Mafia 70: Traditional - Game over!

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Vote: Bookitty

[Erg0]

Just for once, I think I actually know why you did that.

I'm probably wrong, though.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Waste words on the subject...

[Simenon]

pretty sure flare is an alt of IH.

Semi-limited access until friday. I'll land a vote then.

[The Fonz]

Bah, go town.

[Setael]

Mmmm... vanilla ice cream. Go town!

[Ether]

Due to threats on my life if I don't comply, I'm changing Toaster Strudel's role name to "Mafia Godmother" for political correctness.

*notthreatening*

Not thrilled with Flare or Scøpe, but let's go with a

vote: Sir Tornado

for his 1206.

I forgot to ask this yesterday: was I missing something between JDodge and White?

I'm on limited access as well--until Sunday.

[Lemming1607]

I believe I was roleblocked. My flavor was basically "investigation failed" and no other flavor.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Due to threats on my life if I don't comply, I'm changing Toaster Strudel's role name to "Mafia Godmother" for political correctness.

*notthreatening*

Not thrilled with Flare or Scøpe, but let's go with a

vote: Sir Tornado

for his 1206.

I forgot to ask this yesterday: was I missing something between JDodge and White?

I'm on limited access as well--until Sunday.

That's pretty scummy, but what happened to being suspicious of Zorg/BM? I'm pretty sure there is a much better case for them to be scum atm.

Vote: Battle Mage

I believe I was roleblocked. My flavor was basically "investigation failed" and no other flavor.

So the mafia had a godfather and a roleblocker (I highly doubt a protown roleblocker would be stupid enough to block you). The solution to this is simple. If we have a watcher (we have a tracker and a cop, why not a watcher? It balances out the scum power roles, at least), they should watch lemming tonight. This way the scum have to give up their roleblocker to the watcher or let lemming investigate someone. Either way, we get another scum out of the deal, and lemming can start investigating again.

[Battle Mage]

Ok folks, i'm here. I'm not quite sure what happened yesterday- i still havent reread (i'm not going to read an entire game and then find out that i was NKed and unable to post anything. lol)

I don't like MoS's rolefishing on this page, or directing power roles. I think he is stating the obvious, and it's hard to see what his comments hope to achieve.

Will reread and make some analysis soon.

BM

[Ether]

I don't even remember much of the case on Zorg. I remember that there was a point at which you had this fabulously scummy wagon TS started. It had like {TS, Zorg, Flare, Yamahako} at its apex. Just doesn't feel like four scumbags would hop onto you in a row, and I feel worse about both Flare and Yamahako. (Yeah...wow. I just looked through Yamahako's posts and they really, really suck.)

That said, I very much approve of your watcher suggestion and think BM is horribly, horribly wrong about painting it as a scumtell.

[Ether]

In fact, looking back at the old Yamawogon and knowing White and Zeppo to have been town, it doesn't seem quite so sinister anymore.

unvote; vote: Yamahako

[Setael]

Editted by the mod.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Uhh, Setael, you died...

[Erg0]

Alt check?

[Sir Tornado]

Setael... You are dead.

BM. Did you miss ZONEACE directing the Doc last night? Didn't hear anything on that from you... What MoS said was much less directive than ZONEACE. K-scope tried to direct the vig at the end of day 1 too. No comment on that from you either. And, remind me why directing power roles is bad too.

Ether, what exactly do you find scummy in my post?

[Patrick]

Votecount

Bookitty (1) -- KaleiÐoscøpe
Battle Mage (1) -- Mastermind of Sin
Yamahako (1) -- Ether

Not voting: Aimee, Simenon, JDodge, Sir Tornado, Yamahako, Lemming1607, ZONEACE, Battle Mage, Flare, Beastly, Niv, Erg0, Bookitty
16 alive, 9 to lynch.

[Erg0]

TS coming up scum lends weight to one of my earlier theories about Zorg - specifically that he FoSed TS early then followed her onto the MoS wagon with weak reasoning.

Vote: Battle Mage

[Battle Mage]

Setael... You are dead.

BM. Did you miss ZONEACE directing the Doc last night? Didn't hear anything on that from you... What MoS said was much less directive than ZONEACE. K-scope tried to direct the vig at the end of day 1 too. No comment on that from you either. And, remind me why directing power roles is bad too.

Ether, what exactly do you find scummy in my post?

I havent read that stuff yet. lol
I only commented on MoS's post because i saw a glaring scumtell. Directing power roles is scummy in this context, because it was pretty obvious who the Watcher would target. There was no reason for that comment, other than to fish for a power role.

Hence, scummy.

BM

[JDodge]

Setael... You are dead.

BM. Did you miss ZONEACE directing the Doc

last night

? Didn't hear anything on that from you... What MoS said was much less directive than ZONEACE. K-scope tried to direct the vig at the end of day 1 too. No comment on that from you either. And, remind me why directing power roles is bad too.

Ether, what exactly do you find scummy in my post?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Setael... You are dead.

BM. Did you miss ZONEACE directing the Doc last night? Didn't hear anything on that from you... What MoS said was much less directive than ZONEACE. K-scope tried to direct the vig at the end of day 1 too. No comment on that from you either. And, remind me why directing power roles is bad too.

Ether, what exactly do you find scummy in my post?

I havent read that stuff yet. lol
I only commented on MoS's post because i saw a glaring scumtell. Directing power roles is scummy in this context, because it was pretty obvious who the Watcher would target. There was no reason for that comment, other than to fish for a power role.

Hence, scummy.

BM

I don't see how it was obvious for that to be the plan. I really don't. Sure, it seems like common sense now that I've said it, but I really doubt everyone would have thought of that plan.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Also, if it was obvious that the Watcher would do it, then there's nothing scummy about me suggesting it. Directing power roles is only scummy if the direction is towards suboptimal play. I suggested the optimal plan for the watcher, so you'll have a hard time painting it as a "glaring scumtell".

[Sir Tornado]

Setael... You are dead.

BM. Did you miss ZONEACE directing the Doc

last night

? Didn't hear anything on that from you... What MoS said was much less directive than ZONEACE. K-scope tried to direct the vig at the end of day 1 too. No comment on that from you either. And, remind me why directing power roles is bad too.

Ether, what exactly do you find scummy in my post?

Docs perform their protections at night, you know...

[Sir Tornado]

EBWOP, I suppose I should have said "for" last night there...

[Bookitty]

Okay, based on a variety of things, most notably his insistence on directing the play of those with night actions, I'm going to

vote ZONEACE

I realise that this will be greeted with a chorus of people saying that he always plays like this and it's not at all scummy, but I find it scummy, and if he always plays like that, then he should learn how not to play so scummy as town.