Spoiler: Robbnva
Town, loud and grating town, but town nonetheless. I did not like what he has been doing post 367 onwards. In fact post 288 and 364 makes me think that this whole deal is all about personal vendettas and little to do with the game. I have not played enough games here to get a full view of Mafiascum’s meta, but if post 440 is true then I think I get where Robbnva’s frustration is coming from. Not that I’m excusing his actions as okay since this countdown thing is anti-town too. Anyways I have strong town lean on Robbnva because I’ve never seen a scum play this self destructively on D1 before, and I guess gut reasons too.
Spoiler: Elyse
Has been alright, she makes good posts and I haven’t seen any reason to suspect her. Town lean.
Spoiler: Blankface
Blankface: Aside from agreeing with him on the drama I don’t really have anything positive to say for him. He has been pretty absent, and his posts up to 390 have been pretty lazy, and uninteresting. It took being voted by Elyse to kick him into action. I am interested to see what he does now that he seems to be making real moves. Null read, but could easily swing scum.
Spoiler: Cmitc1
I get he is new, but I am really not getting town vibes from this guy. I don’t like posts 58, 106, and I really dislike 118. He has no posts with strong town intent. His pressure vote on Vedith is just a pressure vote and means very little. The rest of his posts really do not have anything to do with the game state, and he is not making very many stances. I am definitely leaning scum on this slot.
If Cmitc1 really uses RQS in his case to lynch me I am gonna laugh. Because that is a dumb reason to suspect somebody of being scum. Why not suspect any of the people for making RVS votes? It’s the same deal. The other complaint he put against me, inactivity, is also amusing since he has not been any more active then I have. Any explanation why wanting to employ RQS makes me scummy?
If Cmitc1 really uses RQS in his case to lynch me I am gonna laugh. Because that is a dumb reason to suspect somebody of being scum. Why not suspect any of the people for making RVS votes? It’s the same deal. The other complaint he put against me, inactivity, is also amusing since he has not been any more active then I have. Any explanation why wanting to employ RQS makes me scummy?
Spoiler: Vedith
His questioning in posts 47, and 178 left a bad taste in my mouth. Also recent post 515 is weird, and I’m not sure what to make of it. He made the stance that Hoopla is scum, I’d like to see him elaborate further on that. Mainly so I can get a better idea of his thought process. Right now I’m leaning scum.
Spoiler: Wake88
I wasn’t sure have to think about this guy at first due to his absence, but I do like how he tried reasoning with Robbnva, and House. I also agree with his post at 501 so much, and share his feeling on House. I read him as null, but I want to town read him.
Spoiler: Hoopla
Initial gut town read. Not entire sure where I stand on her now though. Nothing seems to be standing out to me at the moment.
Spoiler: BBmolla
I’m not a fan of how he has been playing D1. It’s just that posts 166-171 looks really town to me. If I were scum I’d never use so much Meta and AtE as defense so early, since it could weaken credibility into future games to do it as scum here. Would like him to do something other than defend himself in future though.
Spoiler: House
I know people aren’t going to take me seriously on the RQS questions, but he did fail them.
There are other things too that he did that I could see a great deal of scum motivation behind. First and foremost is his interaction with Robbnva. Considering that House has previous experience with Rob he should have known that what a short fuse Rob has. Therefore I can’t understand why a town!House would berate Rob so, there is nothing town could gain from it. Subtract House from the picture, and I sincerely doubt that things with Robanva would have escalated as much as they did. It looks to me like House counted on Rob to be mod killed.
Then Houses interactions with Wake look really bad. Imo Wake was very reasonable in his approach to House, but House remained stand offish the whole time. This seemed to set off some flags to Wake, as noted in post 501, and House’s reaction was to scum read Wake in post 541.
Lastly is House doggedly defending Molla for no apparent reason. I guess he was town reading him sure, but rereading trough the game I swear the House jumped to Molla’s defense MORE than Molla did, which bothers me. Mainly because Molla is a grown man who can speak for himself. The fact that BBmolla is widely town read makes me think that House’s hard defense of Molla is for town cred.
So yeah, I think House is scum lord. You all should lynch him.
There are other things too that he did that I could see a great deal of scum motivation behind. First and foremost is his interaction with Robbnva. Considering that House has previous experience with Rob he should have known that what a short fuse Rob has. Therefore I can’t understand why a town!House would berate Rob so, there is nothing town could gain from it. Subtract House from the picture, and I sincerely doubt that things with Robanva would have escalated as much as they did. It looks to me like House counted on Rob to be mod killed.
Then Houses interactions with Wake look really bad. Imo Wake was very reasonable in his approach to House, but House remained stand offish the whole time. This seemed to set off some flags to Wake, as noted in post 501, and House’s reaction was to scum read Wake in post 541.
Lastly is House doggedly defending Molla for no apparent reason. I guess he was town reading him sure, but rereading trough the game I swear the House jumped to Molla’s defense MORE than Molla did, which bothers me. Mainly because Molla is a grown man who can speak for himself. The fact that BBmolla is widely town read makes me think that House’s hard defense of Molla is for town cred.
So yeah, I think House is scum lord. You all should lynch him.
Spoiler: Masquerade
Masquerade: I wasn’t feeling very good about this slot at first, but at this point they’re a pretty flat null. But hey, that’s better then being scum read right? 
Spoiler: Egg
Egg is a nice poster, and I’d like to town read him, however I’m thinking that this is typical Egg posting ablates, so I should count him up to be a null. Maybe null leaning town then.
Spoiler: ChaosOmega
Chaos hasn’t been very active yet, so null read.
Basically:
Robbnva, Elyse, BBMolla,
Wake88, Hoopla, Egg, Masquerade, ChaosOmega, Blankface,
Vedith, Cmitc1, House
