Open 54 - Basic 12 Player (over) before 529

[JDodge]

Vote: IH

always scum

[JDodge]

Random

vote

:

appleof88

.

Also, Patrick is never scum, so FoS: Glork for voting for a confirmed townie.

Counterproductive.

Vote: IH

always scum

Counterproductive.

Counterproductive.

[JDodge]

random

vote:JDodge

Hi Everyone

So Glork who are we lynching?

don't lynch the guy who snuck the money in

[JDodge]

Oh? You know this for a fact?

Unvote, Vote: IH
Major FoS/IGMEOY: Patrick

FIGMEoSOY?

Wait i just realized that means "Finger I got my eye of suspicion on you"

[JDodge]

not so much that they wouldn't listen to me as much as it was my establishing that i was, in no way, form, or fashion, a Battle Mage or mneme or any other experienced player.

Have things truly come to this? That the premier example of an experienced Mafia elder that occurs to a new player is -

Battle Mage

?

If it's worth anything, it worries me too

[JDodge]

I want each person on Andy to give me exactly three sentences (between 15 and 45 words) on why they are voting for Andy.



gogogo

i'm not voting andy, but can i do this anyways

[JDodge]

I'll look through again later and tell you who the scum are

[JDodge]

Unexpectedly busy = not fun

[JDodge]

I'd say that the better lynch at the moment is andy, based on that last post

Vote: Andycycya

clearly he is trying to save his own skin

[JDodge]

I'd do that, too. What'd you of JDodge lynch, Glork? 295 =

amazingly

scummy.

I find it odd the way Elmo's obsessing over this, but not actually acting on it. Does anyone else agree?

[JDodge]

Eh. I'm somewhat apathetic about a JDodge lynch. I'm not a huge fan of the post, but I know that JD's posts so far have been consistent with his general posting style. Naturally, I'd like him to elaborate on why he thinks Andy is scum (including why "save his own skin" -- if true -- is indicative of being a scumbag) and I'd like to hear his thoughts on everyone else.

Meh, it was more "I don't like a Patrick lynch, and something seems off about Andy's vote" thing

[JDodge]

I find it odd the way Elmo's obsessing over this, but not actually acting on it. Does anyone else agree?

Two posts is hardly obsessing. Regardless, I find it scummy, is it bad to 'obsess' over possible scumtells, JD?

I said I was still thinking.

Yes. It is. Because obsessing over one thing means that you're trying to mount a charge on someone with reasoning that you

acknowledge

is weak, but try to reinforce by repeating ad nauseam.

[JDodge]

Unvote

:

wank

;

vote

:

JDodge

.

Why am I not surprised?

Furthermore, has anyone else noticed that Elmo has been on the largest bandwagon ever since the deadline was put into effect?

[JDodge]

EBWOP:

Unvote, vote: Elmo

[JDodge]

^ failure

Nice rebuttal.

[JDodge]

Unvote

:

wank

;

vote

:

JDodge

.

Why am I not surprised?

Furthermore, has anyone else noticed that Elmo has been on the largest bandwagon ever since the deadline was put into effect?

No, but I'm still pretty okay with his play.

I'd like you to address the inconsistency pointed out in Elmo's post. Why exactly are you voting Andy and why did you say two entirely different things in different posts?

Why can't the two reasons co-exist? I will admit that I withheld my main reason at first; but nothing more.

[JDodge]

I smell blood.

no you're just eager to get your NK in

[JDodge]

Unvote

:

wank

;

vote

:

JDodge

.

Why am I not surprised?

Furthermore, has anyone else noticed that Elmo has been on the largest bandwagon ever since the deadline was put into effect?

No, but I'm still pretty okay with his play.

I'd like you to address the inconsistency pointed out in Elmo's post. Why exactly are you voting Andy and why did you say two entirely different things in different posts?

Why can't the two reasons co-exist? I will admit that I withheld my main reason at first; but nothing more.

Why on earth would you withhold your main reason?

When do I ever give all my reasons?

[JDodge]

Under deadline, one would think that you'd at least give your primary reason rather than some secondary reason. In spite of your tendency not to volunteer your thoughts, I find it odd that you'd say you're voting him "based on that post" rather than because of his vote if indeed you primarily suspect him for the latter.

Actually, if the post is what prompted you to move, I'd expect you to just state "based on his earlier vote and his most recent post" which you didn't do either. And unless I missed something in the past page, you still haven't indicated why his post is A) self-preservation; or B) why that, if true, would make him more likely to be scum.

I just tried to remember why his post felt self-preservative and managed to successfully defeat my own logic.

weeeeeeee

But are you saying that it's not more beneficial for scum to be self-preservative than for town?

[JDodge]

But are you saying that it's not more beneficial for scum to be self-preservative than for town?

In this case, not really. Do you think that defending oneself is more beneficial for scum than for town?

I think that staying alive matters less to town than to others, yes.

[JDodge]

Supposing Andy is one of our power roles, do you still think it'd be more beneficial to try his hardest not to survive?

Possibly; I would still argue that it is even

more

beneficial as scum.

But since I've established that my reasoning for thinking Andy was self-preservative is crap, why are we even discussing this?

[JDodge]

I misread. At first, it appeared as if you implied that the JDodge wagon was wrong or negative, but I think i get it now. You aren't fond of reasonless bandwagoning. I agree, reasonless bandwagoning is wrong.

@Jdodge: Don't you think reasonless bandwagoning is wrong?

If you think the bandwagon is reasonless, a bandwagon that you

know

could possibly lead to a lynch, why are you just letting it go and riding it?

[JDodge]

I misread. At first, it appeared as if you implied that the JDodge wagon was wrong or negative, but I think i get it now. You aren't fond of reasonless bandwagoning. I agree, reasonless bandwagoning is wrong.

@Jdodge: Don't you think reasonless bandwagoning is wrong?

If you think the bandwagon is reasonless, a bandwagon that you

know

could possibly lead to a lynch, why are you just letting it go and riding it?

I had no idea you'd actually say anything about it. You don't mind, do you? I mean, it's practically harmless and, if it does come up to something, I can easily withdraw my vote. I just...want to appear...well...

active

.

Code: Select all

Squad 8 Of Solam

What the hell? You want to deadline lynch me to appear

active

?

I

still

can't see how no one else sees Elmo's extreme focus on getting me lynched.

[JDodge]

EBWOP

I misread. At first, it appeared as if you implied that the JDodge wagon was wrong or negative, but I think i get it now. You aren't fond of reasonless bandwagoning. I agree, reasonless bandwagoning is wrong.

@Jdodge: Don't you think reasonless bandwagoning is wrong?

If you think the bandwagon is reasonless, a bandwagon that you

know

could possibly lead to a lynch, why are you just letting it go and riding it?

I had no idea you'd actually say anything about it. You don't mind, do you? I mean, it's practically harmless and, if it does come up to something, I can easily withdraw my vote. I just...want to appear...well...

active

.

Code: Select all

Squad 8 Of Solam

What the hell? You want to deadline lynch me to appear

active

?

I

still

can't see how no one else sees Elmo's extreme focus on getting me lynched.

Are you

honestly

this upset about being lynched?

What do you mean about Elmo? I thought he wanted a dead Shanba for Christmas.

No. I'm not upset over being lynched. I'm upset over being lynched for

no reason whatsoever

.

*sigh* as much as I feel Elmo is scum, at least he

has

a reason for his vote.

Unvote, vote: Sikario

I have a feeling I know what you're going to say next, so I'll respond now; It's not OMGUS if there's a reason behind it.

[JDodge]

Little bit overcrowded by work. Will post later or tomorrow.

Mod: When's the deadline?

Reading the rules is fun.

[JDodge]

No. I'm not upset over being lynched. I'm upset over being lynched for

no reason whatsoever

.

yeah, because not giving reasons is scummy

oh wait

There's a difference between not giving reasons and openly admitting you have no reason.

[JDodge]

To keep from being deadline lynched, couldn't you switch your vote to someone else so that they'd have as much as you?

For example:

unvote JDodge
vote wank

So now you and wank have the same amount of votes. There's only a 50% chance that you'd die.

I don't think wank is scum. I'm not going to vote someone with equal votes just to save myself if I don't think said person is scum.

[JDodge]

Since it looks increasingly like I will be lynched at the end of the day, let the record state that I'm pretty sure Elmo, Glork and Patrick are scum.

If I'm wrong on Patrick, my next choice would be Shanba.

Just a few final words. Sikario looks less scummy after metagame research that dictates he always acts like a complete idiot.

Unvote, vote: Elmo

[JDodge]

Double OMGUS + Patrick, eh?


You should try busing Patrick instead.

Chalk it up to OMGUS if you want; I've given my reason for Elmo, and clearly you haven't read Patrick's posts.

[JDodge]

Now I don't definetly like JD's reaction

UNVOTE, Vote: JDodge

Interesting; to be entirely honest, I do not feel it is OMGUS that I am using. I feel that my wagon is scum-driven based on how it materialized out of nowhere with no reason whatsoever.

[JDodge]

I feel that my wagon is scum-driven based on how it materialized out of nowhere with no reason whatsoever.

You may not agree with my reasoning for voting for you but you can't claim that I didn't provide it.

I have no problem with your vote, or Andy's for that matter. I have a problem with Elmo's, Glork's and Sikario's votes.

[JDodge]

Since it looks increasingly like I will be lynched at the end of the day, let the record state that I'm pretty sure Elmo, Glork and Patrick are scum.

If I'm wrong on Patrick, my next choice would be Shanba.

Just a few final words. Sikario looks less scummy after metagame research that dictates he always acts like a complete idiot.

Unvote, vote: Elmo

mmhmmmhmmm?