Mini Normal 1809: Game Over

[House]

"BB was caught in a lie, he's caughtscum"

In your experience, is this just as relevant for experienced scum as it is for newb scum in early d1?

I have him the benefit of doubt because my memory is shit and I get crap wrong as town that I'm then pressured as scum for, myself.

EBWOP

[Wake1]

I don't really think it's a matter of 'no one feels that way.' Personally I'm curious myself, and am open to listening to you, and considering your thoughts. The moral of the story I feel is that maybe it's not a good idea to assume no one feels this way or that, because they might feel the other way.

And, frankly, I really don't like Vedith's two latter questions he asked you. The way he asked them felt like they were loaded.

[Robbnva]

So since molla isn't mason. Can we lynch him now?

[Masquerade]

Context in quotes, spoilered for readability.
@Chaos:

Spoiler:

VOTE: Masquerade

Nothing to comment on so far?

cmitc: What/how much experience do you have with mafia elsewhere?

I probably had but I was in a hurry so I didn't.

And now that there's more time for you to clarify, you don't. Well that's useful.

I didn't feel the need to comment on the mason-claiming stuff because I figured it wasn't serious, and at the same time could produce telling reactions from people who did take it seriously. I didn't take issue with Robb vs Elyse because I've seen this happen before during rvs and sometimes it's overeager town and sometimes it's opportunistic scum. Making it effectively null here. Robb and Elyse both struck me as town at the time, but both haven't done enough to live up to that early impression so far.

Spoiler:

100 Grendel entrance post. There's plenty already to comment on, why try RQS instead of just reading the previous 4 pages?

Seems hypocritical to push someone for not commenting on the previous pages when your entrance post didn't comment on the previous pages, either.
You came into the game where there was already a discussion happening, and you posted no content and voted a player who hadn't posted yet or had any votes on them. It screams like you wanted to fade into the background.

The rest of your post is a wishy-washy analysis of Hoopla and other not useful things.

I barely had time when I made my entrance post and just quickly made a random vote for ego after I skimmed the first page. Grendel had time to post his RQS but didn't comment on anything in the gamestate and singles one player out to ask them about the gamestate, which means he's aware of there being such a thing as a gamestate that needs talking about. Which he didn't and still has barely done.
Do you expect me to have strong reads 24-48 hours into the game?

Spoiler:

For now I still like my vote where it is

I'm hurt, truly.

Your only comment about me in your post is agreeing with House's post 54. Post for reference:

penny for your thoughts house

I just thought the supposedly inconsequential correction might have actually been maybe not so inconsequential.

Why edit "ya," out when it's common to say stuff like, "ya, I have experience elsewhere"?

Nothing to really push on, on its own. Just... interesting, and makes me want to watch both Chaos and cmitc.

Please explain why you agree with his post that both of us should be watched due to our exchange from 49 to 51.

Also, who is your biggest scumread in the game that isn't me?

Because it was odd? And at that point I wasn't particularly townreading cmitc.
Vedith. Besides that bad question I miss his joking/fluffy attitude/playstyle.

[Masquerade]

So since molla isn't mason. Can we lynch him now?

Can you remind me of why you want to lynch Molla?

[Robbnva]

Why do people typically want to lynch people?

[Masquerade]

My apologies.
Why do you scumread Molla again?

[Robbnva]

Oh mostly gut plus haven't really seen any protown posts from him.

[House]

The best way I've found to scumhunt is to treat anybody Robb is scumreading as an IC.

[Robbnva]

Not a bad idea actually. So maybe I should town read the people I'm scum reading and scum read the people
I'm town reading and I can find scum?

[Robbnva]

Yeah let's try that

vote: hoopla

[BBmolla]

Cool hoopla is town

[BBmolla]

Oh wait I double reversed it

[Robbnva]

You're lucky people like you

[House]

You're lucky people like you

Is that envy I detect?

[Robbnva]

No disgust cause he's probably scum and we will lose the game cause of it

[BBmolla]

consider it a compliment that I think your reads are so horrid that I don't think you feasibly be this bad as town

[Robbnva]

consider it a compliment that I think your reads are so horrid that I don't think you feasibly be this bad as town

Except I'm not bad and I don't think I'm playing bad.


You falsely accuse someone of asking for a day 1 mass claim
You go and actually ask for one
Then you deny you did and still try to say somebody else did it.

That comes from scum or a bad player and I don't think you are a bad player so it has to be that you are scum.

[BBmolla]

ignore that last post sorry >.<

[BBmolla]

I just got mixed up, I admitted my mistake, not much else I can do there.

[BBmolla]

You falsely accuse someone of asking for a day 1 mass claim
You go and actually ask for one
Then you deny you did and still try to say somebody else did it.

My sense of humor is that of being really ironic

Me and House are fake claiming masons

I think someone is suggesting a mass claim, misunderstanding because I'm a low effort poster who doesn't double check anything

I suggest a massclaim and claim mason and pass it on to House who I know will claim Mason and stop or pass it on jokingly or whatever

you're making a mountain out of an anthill. you're also under the impression that misunderstanding something is scum which is just wrong. you seem to have this thought that if a player isn't perfect with their fact and post checking they're scum when in reality its laziness

[BBmolla]

mafia isn't a game of absolutes.

[Robbnva]

Yeah I don't buy that excuse and your attempts to discredit me aren't appreciated. Now ive vowed to stop tunneling in games but I'm making the exception this time. I'm not going to move my vote off you until you are lynched or confirmed town by the mod himself.

Your entire iso is scummy.

Buh bye

[House]

mafia isn't a game of absolutes.

Enjoying talking to a bra l brick

head

wall?

[House]

mafia isn't a game of absolutes.

Enjoying talking to a brick

head

wall?

Fail post is fail.

EBWOP