Mafia 72: Peril in Panama - Game over!

[Mastermind of Sin]

In my mind these people are dodgy:
Battle Mage
Unright
Mastermind of Sin

Please explain why.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Also, V/LA for a week.

[Gage]

Ehh... There's more to analysing text than that. How about the flavor of certain people's posts. How about buddying up or neglecting completely with some people.

Honestly, I'm just not too good at picking up on flavor of posts and such if I haven't played with a person before. I have to learn their post style before I can tell if they're deviating from it.

I'll finish the roleclaim if you guys still see fit to lynch me, I guess.

[Gage]

In my mind these people are dodgy:
Battle Mage
Unright
Mastermind of Sin

Please explain why.

Well...

Battle Mage seems to be throwing around the insults and the votes pretty liberally. Says Unright is blantant scum (post 70), which, to be fair, is not in

total

contrast to my own opinion, but it isn't like he's a cop and has investigated him yet - after all, there was no night 0, right?

For you?

Jordan is stretching like a motherfucker. It is *NEVER* too early to be serious about lynching.

Post 58. I beg to differ, and so would any other smart townie.

Unright is just a feeling. I was picking up blue/green from him earlier, but now it has swung a bit if the opposite direction.

I don't mind being lynched. It is better than lynching a vanilla townie because it creates a confirmed green in my partner who I will give you before you lynch me, should you not hammer me overnight. I know that a green/blue lynch should statistically almost be expected (but never hoped for) day 1, so there are definitely worse things that can happen. If we have to lynch someone, better the Mason (Yes, I'm claiming) than the doctor or cop, right? Plus, if the town wins I still win even if I'm dead.

[Porochaz]

You roleclaim on what I count as 2 votes? That seems a bit panicky... I also agree with MoS its never to early to get serious, that doesnt mean LYNCH, LYNCH LYNCH!!!! It just means if theres someone who has such a bad case against them its not worth 10 pages of umming and ahing to do anything about it.

[Albert B. Rampage]

I don't believe the claim. Straight up. What kind of mason would claim at -5 ? Lol.

This has to be a scum gambit, imo.

[Unright]

Battle Mage seems to be throwing around the insults and the votes pretty liberally.

Insults don't mean much. Vote-hoping could potentially be a tell... But why is BM on your list (4 votes) and Albert B. Rampage (4 votes) isn't?

Unright is just a feeling. I was picking up blue/green from him earlier, but now it has swung a bit if the opposite direction.

I asked you earlier what the blue/green desgination meant. You never answered, so I'm left to assume that you aren't reading the game too carefully. Your "summary" also left a lot to be desired, but I'm wondering how much of that is because this is a different format of Mafia for you...

I don't mind being lynched. It is better than lynching a vanilla townie because it creates a confirmed green in my partner who I will give you before you lynch me, should you not hammer me overnight. I know that a green/blue lynch should statistically almost be expected (but never hoped for) day 1, so there are definitely worse things that can happen. If we have to lynch someone, better the Mason (Yes, I'm claiming) than the doctor or cop, right? Plus, if the town wins I still win even if I'm dead.

That's still pretty damn fatalist for someone with only 2 votes on them (one of which I think was random). I'm leaving my vote on you until your partner clears you or someone else somehow manages to act more scummy.

[Albert B. Rampage]

So you agree with me that he's scum ? Who else would be ready to lynch him ?

[Unright]

I agree that he is scu

my

. Only the mod knows for sure.

But from my persepective, there is an 85% chance that he's scum.

[Unright]

Hey Patrick (or Aimee if she's back)

: Could you prod the following players:

mandalorian (last post 10/29)
Kakeng (last post 11/1)
richman99 (last post 11/3)
Sir Tornado (last post 10/29)

Thanks!

[curiouskarmadog]

before we get all lynch crazy, is there a way we might be able to confirm him or his partner without a lynch? I have been in a game where I had to claim Mason (earlier than I wanted to) because my Mason buddy was acting super scummy and I had to stop his lynch, so I understand pressure. I, however, dont get this early claim, there was hardly any pressure him. On the other side of the coin, would you have believed the claim any more if he had done it at -1?

Gage why did you claim so early?

ABR, how could this be a scum gambit? Seems like a poor gambit if it is one.

Either way I think it was a newbie mistake. Whether is it is scum or town, remains to be seen.

[JordanA24]

Either way I think it was a newbie mistake. Whether is it is scum or town, remains to be seen.

But Gage is not a newbie is he. He's very experienced on another site he claims.

The claim, I suppose I believe it for now, but I'm very wary of him, masons can be very believable if they aren't lynched, and some of his posts were really scummy, the drawn out threats to claim particularly. The only problem I can see with scum fakeclaiming mason is that if one dies, they both go. So, I'm not sure.

FOS: Gage

[Nekka-Lucifer]

...blue/green... ...green... ...green/blue...

Ehh? What's this green blue alignment thing you are talking about?

[Dragon Phoenix]

I have a hard time believing that he's a real mason claiming with hardly any pressure.

I have a hard time believing that he's scum claming with hardly any pressure (although 2 player mason group is one of the safest claim for scum in a game this size).

I have a hard time trying to understand what all this blue and green gobbledigok is about.

In sum, Cage gives me a headache.

[Porochaz]

Are you from something awful Gage, I was playing a game here where they used Green and Blue fonts to show what "team" they were on... but as far as I could tell that was a joke...

[curiouskarmadog]

A bunch of SA kids came over a couple of weeks ago, but most have departed..could be left over from that.

[JordanA24]

A bunch of SA kids came over a couple of weeks ago, but most have departed..could be left over from that.

Yep, thank God, they sure lived up to their name.

[curiouskarmadog]

A bunch of SA kids came over a couple of weeks ago, but most have departed..could be left over from that.

Yep, thank God, they sure lived up to their name.

agreed

[Porochaz]

agreed as well

[mandalorian]

Of course, I suspect I'm now the favorite to lynch. If need be, I can roleclaim, because it isn't like I'm terribly important. There is also one person who can back me up, but I certainly am not going to roleclaim for them. If and when I roleclaim, they can back me up if they see fit.

Hang on. Did you just claim Mason or did you just say that you could be proven by the cop?

That "1 person who might not back me up" stuff sounds like he's Mason, but his Mason partner (he specified that there is only one) won't confirm his claim, although that is the only "power" that two Masons have.

Actualy, it was my intent to start by apologizing for submarrining. But, since my only post inluded a vote on Gage, more power to for cuting down on spam.

[curiouskarmadog]

Of course, I suspect I'm now the favorite to lynch. If need be, I can roleclaim, because it isn't like I'm terribly important. There is also one person who can back me up, but I certainly am not going to roleclaim for them. If and when I roleclaim, they can back me up if they see fit.

Hang on. Did you just claim Mason or did you just say that you could be proven by the cop?

That "1 person who might not back me up" stuff sounds like he's Mason, but his Mason partner (he specified that there is only one) won't confirm his claim, although that is the only "power" that two Masons have.

Actualy, it was my intent to start by apologizing for submarrining. But, since my only post inluded a vote on Gage, more power to for cuting down on spam.

does this mean you believe the claim or not?

[Albert B. Rampage]

A bunch of SA kids came over a couple of weeks ago, but most have departed..could be left over from that.

Yep, thank God, they sure lived up to their name.

agreed

Hey, I led that charge.

[Battle Mage]

before we get all lynch crazy, is there a way we might be able to confirm him or his partner without a lynch? I have been in a game where I had to claim Mason (earlier than I wanted to) because my Mason buddy was acting super scummy and I had to stop his lynch, so I understand pressure. I, however, dont get this early claim, there was hardly any pressure him. On the other side of the coin, would you have believed the claim any more if he had done it at -1?

Gage why did you claim so early?

ABR, how could this be a scum gambit? Seems like a poor gambit if it is one.

Either way I think it was a newbie mistake. Whether is it is scum or town, remains to be seen.

I should note that your claim in that game didn't really help alot. In the end, it resulted in much the same way as you not claiming for him, except that it would have been you left alive, rather than D3sisted.

@ABR-ah, but did you get to modkill one of them?

[Albert B. Rampage]

@ABR-ah, but did you get to modkill one of them?

Even better. My strategy is usually to make them THINK they are going to get modkilled. Then they overreact, do the whole "you can't fire me, I quit!" thing, and ask for a replacement

[Battle Mage]

@ABR-ah, but did you get to modkill one of them?

Even better. My strategy is usually to make them THINK they are going to get modkilled. Then they overreact, do the whole "you can't fire me, I quit!" thing, and ask for a replacement

nah, that makes them think they are getting their own way. Its like them committing suicide, rather than you getting the pleasure of doing them in yourself.

BM