New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[RachMarie]

Could someone explain to me with 2 scum flips and all why we are popcorn claiming?

[RachMarie]

Do you think it is MYLO now Perf? Because I think claiming gives scum an advantage otherwise.

[Killthestory]

i kind of just want to lynch hebi and see where we go from there.
perf is probs town with slandaar. slandaar is town.

aaa theres too much probable scum this is scary

[Killthestory]

everyone give their reads rn

like literally rn please give your reads

or at least give your top 3 town, top 3 scum

[hebichan]

top three town

kts, performer, slandaar

top three scum

SS, Firebringer, KAAG slot

[Something_Smart]

(aside from KTS obviously)
Performer, DGB, Nero

hebichan, Dominator, Slandaar

[RachMarie]

@ Kill

Slan, you, DGB

not so strong on heb and Perf, and nero

just

replaced in, need more from him, usually though with some time, I can peg him.

Fire is my strongest scum read, not as sold as DGB and slan on the revolving door slot that is now dominator, though if it comes to deadline he would be better than a NL, but I would like to see some activity from this slot first, so far we have had almost nothing from it.

[Nero Cain]

@Nero were you speaking of the themed game with Fire, BBT as Town 2-shot Bp , Titus; and GL, Thor, and massive scum? (I may not be fully recalling the details correctly but I'm curious of the meta you spoke of for Fire)

maybe...i dunno. I just remember a post from him that he made after the game that was along the lines of "yea when I put effort in I'm scum." Its WIFOM and I've seen this whole I've given up on the game from both town and scum. And he's a better lynch than lynching a flake slot.

+

with an SK in play (I'm assuming 1 of the 3 kills from night 3 was an SK until more information.) I could see Fire playing to his town "meta" to coast by.

I am proposing a mass claim in the form of popcorn, starting with KAAG slot. I will claim last.

not today.

I like Performer's idea

What makes you like the idea?

Did you ISO your predecessor?

I did, I found myself not agreeing with him a lot.

amished tell?

My town reads are prob kill, Rach and SS while my scum reads are Fire, Slan and maybe Hebi.

[DrippingGoofball]

Hebichan is scum.

[Nero Cain]

either vote Fire with me, start a Hebi wagon or explain why the Dom slot is scum WITHOUT referring to Dom's "lurking". I think its null.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm not voting Fire

[Firebringer]

Can we lynch the empty slot thats been replaced 30 times?

[Slandaar]

not as sold as DGB and slan on the revolving door slot that is now dominator

I was joking about 'must be scum'. I do think the slot has a good chance of scum though based on the reasoning in 2309 (if you actually go and reread the part of the game I am talking about you will see what I mean).

I also don't see many slots left who have potential to be scum.

4. Killthestory - No
7. Performer - No
9. hebichan - Possible but Nah
11. Firebringer - Really Don't think so
12. RachMarie - Really Don't think so
15. Slandaar -
16. Reverie - Probable
18. DrippingGoofball - Really Don't think so
19. KickAssAndGiggle - Probable
21. Something_Smart - Possible but Don't think so

I like the Dominator wagon.

----------

I didn't think massclaim was optimal earlier in the day with just KTS claimed but it depends on you, Performer, I don't think it can be bad either so eh.

[Something_Smart]

9. hebichan - Possible but Nah

Explain.

12. RachMarie - Really Don't think so

Explain.

19. KickAssAndGiggle - Probable

Explain.

[Axl_Rose]

Prodding TheDominator37, he has 24 hours to post before I seek a replacement

[Performer]

Could someone explain to me with 2 scum flips and all why we are popcorn claiming?

Do you think it is MYLO now Perf? Because I think claiming gives scum an advantage otherwise.

I think in worst case with 2 scum and 1 SK remaining, that this is MYLO. In the event of my death tonight, then I thought we stood a better chance if we did the mass claim popcorn. Based on most people's suggestions, it doesn't look like the optimal idea so I will shelf it.

either vote Fire with me, start a Hebi wagon or explain why the Dom slot is scum WITHOUT referring to Dom's "lurking". I think its null.

Recently explained by 2787 , which is convincing. Also did another ISO of the 3 predecessors, including jam, Yume, and Reverie. If there is actually 1 scum and 1 SK remaining instead, that slot might be the SK - based on the "NOW DIE SCUM" post by jam. The rest of the posts in the short ISOs, don't contribute much substance.

VOTE: TheDominator

[Performer]

I have a top 2 scumreads right now:

TheDom & Nero slot

I had

Fire

as town but his suicidal demeanor in the recent pages, looked anti town. "Didn't replace out b/c there have been so many replacements but I give up on this game" - doesn't look involved. I put him as null for now, along with

Rach & Drip.

For top 3 townreads, right now they're

KTS, Slandaar, SS. I also townread hebi.

[Performer]

People's reads so far

Drip - t on fire ; s on hebi
kts - t on perf/sland; s on hebi
heb - t on kts/perf/slan; s on ss, fire, kaag
ss - t on perf/drip/nero; s on heb, dom, sland
rach - t slan, kts, drip; s on fire,
fire - s on domi
nero - t on kts, rach, ss; s on fire, slan, heb
sland - s on kaag/domi
---

6-24-16 is d5 deadline & the most recent vc is below:

Killthestory -
Performer - Killthestory
hebichan - SS
Firebringer - hebi, rach, nero
Rachmarie -
Slandaar -
yume/reverie/Dominator37 - fire, Drip, Slandaar, perf
DrippingGoofball -
nero/KickAssAndGiggle -
Something_Smart

Not Voting - dominator

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
---

forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=65280&f=56&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&user_select[]=12589&user_select[]=0&user_select[]=0&user_sort=Go

link to nero cain's town meta, for anyone interested
after digging through several pages of his meta, I haven't found a scum game of his so far but that is what I found so far

[hebichan]

While as a vanilla townie in a game that is almost all replacements and it not in lylo, I have no problem being lynched, I still would prefer a fire lynch here.

I feel like fire is just playing everyone with the roll over and die claim.

That is my thoughts.

The reason I like claiming here is because people claimed to have roles that proved them townies and explained there plays, I would love to narrow down my reads more precisely.

Also if the dominator train has enough support I will switch there.

[RachMarie]

uggh not completely convinced that slot is scum but uggh it definitely has had the most horrid luck with replacements.

Sigh I would rather lynch someone whom I feel is scum, Slan and DGB, but meh if we have to get yet another replacement who immediately flakes out, or deadline I will join you. This is getting ridiculous, however, I hate the fact we will have zero info to speak of if it turns out that slot is town and not scum like ya all think, however, don't want a slot like that in LYLO or MYLO either.

[Something_Smart]

Why do you feel DGB is scum?

[Nero Cain]

People's reads so far

Drip - t on fire ; s on hebi
kts - t on perf/sland; s on hebi
heb - t on kts/perf/slan; s on ss, fire, kaag
ss - t on perf/drip/nero; s on heb, dom, sland
rach - t slan, kts, drip; s on fire,
fire - s on domi
nero - t on kts, rach, ss; s on fire, slan, heb
sland - s on kaag/domi
---

6-24-16 is d5 deadline & the most recent vc is below:

Killthestory -
Performer - Killthestory
hebichan - SS
Firebringer - hebi, rach, nero
Rachmarie -
Slandaar -
yume/reverie/Dominator37 - fire, Drip, Slandaar, perf
DrippingGoofball -
nero/KickAssAndGiggle -
Something_Smart

Not Voting - dominator

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
---

forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=65280&f=56&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&user_select[]=12589&user_select[]=0&user_select[]=0&user_sort=Go

link to nero cain's town meta, for anyone interested
after digging through several pages of his meta, I haven't found a scum game of his so far but that is what I found so far

OMGUS and all but this post is very IIOAy

[RachMarie]

Nero is passionate and actively involved when he is town, and tend to be more lurky and non involved when he is scum, It is a bit more complicated than that, but that is the jist of it.

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: TheDominator

[RachMarie]

umm DGB .... You were already voting him