Mini 1830 - Game Over

[The_Jester]

@SquareWorld I'd like to see some reads from you.

[VictorDeAngelo]

OHHHHHHHH KAY
Did no one catch this post by CCC?

Newbie games have nine players, two of whom are Mafia. Here we have eleven players.

Three mafia sounds about right to me.

Why did NO ONE call him out for the reasons they called me out?

I don't get the angle here. Are you saying you find this post suspicious or what?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm saying I find it a little suspicious, BUT I find the people who called me out but not him MORE suspicious.

[Grendel]

I'm gonna try and contribute tonight, but if I can't then i can tomorrow.

Probably should've said something at the start of the game, but M/T/W/T's are super stressful, and busy for me. Fridays + Weekends are when I do better.

[Grendel]

Not sure what my feelings on CCC are.

I don't like how hard he is pushing self meta. He looks like lynch bait too though. :/

Not sure how far I'd get looking at CCC alone for that reason. I'll have to looks at his wagon later to see if it looks scum motivated I guess.

[gerryoat]

I'm gonna vote RhazhBash based on what I said earlier, waiting for him to say more anyway

VOTE: RhazhBash

[eagerSnake]

My vote on eagerSnake is now a serious vote.

This, however, can only be a few things:

A lazy town
A scum
A town with an ulterior motive

I reckon I could probably take a random post in this game, make the same statement and it would probably hold up.

So you admit to be one of the 3 things I mentioned. Which one are you?

[Eggman]

Vote Count 1.03

Manuel87

: RhazhBash, Square World

CCC

: Square World

RhazhBash

: VictorDeAngelo, gerryoat

VictorDeAngelo

: eagerSnake

Gamma Emerald

: Grendel

Square World

: CCC

With 11 players alive, it takes

6

for a lynch.
The deadline for this day is (expired on 2016-09-26 18:00:00).

GreenNope has been prodded again. As they have been inactive for the entire week, I am looking for a replacement for their slot.

[RhazhBash]

Snake I need to ask. What experience with Mafia do you have aside from EM?

[eagerSnake]

I also played about 1000 games of IRC mafia about a decade ago.

[RhazhBash]

My vote on eagerSnake is now a serious vote.

This, however, can only be a few things:

A lazy town
A scum
A town with an ulterior motive

I reckon I could probably take a random post in this game, make the same statement and it would probably hold up.

So you admit to be one of the 3 things I mentioned. Which one are you?

Posts like these make me Townread you. Your lack of experience with prolonged games of Mafia like this shows in posts like this. Usually if I read someone as inexperienced and then see them with a tryhard attitude it's a huge Towntell for me.

[CCC]

@SquareWorld I'd like to see some reads from you.

SquareWorld: So would I.

[VictorDeAngelo]

I'm assuming 131 isn't serious, right?

[eagerSnake]

Why would you assume it isn't serious?

By saying that you "could take a random post and it would hold up" insinuates that you feel it holds up in my post. So I ask which one is it?

[RhazhBash]

Snake stop posting.

[CCC]

Snake stop posting.

Why? He's got a good point. The insinuation is there, and asking for more clarification on that point is perfectly reasonable. (I'd rather like to see the answer to Snake's question myself).

[Gamma Emerald]

I really don't understand that bit about the random post holding up. Could you explain a little more, Eager?

[VictorDeAngelo]

Why would you assume it isn't serious?

I assumes it's wasn't serious because it's not a very probing question. You basically asked me if I was town or scum.

Unsurprisingly my answer is I'm town. If I have an ulterior motive I'm not going to admit to it. If I'm lazy I'm not going to admit that either.

When you asked the question, did you think it would help catch scum, and if yes, how?

By saying that you "could take a random post and it would hold up" insinuates that you feel it holds up in my post. So I ask which one is it?

Not sure what your getting at here at all. When I said you "could take a random post and it would hold up" I was saying that the question could applied to any post and make sense. The intention was to point out the lack of analysis behind the post. My initial instinct was you were trying to deflect away from the vote itself. At this point, I'll admit I'm somewhat unsure what you were trying to do.

[Grendel]

Also, about my lower activity: I am currently in 4 games. Not as much time to spend here. I even said in the postgame I would be able to be super active in one game anymore. I don't particularly like the look of your most recent posts either. What were you going to do when you got caught up in our previous game? Because there you never did anything unique.
About being cop: I wanted to confuse the Mafia about me. It sure worked, you NEVER considered me as a PR.

Being in so many games explains your low activity here, but why does it affect the lack of stances?

So what didn’t you particularly like? Saying you don’t like something is nice and all, but not explaining why doesn’t help you.

Yeah, you did some good wifom in that game.

Grendel, I'll say it again, i don't see how you get all those reads in 3 pages of pretty much nullness.

If I got reads from nothing but "nullness" then that should be a reason to suspect me right?

If it is for you then push me. This game needs more clashing.

My experience so far suggests that the entirety of day one is going to be pretty much nullness. I've never been on a game on this site where a Mafia player was lynched on the first day, so I'd be surprised if anyone has anything even approaching a decent read on the first day.

Do you ever read other games? There are garnteed to be games were scum was hung D1 for legitimate reasons. Don't be a downer, its not good for town morale.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm saying that you didn't do a special thing like you tried to do in this game. I understand I beat you to RQS, but STILL.

[Grendel]

In my previous post, I suggested that VictorDeAngelo and Gamma Emerald were pinging as very slightly scum. To that list I will now add GreenNope and Square World; the first for being completely absent, and the second for providing extremely short posts with no reasons for his votes. From these four, I will elect to park my vote (for the moment) on:

VOTE: Square World

How much scummier is Box World compared to Pokémon Remake Emerald, and Old Man Victor?

Also, stop self-metaing at the drop of a hat.

[Grendel]

I'm saying that you didn't do a special thing like you tried to do in this game. I understand I beat you to RQS, but STILL.

Uhh... wouldn't that be reason to town read me???

Your response to my analysis sounded like you were pinged.

Can you throw me a reads list?

[Gamma Emerald]

I was not pinged, I was defending myself. I do townread you for it. I may throw together a reads list sometime today.

[Grendel]

VOTE: Manuel87

try to guess why

You have not posted enough of your thought processes to expect other people to see where you are going with this vote.

So enlighten us

I was not pinged, I was defending myself. I do townread you for it. I may throw together a reads list sometime today.

Okay. You still look like scum to me though friend.

Today would be great.

[Grendel]

@Snakebuddy, Do you still think Gamma is town?

Also ask me stuff from time to time, keep the pathway of communication open. I’m going to assume that everything you are going to post is coming from town’s PoV. There really is no reason not to collab with me.

(Wow, that came off as egotistical)