meant in terms of the rules of the game? That makes sense, I guess...

I figured you meant in terms of outing roles, etc... My mistake.

[schismatized]

This isn't very unlike JDodge, so I really can't say we are getting some vibes off of it.

Also, questions for schis:

1. Why did you say this:

You know, thats the real townie thing to do.

Why?

Let me start by asking: do you believe it's always a townie thing to explain your votes? Do you believe scum are more likely to not explain their votes than townies are?

yes to both.

and then:

DIE SCUM

vote: jdodge

vote CKD

Hypocrit much?

2. Why is the meeping "annoying"?

3.

in light of new evidence do we kill shanny, zoneface, or roid?

unvote dodgy dave

how many is that on zone?

These just scream opportune scum to me. Any chances of changing my mind?
4.

The two highest players on my scumdar atm are Nocmen and Thyroid. I think their roles pose the biggest threat to the town.

I understand thyroid, but how am I a threat?

1.

look what we have done. we let one person off the hook for voting with no given reason and then everyone thinks they can do it.

vote kaliedoscope

^^^This post was less than a half hour before the "die scum" one. I think its pretty self explanatory, but will explain: sarcasm. I made a this statement, and then jdodge followed up with a reasonless vote. And the CKD vote was because I had just made a fairly large post warning of the bad possibilities the tickets could have, and then he blatantly buys one with the "what the hell" attitude. So not really hypocritical, unless you don't read the context.


2. Because it bothers me.


3. Not really. To me, it seems like one of those, "who would say that if they were scum?" I was basically saying who the town was FOS'ing whether we should bandwagon them.

4. Simple, you could be scum buddies. You have came up with a creative role to protect yourself (PR) and jedi is using the "it was a protown role" thing to back himself.