Mafia 70: Traditional - Game over!

[Flare]

Flare is alive and making another promise. ._.

Will try to do a reread this weekend, and post.

[Lemming1607]

I investigated Toaster. I got innocent.

Isn't that a pickle.

[Lemming1607]

Lemming... why

are

you not claiming your results?

because I asked before I claimed and people said Toaster should go first so I decided to wait till toaster claimed.

[Lemming1607]

I have a guilty, so I think I should go last. It's going to rush the day, and reduce the amount of information we gather from it.

With two cops (and maybe more), I think it's imperative that we be cautious and sort out special mechanics/sanities before acting out. Since the result was "guilty" - the scum might jump on it. This, regardless or Lemming's credibility, or mine, I think that it would be best if I were to go second.

Did anyone else notice these two posts completely contradict each other?

The first one implies that the town would lynch TS' guilty result, and the second is urging us not to.

[Lemming1607]

I have a guilty, so I think I should go last. It's going to rush the day, and reduce the amount of information we gather from it.

With two cops (and maybe more), I think it's imperative that we be cautious and sort out special mechanics/sanities before acting out. Since the result was "guilty" - the scum might jump on it. This, regardless or Lemming's credibility, or mine, I think that it would be best if I were to go second.

Did anyone else notice these two post's tone contradict each other?

The first one says the day will be short, implying for us to lynch the guilty result, and the second is urging us not to.

I messed up the meaning of what I meant. It was tone not what he said. Edit by way of post

[SomeStrangeSimenon]

so either lemming is scum, ts is a godfather, or lemming-ts is an insane sane cop pair.

[Sir Tornado]

Also for the record, that was the main reason I FoS'd MoS yesterday. The fact that he came out with the possibility of multiple cops so early is odd to me. Multiple cops in a game is pretty broken unless they have different sanities, making it a sort of mini dethy, or the scum has some crazy roles to balance.

Or maybe there's something in the game that heavily balances multiple cops.

Or occam's razor and Toaster is lying

I investigated Toaster. I got innocent.

Isn't that a pickle.

Vote Lemming

[Erg0]

Yeah, I thought that was weird too. Explain, Lemming?

[Patrick]

Votecount

Battle Mage (3) -- Erg0, Mastermind of Sin, KaleiÐoscøpe
Mastermind of Sin (1) -- Niv
Lemming1607 (2) -- ZONEACE, Sir Tornado
KaleiÐoscøpe (1) -- Simenon

Not voting: Aimee, Toaster Strudel, The Fonz, JDodge, Ether, Yamahako, Lemming1607, Battle Mage, Setael, Flare, Beastly, Bookitty
19 alive, 10 to lynch.

[Sir Tornado]

Meh,

unvote

This gets even more ridiculous now...

I have a guilty, so I think I should go last. It's going to rush the day, and reduce the amount of information we gather from it.

With two cops (and maybe more), I think it's imperative that we be cautious and sort out special mechanics/sanities before acting out. Since the result was "guilty" - the scum might jump on it. This, regardless or Lemming's credibility, or mine, I think that it would be best if I were to go second.

Why have you hinted that the lemming is scum, and implied he be lynched quickly when you know that there is a possibility of having different cop sanities?

Both Lemming and TS can't be scum, but I just can't decide which of them looks more scummy at the moment.

[Lemming1607]

Sir Tornado picked up on what I was talking about.

Also I didn't want to reveal that I got Toaster was innocent unless I had to. There's just this thing in the back of my mind that he might still be scum and we were about to lynch the godfather on day 1. I figured if I didn't give my results I might live a little bit longer to get more results.

Or he could be telling the truth and is also a cop.

[Lemming1607]

Yeah, I thought that was weird too. Explain, Lemming?

Well, since I didn't want to unvote Toaster all day yesterday after he claimed, and only did at the last minute in the hopes of someone I found scummy would be lynched, and then didn't IMMEDIATELY vote Toaster today should be some kind of indication that I got an innocent result on toaster, who I found way more controversial than MoS.

So now I'm talking about MoS being scummy...how is that contradicting?

[Yamahako]

Both Lemming and TS can't be scum.

Why not?

[Setael]

The most obvious answer is that lemming is a real cop and TS is an insane cop. That would fit both their results. I think we should wait and let them both investigate again tonight, with the understanding that lemming's results are probably the only ones that can be trusted.

On to scumhunting. Is SomeStrangeSimenon an alt for Simenon? I need to reread.

[Erg0]

Yeah, I thought that was weird too. Explain, Lemming?

Well, since I didn't want to unvote Toaster all day yesterday after he claimed, and only did at the last minute in the hopes of someone I found scummy would be lynched, and then didn't IMMEDIATELY vote Toaster today should be some kind of indication that I got an innocent result on toaster, who I found way more controversial than MoS.

So now I'm talking about MoS being scummy...how is that contradicting?

Well, you're calling MoS scummy for raising the idea that there are two cops, but if you're telling the truth about being a cop then your result would seem to indicate that there

are

two cops (since you got an innocent on the other claimed cop).

At the start of day 2 you still seemed to think that you were the only cop, whilst at the same time having an innocent result on TS. That doesn't make sense to me.

[Erg0]

While I'm talking to the cops...

I have a guilty, so I think I should go last. It's going to rush the day, and reduce the amount of information we gather from it.

TS: Did you really think that Lemming could have been quicklynched based on your guilty result?

[The Fonz]

Guys- at this point, a claim from me is unavoidable.

I am a tracker. I followed TS last night, and TS performed no night action.

[ZONEACE]

so then lemming is the insane cop?

[ZONEACE]

or ts is the godfather?

[The Fonz]

Possibilities:

1. Lemming is insane or naive
2. TS is Godfather
3. Both are scum (unlikely)

[Erg0]

Well TS obviously isn't a cop if she didn't do anything. We'll get the answer on the other question once we lynch her.

Unvote, Vote: Toaster Strudel

[The Fonz]

Oh, and

vote: Toaster Strudel

, obviously.

[Simenon]

Did I not called it?

ah called it ah called it.

Unvote
Vote Toaster Strudel

[Simenon]

By the way, we are lynching one of Zoneace and SirT tomorrow. Preferably ZONEACE

[The Fonz]

In a big game like this, where multiple cops are often encountered, a player is better off discretely

investigating

a cop claimant the next night, rather than outing himself with a counterclaim during the day.

THIS post makes me think GF.