Micro 643: Desperation Day (Game Over)

[BlackStar]

*you're

[callforjudgement]

Vote Count

Mas y Menos

(3): BTD6_maker, xyzzy, Comparing Realities

BlackStar

(1): Alchemist21

Gamma Emerald

(1): BlackStar

xyzzy

(1): Mas y Menos

Not voting

(1): Gamma Emerald

With 7 votes in play, 4 votes are required for a lynch.
Deadline is Sunday 2 October at 01:15 UTC (

automatic countdown: (expired on 2016-10-02 01:15:00)

)

[Gamma Emerald]

I would vote Mas, but since he's at L-1 I'll pursue a different lead.
VOTE: Alchemist
None of your posts really scream town or scum, but that's the problem: I don't think you've actually put any major ideas out.

[Alchemist21]

Then what have you been reading? I'm the one telling you why Black Star is scum and why you, CR, and Mas are all Town.

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay, but what I'm saying is you haven't really added much aside from that. Your posts seem mostly reactionary.

[Comparing Realities]

Are you rewording my posts?
I said BlackStar and Alchemist are my top 2 townreads.....

~Mas Y

Misread that, then. Apologies.

VOTE: Black Star

Gamma, you should vote Mas.

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay then.
VOTE: Mas y Menos

[BlackStar]

@conparing realities If you think that mas is scum, then why wouldn't you stay on the wagon and ask gamma to hammer? It doesn't make sense to jump off.

[BlackStar]

It's also weird that he's been at L-1 for ages now and nobody has asked him to claim to anything

[BlackStar]

*or anything

[Gamma Emerald]

Well claiming has no point because there are no PRs.

[BlackStar]

Well claiming has no point because there are no PRs.

Really?

[BlackStar]

Oh, you're right. I didn't look at the first post

[BlackStar]

If you hadn't said anything though, someone might've have slipped and fake claimed and then we'd know that they were scum

[Comparing Realities]

It's also weird that he's been at L-1 for ages now and nobody has asked him to claim to anything

Well claiming has no point because there are no PRs.

Really?

Oh, you're right. I didn't look at the first post

...This whole time, you've operated under the presumption there were at least one or two PRs?

[BlackStar]

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

[Comparing Realities]

More on this later.

[Gamma Emerald]

@Mas: If you think CR is town now, who do you scum read besides me and xyzzy?

[xyzzy]

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

this is a really bizarre thing to not notice, but it feels like a mistake that scum wouldn't make.

[BlackStar]

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

this is a really bizarre thing to not notice, but it feels like a mistake that scum wouldn't make.

The opening post of every game generally says pretty much the same thing, so I usually don't bother reading them

[Gamma Emerald]

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

this is a really bizarre thing to not notice, but it feels like a mistake that scum wouldn't make.

I don't quite agree here.

[Comparing Realities]

It's also weird that he's been at L-1 for ages now and nobody has asked him to claim to anything

Well claiming has no point because there are no PRs.

Well claiming has no point because there are no PRs.

Really?

Oh, you're right. I didn't look at the first post

If you hadn't said anything though, someone might've have slipped and fake claimed and then we'd know that they were scum

...This whole time, you've operated under the presumption there were at least one or two PRs?

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

I've never been in a game that didn't have one, so I just assumed that this one did too

this is a really bizarre thing to not notice, but it feels like a mistake that scum wouldn't make.

I don't quite agree here.

[Gamma Emerald]

Point being...?

[BlackStar]

I guess he just learned about multi-quoting

[Comparing Realities]

^ Posted too early on mistake, ignore.

Alright, there are three possibilities that just happened here, given the following constraints:

A) Black claims to have not known this was purely vanilla
B) Gamma was the one who responded to Black, giving Black's claims credit
C) Gamma does not believe that this is a thing that "scum would not do"

Which raises the following possibilities:

1) Black is scum who genuinely did not know this was purely vanilla. Unlikely; PRs would undoubtedly be a topic of conversation during the night. This would mean that both Black and his partner did not read the first post, which is terribly unlikely.

10%

2) Black is scum who knew this was purely vanilla, but fabricated this as a townslip. His partner would necessarily be Gamma, and they orchestrated this. (Partner doesn't have to be Gamma, but it's the most likely explanation. It feels awfully coordinated.) The initial interaction does feel a bit too peppy, almost cheeky; the same person who sarcastically posted a gif of a guy bleating "ANOTHER ONE" is also the guy now giving off an innocent air of "Hmm, Really? Didn't know that. Huh." But then Gamma tried to shoot down xyzzy's assertion that this was a townslip, and I also just remember that they hate eachother. So this is unliekly, also.
...Then again, today

is

the day for bussing, and neither are off-the-rails amped for the death of the other...

20%

3) Black is town who genuinely did not know this was purely vanilla.

70%