In post 171, Alchemist21 wrote:I don't think scum, unless very experienced and already known for disliking large posts, would get as confrontational about a single wall-post as rb has. I think scum would be more inclined to say "Fine, I'll look back over it," and not call this much attention to themselves.
VOTE: BTD6_maker
BTD strikes me as the flying under the radar type. I'd like to see more thoughts from him, especially harder stances than "This is mostly NAI."
I was referring to one action. My reads are developing and are still weak in early Day 1. Voting because you think I am scum is good. Voting because you want me to give more reads is not.
"one of these days i'll read you correctly" - Transcend, Micro 714
I think I can confidently say Mas y menos is Town now.
I was leaning that way after 121 because I don't think Firebringer is the type of person to use our history of sharing an alignment to his advantage, at least not with the same friendly attitude he had. Questioning me on my BTD read just now makes me confident that Fire is Town who cares about this game.
P-edit: Well it's not really about whether they could or couldn't fly under the radar, I just think the attempt to do it is there, and that's what's scummy.
In post 171, Alchemist21 wrote:I don't think scum, unless very experienced and already known for disliking large posts, would get as confrontational about a single wall-post as rb has. I think scum would be more inclined to say "Fine, I'll look back over it," and not call this much attention to themselves.
VOTE: BTD6_maker
BTD strikes me as the flying under the radar type. I'd like to see more thoughts from him, especially harder stances than "This is mostly NAI."
I was referring to one action. My reads are developing and are still weak in early Day 1. Voting because you think I am scum is good. Voting because you want me to give more reads is not.
And supposing my vote is for both reasons, what do you make of that?
In post 121, Mas y Menos wrote:Comparing Realities is the only one pinging me right now:
VOTE: Comparing Realities
I have town on Alchemist, Rb, XYZ.
Rest Null.
Also Alchemist, I think this continues the trend of us being same alignment
~Mas Y
Can you please try to give some reasons for this vote? At the moment you haven't mentioned a single other thing about CR outside of RVS. If no one gives reasons then no one will be able to see what pinged you, or even if there was a reason other than "I want CR mislynched today so that a scum is not lynched". This post is mildly scummy to me.
"one of these days i'll read you correctly" - Transcend, Micro 714
In post 171, Alchemist21 wrote:I don't think scum, unless very experienced and already known for disliking large posts, would get as confrontational about a single wall-post as rb has. I think scum would be more inclined to say "Fine, I'll look back over it," and not call this much attention to themselves.
VOTE: BTD6_maker
BTD strikes me as the flying under the radar type. I'd like to see more thoughts from him, especially harder stances than "This is mostly NAI."
I was referring to one action. My reads are developing and are still weak in early Day 1. Voting because you think I am scum is good. Voting because you want me to give more reads is not.
And supposing my vote is for both reasons, what do you make of that?
Please give the full reasons for your scumread. Are you scumreading me just because I am not posting as much, or is there more?
"one of these days i'll read you correctly" - Transcend, Micro 714
I'm scumreading you because I think that you are trying to post while giving as little valuable content as possible. Nothing you've said is really useful, and I think you just don't want to form hard opinions because you don't want to come under scrutiny for them. I couldn't even tell if what you said about xyzzy was a scumread or just a dislike of the vote.
I like this better than Mas. Xyzzy doesn't do much other than throw shade and despite thinking I'm a strong lynch candidate, keeps their vote aligned with mine. Key, Alchemist: thoughts?
Of course, Xyzzy thought that you and Mas are both viable lynches. I don't see how picking one of them (the one you happened to be voting) is scummy.
However, overall this is one of the better non-RVS votes in this game. Nulltown read.
UNVOTE: RB
"one of these days i'll read you correctly" - Transcend, Micro 714
In post 181, Alchemist21 wrote:I'm scumreading you because I think that you are trying to post while giving as little valuable content as possible. Nothing you've said is really useful, and I think you just don't want to form hard opinions because you don't want to come under scrutiny for them. I couldn't even tell if what you said about xyzzy was a scumread or just a dislike of the vote.
I don't want to form hard opinions because I don't have very strong opinions in early Day 1. As the game progresses opinions naturally get stronger. Also, explain why my analysing of votes is not valuable.
"one of these days i'll read you correctly" - Transcend, Micro 714
In post 181, Alchemist21 wrote:I'm scumreading you because I think that you are trying to post while giving as little valuable content as possible. Nothing you've said is really useful, and I think you just don't want to form hard opinions because you don't want to come under scrutiny for them. I couldn't even tell if what you said about xyzzy was a scumread or just a dislike of the vote.
I don't want to form hard opinions because I don't have very strong opinions in early Day 1. As the game progresses opinions naturally get stronger. Also, explain why my analysing of votes is not valuable.
Opinions are still opinions, and they have info the Town can work with. Everyone's opinions are going to be weaker D1, but there should be some you can state outright. VCA can be valuable in the later stages of the game, but D1 it's not useful, and if you're not generating D1 content because you're doing something like that, then even if the claim is true then you may as well be doing nothing.
In post 184, BTD6_maker wrote:Null-weak Town: RB, Comparing Realities
Null: Blackstar, Gamma Emerald
Nullscum: Keyenpeydee, Xyzzy
Weak scum: Mas y Menos,Alchemist21
Does this help?
This is the most useful post you've made. At least now I have an idea of your reads and can probably see where you're coming from on some of them.
|| Mini Normal 1848 || The Hogwarts Mafia || Valentine's Day || The Divergent Series || Another Mafia || Cities & Beaches || Moonlight || 13 Reasons Why ||
I like this better than Mas. Xyzzy doesn't do much other than throw shade and despite thinking I'm a strong lynch candidate, keeps their vote aligned with mine. Key, Alchemist: thoughts?
|| Mini Normal 1848 || The Hogwarts Mafia || Valentine's Day || The Divergent Series || Another Mafia || Cities & Beaches || Moonlight || 13 Reasons Why ||
rb, well i did an iso read and gotta say I'm actually surprised that her vote still stays on mas y menos despite saying you're a strong lynch candidate which is kinda alarming for me.
VOTE: xyzzy
Care to explain why rb is a strong lynch candidate? Make it detailed.
And I'm sorry for voting you, rb because I just don't like what you're doing rn. Explain it would get me replaced but Imma trust you now. And also, I did a xyzzy iso so I don't quite sheep you.
|| Mini Normal 1848 || The Hogwarts Mafia || Valentine's Day || The Divergent Series || Another Mafia || Cities & Beaches || Moonlight || 13 Reasons Why ||
I like this better than Mas. Xyzzy doesn't do much other than throw shade and despite thinking I'm a strong lynch candidate, keeps their vote aligned with mine. Key, Alchemist: thoughts?
Sorry I forgot to respond to this earlier. I think at this point of the game Town xyzzy is more concerned with applying pressure and getting info to work with rather than getting the lynch through ASAP, and stating you're a strong lynch candidate is saying that they find your play scummy, so I don't think it's that unusual that they kept their vote where it is.
That said, Xyzzy is still null to me because I don't think they've done anything that's unfakeable as scum, but they're posting in a way that I think will make their intentions clear by the end of the Day, so I'm content to let them continue as they are for now.
|| Mini Normal 1848 || The Hogwarts Mafia || Valentine's Day || The Divergent Series || Another Mafia || Cities & Beaches || Moonlight || 13 Reasons Why ||
|| Mini Normal 1848 || The Hogwarts Mafia || Valentine's Day || The Divergent Series || Another Mafia || Cities & Beaches || Moonlight || 13 Reasons Why ||
I like this better than Mas. Xyzzy doesn't do much other than throw shade and despite thinking I'm a strong lynch candidate, keeps their vote aligned with mine. Key, Alchemist: thoughts?
Of course, Xyzzy thought that you and Mas are both viable lynches. I don't see how picking one of them (the one you happened to be voting) is scummy.
However, overall this is one of the better non-RVS votes in this game. Nulltown read.
UNVOTE: RB
Based on the way this game has gone, having a lynch pool of Mas and myself makes zero sense unless someone thinks I'm bussing him.
In post 196, rb wrote:Why is being wagon-happy in the early game scummy though? I don't agree with that.
He votes someone, doesn't really apply any pressure and then moves onto the next person as soon as suspicious on comes their way. I don't like the tone of his posts because they feel forced to me.
